SHOCK dissipates; pain lingers; and rage will extract its due some time. On Saturday morning, the 23-year-old girl who had been raped by a criminal gang festering with demons on the night of Dec 14, gave up her unconscious struggle for life in a Singapore hospital. Delhi, and perhaps India, fell silent. What was left to say?

What else was left to hear after what we have heard during this fortnight’s public discourse?

The government was bewildered by the paradox that finally shredded its moral roots, if indeed there were any left. The ruling elite thought that tokenism was sufficient as an escape route.

Statistics encouraged such thinking. This was hardly the first rape in Delhi; at least 600 have been reported in 2012 alone. India forgets a thousand rapes a day; why should people get particularly provoked just because this rape happened on a rogue bus running with the support of a deeply corrupt police system that permitted a physically and mentally twisted driver to operate because he had paid police to get his licence?

The general view was that a few speeches in parliament would be more than enough. Strangely, the principal faces of governance, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Congress president Mrs Sonia Gandhi, did not think that they needed to read out a few paragraphs churned out by their speechwriters on that day in parliament. The future of the Congress, Rahul Gandhi, was missing from the present. Nor was he visible on Saturday.

Outside parliament, it was a different space. Women lit a flame of anger that exposed through the clamour of public discourse the truth of what many men in power truly felt. Visceral hatred born from other causes can deform men into rapists by intent.

Perhaps the most unbelievable instance was the case of a former Marxist minister in Bengal, Anisur Rahman, taunting the state’s chief minister Mamata Banerjee in language that cannot be repeated.

Leftists have been sincere guardians of gender equality. They have demanded the maximum punishment for the gang in Delhi. We are waiting to see what punishment they inflict on their former minister.

The ugliest remark came from Andhra Pradesh. This quote is unusual not because it is rare, but because it is rarely expressed in public. The chief of the Andhra Congress is a man called Botsa Satyanarayana. This is what he said about the young victim who has just died: that she “should have been more careful”. He also thought that it was a “minor incident”. Will anything happen to this retarded, obnoxious politician? I doubt it. Make your guess and keep checking the newspapers.

We will know soon enough if this crisis marks the beginning of reform in social justice, or is merely another chapter of tears that dries up the next day as life totters on with nothing learnt.

But here is a suggestion for political parties. Reform begins at home.

They made the right noises when public anguish peaked on Saturday, possibly because they were afraid of a public backlash. From Monday they could do something concrete.

Every political party, whether Congress, the Bharatiya Janata Party, left or regional, has criminal elements including those who have raped. A few of them even rise to elected level. Could they begin with action against them?

All leaders prefer fudge to change. After a week of doing very little, Mrs Sonia Gandhi invited six young people in an effort to calm and reassure the protesters. This group was led into her presence by a minister. A curious thing happened on the way out.

All six refused to identify themselves to the media. Newspapers got their pictures but not their names. Why? Were they from a Congress party forum or from the incensed crowds in the heart of the capital? It did not work. Something fundamental has changed. The ground has shifted.

In December, 2012 changed from yet another ordinary year in a desultory sequence to a swivel moment in India’s history — when women, their identity, their rights, their dignity, became the central issue before the nation.

It was not just one more crime, however awful, that brought young Indians together. It was a scream of anguish against widespread, inhuman and unchecked corruption in every aspect of existence that has turned the citizen into a hapless victim of kleptocracy, with women suffering the more malicious wounds of brutalisation.

The government has dismissed every public protest over the past years with contempt. Anna Hazare was a ‘fraud’. Arvind Kejriwal was a ‘pipsqueak liar’. Ministers competed with each other in becoming more vicious about leaders of popular anger; they laughed and threatened, and were rewarded by Mrs Sonia Gandhi and Dr Singh with better portfolios.

When you are in power, you never hear the volcano rumbling in the belly of the mountain, although fires are licking at the mouth of the crater.

