FOR two sects united by their belief in one Maker, one Book and one Prophet, the amount of blood spilt in the name of their respective faiths by Shias and Sunnis is truly staggering. This is specially so when one considers the tiny differences that define and divide them.

Since the earliest days of Islam in the 7th century when the schism first tore the young Muslim community apart, the two sects have been warring incessantly. Untold thousands have been killed over the years, and this internecine war continues to devastate communities and nations.

I am not qualified to go into the rights and wrongs of this old conflict. However, as a student of history, I can think of no other single cause of disunity among Muslims as this corrosive, centuries-old struggle. Other religions have gone through periods of sectarian violence: witness the bloody religious wars that Catholics and Protestants fought in Europe.

But while these tensions have mostly died down with the slaking of religious passions among most Christians, Muslims continue to fight over whose version is the true Islam. Indeed, much of Islamic history is written in the bloodshed either over succession, or in sectarian wars.

First, Ottoman rule across large parts of the Arab world held Shia-Sunni violence in check, even though in many provinces, Shias were subjected to discrimination. But as this vast area was controlled from Constantinople, open warfare was rare. Then, in the post-Ottoman, colonial era in the last century, European powers largely prevented Shia-Sunni tensions from breaking into hostility.

In the last half of the 20th century, after the departure of colonial forces, many Muslim countries were ruled by secular dictators who, for all their many faults, kept the lid on these ancient sectarian tensions. From Saddam Hussein of Iraq, to Muammar Qadhafi of Libya, to the Assads of Syria, and to Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, violence between the sects was kept at a minimum.

Nevertheless, the ruling sect did marginalise the other: thus, the majority Shias under the Sunni Saddam fared badly. Now the shoe is on the other foot, and it is the minority Sunnis under the Shia heel. In Syria, the minority Alewites have ruled since the Seventies. In Sunni Saudi Arabia, the Shias are marginalised.

The list goes on, but one thing is clear: both sects harbour deep distrust of each other. Indeed, in a recent Pew Institute survey on attitudes in the Muslim world, only 53 per cent of those surveyed in Pakistan considered Shias to be Muslims. This figure is even lower in several other Muslim countries.

There is similar doubt on the other side, with many Shias casting doubt on Sunni beliefs. So clearly, time has only sharpened this schism, rather than healing old wounds. But while more often than not, these tensions are limited to neighbourhoods and nations, the emergence of a Shia theocracy in Iran has taken these differences to a new level.

Although mediaeval Islam saw states engaging in sectarian warfare, this tendency was later suppressed in modern times, as we have just discussed. However, although the Iran-Iraq war was fought over territorial claims and counter-claims, overtly sectarian symbolism was deployed by both sides.

And when the Americans invaded Iraq in 2003, the ruling Baath Party was ousted, and the minority Sunnis displaced from power. This led to a Shia revival, and a major gain in Iranian influence. Indeed, the US-led campaign was widely viewed in the Middle East as having enhanced Iranian power across the region.With friendly Shia governments in Iraq and Syria, Iran could easily send arms to Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in Gaza. Together with its nuclear aspirations, the Iran of the ayatollahs sent alarm bells ringing in Sunni capitals in the region.

Thus, when the Arab Spring reached Syria a couple of years ago, protestors were supported by Sunni Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Qatar. And seeing an opportunity to cut a hostile Iran down to size, western powers have now thrown their weight behind the anti-Assad forces.

But supporting Sunni fighters is proving tricky, given the penetration of the Syrian opposition by Salafi groups that have flooded into the country. Indeed, they are proving to be the most effective and organised among all those currently trying to overthrow their Alewite rulers. The presence of these extremists has made western powers wary of supplying them with lethal anti-aircraft missiles. The fear is that these weapons could be turned against Israeli and western aircraft.

Both Iran and Hezbollah are doing their best to keep the tottering Assad regime in power. They know that a hostile, Sunni-dominated government in Damascus would make life difficult for both of them. Increasingly, the secular Syrian resistance is being sidelined by extremist forces.

The real danger is that Syria will fragment along sectarian and ethnic lines. This would cause chaos in the region, with the spill-over being specially lethal for Lebanon, a country delicately poised over several religious and sectarian fault-lines. Although the great sectarian divide is now playing out in the geopolitical arena, violence between Shias and Sunnis is becoming increasingly bloody in countries like Pakistan. In the subcontinent, the two communities have lived peacefully side by side for centuries. Even though there were occasional clashes at Ashura, there was little of the organised killings that are taking place with sickening regularity in Pakistan today.


Comments are closed.

