Today's Newspaper

In paper Magazine
ad_head
Waziristan war zone conditions worry aid workers

Tuesday, 03 Nov, 2009
font-size small font-size largefont-sizeprintemail share
‘I would be hesitant to take the Pakistan military’s word on anything,’ said Hasan of HRW. Without independent monitoring, ‘how do we know that 400 tons of rations has actually got to the civilians?’ —AFP Photo

ISLAMABAD: Rising numbers of civilians are pouring out of Pakistan’s war zone to flee battles between soldiers and Taliban militants but the fate of those left behind is uncertain, humanitarian workers say.

‘How much civilians are affected, we don’t know, and for that we need access,’ said Billi Bierling, spokeswoman for the UN’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in Pakistan.

Up to 250,000 people have fled the military’s major offensive, now into a third week in South Waziristan on the Afghan border, said Lieutenant General Nadeem Ahmad, chief of the state-run agency handling the displaced.

But no one knows the exact number of displaced people or those left in the conflict zone because foreign aid workers have not been able to enter the areas, the humanitarian workers say.

‘We... know that there are still civilians trapped in the areas where fighting’s taking place,’ said Sebastien Brack, spokesman for the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in Pakistan.

Normally about 300,000 people live in the part of South Waziristan which the military is seeking to clear of terrorists.

The military said that only one to two per cent of the population remained in the conflict zone.

‘These are people who have stayed back to take care of their properties,’ Ahmad told AFP.

But the ICRC that warned the numbers were likely higher because others could not afford the ‘extortionate’ rates charged by people offering transport for those fleeing.

‘The people who are left behind are often the poorest of the poor,’ he said.

Like aid workers, reporters usually have no access to the conflict area, where communication lines are down.

A correspondent briefly invited by the military into areas of South Waziristan under its control on Sunday saw no civilians.

Brack said the ICRC had tried unsuccessfully to gain access to South Waziristan to assist victims of fighting and to visit detainees, in accordance with its mandate.

US-based Human Rights Watch has urged Pakistan to ensure that sufficient supplies reach trapped civilians, warning of it humanitarian law, it said.

Although ICRC has no staff in the area, it has for months been sending medical supplies to assist eight clinics in Waziristan, Brack said.

Those clinics are each treating two to three patients injured in the fighting each day, he said, but ‘it’s getting more and more difficult to get medicine to them’.

Ahmad said more than 400 tons of army rations had been allocated for people still in the area of military operations.

‘I would be hesitant to take the Pakistan military’s word on anything,’ said Hasan of HRW. Without independent monitoring, ‘how do we know that 400 tons of rations has actually got to the civilians?’

Those escaping the fighting have migrated to the north-western towns of Dera Ismail Khan and Tank where they are staying with relatives, friends, host families or in rented houses, Ahmad said.

The United Nations has no international staff in those towns but is working through local partners to distribute food, blankets and other essentials.

‘We are certainly meeting the needs of the people who have arrived in Dera Ismail Khan and Tank,’ while the UN negotiates with the government to allow its expatriate staff to join the emergency relief effort, Bierling said.

The government says it does not want international organisations in the area because of concerns for their safety.

The United Nations on Monday said it was pulling out non-essential international staff from North West Frontier Province because of what it called ‘the intense security situation’.


Tags: waziristan operation,aid workers,wfp,undp,unhcr
font-size small font-size largefont-size printemail share
HIGHLIGHTS
  • When more is less
    Pakistan’s birth rate is roughly 20 per cent higher than India’s, and exceeds that of Bangladesh: Khakwani.
  • The path of corruption
    Eventually, as is well known, the NAB process itself was corrupted and used for political purposes: Burki.


advertisement