The writer is editor of The Sunday Guardian, published from Delhi, India on Sunday, published from London and editorial director, India Today and Headlines Today.


Comments are closed.

Comments (18)

peer
December 30, 2012 7:08 pm
your correlation of a gurgling sound in the belly to a volcano has reminded me of my childhood, when boiling of water in my grandparents' electric kettle would scare me with the fear of an impending explosion but my grandfather grinned with confidence as he had trust in 'cut off' Gandhi's should not be worried as they are not, bcoz they've confidence in cut off In a country where two women's brutal rape and murder ,half a dozen killings, weeks of complete shut down in kashmir thousands of protesters's injuries (asiya neelofer jan case in kashmir) could not bring justice to the families, you can not expect revolution with a candle light march at indiagate
abbastoronto
December 30, 2012 4:49 pm
In 1976 at work in Montreal the talk with an Algerian colleague turned to Indian movies. Tee hee, tee hee, he grinned, making a suggested gesture of a stiff penis with his arm. He told that the Indian movies were popular with the Arab Sheikhs who used it for titillation. Now 1976 is was Victorian era. This is 2012. The victim had just left the cinema. I would not be surprised if it came out that the rapists had also come out of a movie, and imitated life with art.
vivek
December 30, 2012 3:32 pm
And This does not mean a change in social environment..
Dahij
December 30, 2012 2:44 pm
India's male dominated culture has wrought untold misery on women, and the current leadership is pathetic in the face of challenges. The culture has lost its old values of respecting women, and does not have the civility to see women as humans. The hope was that the younger generation might bring the much needed change, but they seem to lack the zeal of the generation that liberated the country. The generation that followed the liberators will go down in history as the worst. They are only concerned with glorifying themselves and have no clue as to their responsibilities. We can only hope that, by some miracle, the next generation will be more enlightened.
Chanakya
December 30, 2012 2:33 pm
Well they're doing something, and they must be encouraged,not belittled.
Chanakya
December 30, 2012 2:28 pm
Bring out another revolution, NOW.Through out these inhuman rulers out of power, if possible out of the country, restore the good name, peace. prosperity equality and respect of law NOW IS THE TIME,
Ajay Vikram Singh
December 30, 2012 1:00 pm
Under the belly of this rape case, lies the moral corruption in our people and values. How do you end corruption, moral or otherwise? How do u stop people from lying, being cowards & immoral, being corrupt and hypocrite? This is a timeless problem of humanity. We tried to solve it with religion, in the name of God and those same corrupt people misused the name of God most to hurt the humanity further. We tried to solve it with inclusive governance, democratic systems that brought up a liberal, loose system, where the same people misused it thoroughly. Finally, it all boils down to having better individuals, no matter what laws or systems you create. How do you make people better as a human being? What inspires someone to be just and moral? what drive someone else to become utterly selfish and morally corrupt? probably, as a society we need to be totally intolerant towards morally corrupt people. But who will define morality? or is morality enough? we need to create an atmosphere where good prevails. I don't know, if we can ever achieve that. world never achieved that. There were always bad people and there was always crime & corruption. I have given up on this society and any idealistic dreams i used to have about human life. I don't have answers and i am so bloody angry and frustrated.
abbastoronto
December 30, 2012 11:56 am
You play with fire, you get burned. On the one side there is public outrage, from English educated middle class. On the other side a billion souls weaned on Bollywood that objectifies women more than Hollywood does. Bollywood wins hands down.
Shan
December 30, 2012 11:13 am
What volcano? This is the same visceral hatred which supported Anna for a year till it became boring. Last I heard he could not gather even 500 people. Public deserves the leaders it gets. Lets see how long the protests last? It has become a fashion to light a candle on India gate. Society doesnt change with lighting candles.
Prashant
December 30, 2012 10:43 am
I feel like saying Sorry. I am sorry for the fact that I could not stop you from dying, could not reduce your pain by sharing some of it and for being from a gender that not only has the ability to rape women but in some cases also the intent and tendency. May god bless you goirl where ever you are.