Comments (97)

K.Rashid
March 5, 2013 9:59 pm
Yes, and God created all men equal. God does not ask for man to kill his fellow human beings- rather to serve each other with humility and kindness irrespective of race, religion and color. If we do not or cannot understand this, then shame on us. At least I hang my head in shame and despair. May God show us the straight path.
Sonu
March 5, 2013 9:38 pm
Stop blaming others. No wonder you guys are regressing !!!
AHA
March 5, 2013 7:41 pm
Intolerance is the only thing we have been preaching for the last as many years a I can remember. And now we are being rewarded for our hard work.
AHA
March 5, 2013 7:38 pm
With your line of reasoning, we will never be able to address our problems. The problems lies with us and within us, squarely.
Jim
March 5, 2013 7:19 pm
If you call for secularism then you agree that the country's name shouldn't be "The Islamic Republic of Pakistan" or "The Islamic Republic of Iran" etc. but just Republic of Pakistan?
Ahmed j
March 5, 2013 6:58 pm
I don't know why this surah Imran (3:151) is quoted here. The revelation time was when muslims were defeated in the Battle of Uhad. You should have explained in what context this verse is used here. There is a meaning and reason for the surah and addresses a particular community at that time. The problem with us Muslims is that verses are quoted in parts, only where it suits our ideas without knowing the full real reason and background. Please even now you can explain with what meaning you have taken the verse.
AKN
March 5, 2013 5:42 pm
One should not allow themselves to be DIVIDED and RULED.
excalibur
March 5, 2013 5:24 pm
I Challenge any fair minded Muslim to hear what Javed Ahmad Ghamidi has to say on the issue of Shia/Sunni in response to a Shia Alims claims incorrectly citing the Quran. Make an honest judgement and see for yourself what is the truth of the matter
NASAH (USA)
March 5, 2013 4:30 pm
What is a "Shia mosque"?
Shubs
March 5, 2013 3:42 pm
But of course...!
Shubs
March 5, 2013 3:36 pm
abbastoronto, you would do yourself some good if you would leave your alternate universe and step into the real world. In the land of "Venerable Mao", the Chinese are hurtling towards western civilization like nobody's business. I don't know when was the last time you visited China, but I'm here now, in the middle of one of their giant, bustling cities. And all one can see around is the unending race to be more American than the Americans, more European than the Europeans themselves, not only in terms of material trappings, but lifestyle, culture, food, clothes, consumerism. And you know what, they have got it right. Because at heart, they are still Chinese. They may be nationalistic, but their lives are not driven by some dogmatic interpretation of some ancient book. They know how to take the best of both worlds. They know that it is a global world. The only one still dreaming about a "clash of civilizations", my friend, is you.
Muslim
March 5, 2013 2:00 pm
We surely should defend for our faith and religion. But defending never means slaughtering and killing innocents. If you think your religion or believe is right educate the people around you by words not by guns. Holy Prophet(pbuh) educated people about Islam. He never picked up a sword against any disbeliever though he faced extreme opposition and persecution. But he forgave all of his enemies and prayed for them. This is what Islam is. Islam is the religion of peace where even the rights of animals are respected. May Allah guides you to the right path Ameen.
Rajeev
March 5, 2013 1:27 pm
The name you are using is that of a radical muslim politician from Hyderabad which shows that you are an Indian enjoying "pouring ghee on the fire". Grow up man!
Rajeev
March 5, 2013 1:21 pm
How can you teach secularism to the people of a country formed on the basis of religious prejudice.
Fuzail Z. Ahmad
March 5, 2013 12:58 pm
Whats wrong with you BRR? Be a sport, dude.
Parvez
March 5, 2013 12:03 pm
Religion by itself is a good thing. The misuse of religion for political, personal and criminal reasons is decidedly not a good thing.............everyone knows this but no one implements it and the blame falls on religion or politics where as the blame lies solidly on human failings.
Kafir Jahaz
March 5, 2013 9:56 am
Dude! Shame on you.
Leo
March 5, 2013 7:14 am
More harm is done by not raising your voice where it is actually required. Very good point!
ronak
March 5, 2013 4:46 am
muslims killing muslims, way to go man.
Shruti
March 5, 2013 4:06 am
That's not true. These people are not killing out of poverty (though I don't see why poor people would murder others). They are killing because they are intolerant. And that is just downright horrible!!
Raj
March 5, 2013 2:59 am
Um! What a pearl of wisdom!
sam
March 5, 2013 2:59 am
Why there are no Shia mosques allowed in Saudi Arabia ? Knowledgeable people please write more details.
AHA
March 5, 2013 2:54 am
Our existence is the proof that God exists. There is no proof for anything else. It is just your belief versus mine.
AHA
March 5, 2013 2:48 am
Excellent comment. Hats off.
AHA
March 5, 2013 2:43 am
Quran (3:151) - "Soon shall We cast terror into the hearts of the Unbelievers, for that they joined companions with Allah, for which He had sent no authority."
Ajaya K Dutt
March 5, 2013 2:36 am
I do not believe in God, whatever kind. If somebody believes, as Mr Akbar ud-din Owaisi said in his comments today, that I should be slaughtered then I know where the evil is. I am not blaming Mr Owaisi, or millions other like him. I curse the root cause. When I sit in meditation, to cope with my own trials and tribulations, I see all those, who perceive me evil because I do not believe in their brand of God; are truly evil.