Baqer
December 30, 2012 10:02 am
Rape was a prerogative of fashionable rich brats just for the hack of party fun. Currently, it stems from mentally depressed frustrated youth. It is such a common phenomena worldwide that governments do not bother. Even in Dubai, an Arabian city, a case was recently reported of a Pakistani driver raping an Ethiopian woman (Khaleej Times) that she committed suicide in her Embassy. In Pakistan, notorious gang rape of Mukhtar Mai, splashed newspapers and is now history. I watched an Indian film years ago depicting a woman gang enticing sick rapist and doing away with their so-called manhood with razor-edged blades. This may prove as a stop-gap for the time being. Besides, an actress called Neetu, has rightly suggested that women must get some sort of self-defence training. This episode of a young lady cremated at twenty-three (the prime of her youth and a future medical prospective) brings nausea in a country which prides as "Incredible India' in tourism adverts.Sexual intercourse must be by mutual consent outside marriage otherwise it is brutal physical and psychological murder, the penalty of which should be "chop-chop" (as beheading in Saudi Arabia), public flogging as enforced by Zia-u-Haq in Pakistan or shoe-bashing till Death (like Mussolini, former dictator of Italy).
Paras Vikmani
December 30, 2012 9:03 am
It's the end of Congress in 2014
hitesh
December 30, 2012 7:54 am
Why shouldn't we put a right man at the crater of this volcano to harness its energy in well-being of the nation ? Everybody knows who he is.
Sumit Mazumdar
December 30, 2012 6:47 am
What does it mean that a volcano will erupt? We in India, neigh, South Asia, will have to slog through these problems ourselves. Not the government, but we will have to take responsibility as individuals. Rapes happen because we look at women as property of someone else's. As commdity. We will have to educate our sons and not just shout at our governments. Educated rich people in India are involved in female foeticide. Government can do nothing. We, and we alone have to fight this. We should fight against the dowry system, honor killings, caste system, religious bigotry, everything. Let us take vows as individuals that we will not be silent when we see women harassed on the streets of Kolkata and Karachi, Delhi and Lahore.
ahmed41
December 30, 2012 6:37 am
~~~~Hello ! Why is there an expectation that politicians will initiate changes ? They can not. Governance is their sphere of activity. Controlling the minds and habits of members of society at large is a matter of social organization. It belongs to the field of guiding grown up adults ( who are just large children ) into acceptable patterns of behaviour. This has to do with sociology, social action and the correct practice of religious and behavourial values. Politicians and policemen can only stand on the periphery while society works out what it will accept and not accept~~~~~~~gender equality and justice, in an increasingly modernizing society.
Feroz
December 30, 2012 6:15 am
When a Nation reaches tipping point frustrations need only a spark to cause a conflagration. The Politicians have adopted a divide and rule policy to stall all calls for accountability. They spend huge sums of money to get elected and muscle power too. Once elected they are continuously looking for opportunities to illegally line their pockets rather than work for the welfare of the people. Winability is the only criteria for getting an electoral ticket and who can ever beat the mafia in money and muscle power. Political parties have become family business dynasties. If political parties do not reform and bring changes street protests can only intensify and the going for the Political class could become ugly.
Rao
December 30, 2012 5:02 am
Nobody could have written better than M.J.Akbar about this heinous crime and the moral that exists in all walks of life. He is right in his description of Indian prime minister who mumbles few lines from a prepared speech like a zombie and Sonia Gandhi nodding approvingly. What a moral rot sweeping the country. .... From a former Hindustani.
dk
December 30, 2012 4:10 am
well said mr mj akbar...what difference this so called young generation leaders led by rahul gandhi going to make ? they all have disappeared when nation wanted some sort of leadership. what exactly is happening in country is total vacuum of leadership at national level and its money laundering private limited companies under political parties which are sucking the country. rightly said .. time has come for volcano to erupt.