umesh bhagwat
March 5, 2013 2:06 am
in my opinion,it is politics and not religion which is pitting brother against brother!
SKChadha
March 5, 2013 1:34 am
Probably ..... forgotten the true meaning of universal brotherhood .... ?
Naseer
March 5, 2013 1:18 am
@ Fuzail - Agree 100%. Shias and sunnis are mourning together. It is some extremists / terrorists who do these kind of things.
Affaf Zahid
March 5, 2013 12:43 am
Your ignorance saddens me to no extent. 'tis a shame.
Ahmed
March 4, 2013 11:50 pm
God can take care of Himself. Worry about the mischief done in Pakistan by "pious men" who think killing innocent people will get them a place in heaven.
IndiaUSA
March 4, 2013 11:47 pm
Pakistan should elect Sir Rehman Malik as next Prime Minister...that will solve all it's problems.
Ahmed
March 4, 2013 11:47 pm
shia-sunni is about power too. there is no theological difference between the two sects.
Ahmed
March 4, 2013 11:44 pm
You certainly dont believe in even the slightest of intelligence.
Akil Akhtar
March 4, 2013 11:39 pm
Every muslim country that US has interests in controlling or changing govt in the last ten years is now suffering shia sunni divide and violence even where it did not exist before, be it Libya, Iraq, Syria, Pakistan....Wonder why? but divide and rule policy of the Anglo Saxons comes to mind....
Sohrab
March 4, 2013 11:00 pm
A country created in the name of religion is doomed from the word go. Unfortunately until we throw the two nation theory in the Arabian sea as we did not sink it in the bay of Bengal (how as kids we hated this statement by Indira Gandhi on the partition of Pakistan), nothing will improve. Unfortunately the wrongs of history have to be righted by its own people. Being a minority we were told by our parents not to discuss Islam and Kashmir growing up in Pakistan. I think that was not correct either. If nobody is going to speak up, this is the hell the rest will be doomed to live in. I lost a dear Shia friend and his son in Lahore, just because they were Shia. I refuse to stand by and not let my feelings known. Let us learn from history and put a lid to religion in the business of the state, as was suggested by Jinnah.
PN
March 4, 2013 10:47 pm
Yes, it's that sordid peace after mayhem.
PN
March 4, 2013 10:43 pm
Your concept seems weird. Are you implying that the sectarian Islamic wars, non-stop, since the 7th century, as the author so rightly states, were the product of perpetual hunger? What a load of rubbish!
Waqas
March 4, 2013 10:41 pm
True, there is no evidence to suggest that God exists. However, if he does, he must be pretty sad to see how humans are hating and killing in each other in his name.
Waqas
March 4, 2013 10:35 pm
Its important to keep an eye (and to help the neighbor) if his house is burning, lest the fire might spread to my house.
P
March 4, 2013 10:27 pm
This is a response to Ranjit, Kumar and all other indians who now have a negative view of PAK. IF history serves these guys anything, Pak didn't have violence and killing problem 10 years ago. This instability is coming from Failed adventure of American led war in Afghanistan. Indian politician think that they've greater role to play in afghanistan and now they're gettnig dictation from Washington and some meddling in the internal situation in Pak too. They're dumb not to have improved relation with PAK and try to help each other acheive stability and economic vitalitly for their people. So America is winning by continually creating animosity between two nations. India certainly has become economic power in the region. However; if she wants to become World power, it'll need to reassess it's politics and first thing comes to mind is how we can acheive peace in the region and develop our people regardless of their faith because IF Pak is going through rough time, India too can have similar issues in the future. Just like in the past, Sikh's wanted their own state and Tamil Nadu conflict.
khatun
March 4, 2013 9:28 pm
Whenever a muslim iskilled in India, all mullahs are up in arms. When hundreds die in Pakistan, nobody bats an eyelid. Hypocrites of the highest order.
sana husain
March 4, 2013 8:56 pm
sunnis ar e just as sympathetic about whats happening as shias are about felllow shias being killed. this is the doing of militant groups who have no faith. while i agree they have differences they dont believe in killing each other. i request the author to not mislead the readers with this shia sunni rhetoric. all the sunnis i know condemn the attacks on shias.
Harinder
March 4, 2013 7:46 pm
Muslims need to learn the art of "TOLERANCE"
Vittal Pyati
March 4, 2013 7:33 pm
Karl Marx seem to have said, "Religion is opiate of humanity". How true..If the suicide bombers had been a Hindu or a Christian instead of Sunni blowing up Shiaa assembled in their mosque, the entire Muslim world would have blamed the West or India.
Razzaq
March 4, 2013 7:30 pm
Religion is opium of masses. This has been proved right in the case of Pakistan.
Arun
March 4, 2013 7:03 pm
Bilal... I find it intiguing, Did the killing part pain you or the matter of neighbour made a comment in your national newspaper pained you ? Enlighten please...
Raj
March 4, 2013 6:42 pm
To add if somebody kills you don't blame that as you deserve that.
rahim
March 4, 2013 5:51 pm
This is how you doom yourself, family, neighbors and our country with hatred born out of ignorance. May peace be with you
Akram
March 4, 2013 5:44 pm
The roots of the Shia Sunni conflict can also be traced to political power struggle bewteen the descendants of the Holy Prophet. Its always about political power, seldom anything else.