PIA had lost as many as seven million potential passengers to other airlines between 2009 and 2012 due to unilateral liberal traffic rights given to foreign carriers: report — File Photo

ISLAMABAD, Dec 3: The Pakistan International Airlines bemoaned in the Supreme Court on Monday that the unilateral grant of liberal traffic rights to foreign airlines was one of the reasons for the national flag carrier’s decline.

A day before the hearing of a case relating to rampant corruption in PIA, its management submitted a report to the court highlighting the airline’s history, issues affecting profitable operations and the reasons for its continued downward slide.

It said Pakistan had become a lifeline for foreign carriers, mainly from the Gulf region, which were sucking away the resources of Pakistan (Pakistani passengers). “Precious exchange is being drained and the airline of Pakistan is the ultimate loser.”

The report regretted that foreign airlines had been increasing their capacity on Pakistan routes because of the facility of liberal traffic rights. Successive governments have allowed foreign airlines to fly to and out of the country without offering any reciprocal rights to PIA to fly to their countries.

As the rightful revenues of PIA were taken away by the ambitious airlines of oil-rich countries, PIA was unable to invest in new aeroplanes, it said, adding that no aircraft was inducted into its fleet from 1992 to 2002. This was the period when the airline started incurring losses.

The report said PIA had lost as many as seven million potential passengers to other airlines on the US and UK routes between 2009 and 2012 because of the unilateral liberal traffic rights given to foreign carriers. The rights were given despite the fact that PIA was operating direct flights to the two destinations. “This decision alone robbed PIA of more than Rs150 billion in three years.”

NO RECIPROCITY: The report regretted that while Pakistan had been liberal in granting traffic rights, advanced nations like Japan, South Korea, Canada, Ireland, France, South Africa, Hong Kong and Qatar had not given the same facility to PIA in order to protect their own economies and airlines.

During the 1980s, PIA used to operate 45 international destinations, but now the number had come down to 37, the report said.

It added that over the years many airlines had ceased their operation through Pakistani soil, mainly because of the law and order situation in this country and the global recession.

“Non-availability of lucrative business opportunities for travellers led to reduction in the number of airlines operating in Pakistan to less than a dozen, of which PIA is providing ground handling services to only five airlines,” it said.

Although PIA’s revenue stood at Rs 9 billion last year, it was offset by a burden of Rs 39.68bn brought on by an increase in fuel cost, salary and wages, flight equipment rentals, exchange loss, administrative expenses, taxation impact, etc.

A three-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, Justice Gulzar Ahmed and Justice Shiekh Azmat Saeed will take up the case on Tuesday on applications moved by the Transparency International and PML-N Secretary General Iqbal Zafar Jhagra and Marvi Memon, a leader of the same party.

Already in the headlines for all wrong reasons, PIA again came under the flak on Monday when counsel Khalid Anwar requested the court to take a suo motu notice of the pathetic state of affairs in the airline.

The request was made against the backdrop of Sunday’s incident when an Islamabad-bound PIA aircraft developed fault in one of its engines and was stuck at the Karachi airport for hours. The chief justice and some federal ministers were among the passengers.

“I usually travel by PIA and whenever I step inside the aircraft I become nervous,” the counsel said, adding that maintenance of aircraft was not up to the mark.

But the chief justice told him that the court was already seized with a case pertaining to the national flag carrier.


Comments are closed.

Comments (16)

Feroze
December 9, 2012 6:07 pm
PIA and the Government are not two seperate institutions ...... they are one and the same. This is where you find the institution run by incompetent and untrained corporate executives, appointed of course by the government, who have no negotiation skills and do not know how to negotiate to win. Their counterparts sitting across the table are well educated, seasoned negotiators who win everytime they strike a deal, either by using their connections, their knowledge of their product or simplypolitical pressures and maybe at times a few "expensive gifts".
Shahzad
December 5, 2012 5:40 am
Why blame others when PIA cannot correct its own operations? PIA should learn a lesson from Emirates Airlines which was established during mid 80 by leasing two aircrafts and 16 staff persons mostly from PIA. Massive corruption, overstaffing and bad services are the main cause of PIA's reputation. It should be noted that PIA was one of the best airlines in the world till end of 70s, but nationalization policy and political motives made it worse. I met one of the Britishers in Penang, Malaysia in 2005 who said that PIA is the worst airline in the world as per his own travelling experience. I was really shocked and sad on his comments. One can notice that PIA tickets are always booked at the time of travelling whether local or internationa but stil the airline is in loss due to corruption.
ali
December 4, 2012 9:58 pm
Right, so the solution is to remove competition and increase the tax to 300%+ like you did to all foreign car manufacturers. Indian benefited hugely since they opened up. State protectionism is an ultimate tool for personal kick backs. Pakistan is the only country where a depreciating asset like cars actually go up in value and air travel monopoly by PIA has resulted in so many sub-standards. Consumer is the ultimate sufferer and is so ignorant that would never raise its voice.
Muhammad Anwaar
December 4, 2012 7:39 pm
my name is Muhammad Anwaar and i am a student of leadership and management studies. the core issue of PIA is mismanagement and corruption. make me managing director of PIA. Inshaallah I will make it profitable and Asia's best airline in next 3 years.
ikhlaque chan
December 4, 2012 5:05 pm
Most of this claims by PIA is wrong. PIA is enjoing monopol situation for direct flights from US, Europe and Canada. They offer bad food, dirty planes, look at the business class in their planes, its just like in Pakistan Railways. The staff is rude, (search youtube or others). They charge you 1700 dollars from Oslo to Lahore, and you get no info about when the plane is supposet to arrive or depart. Their service mannager escape from duty every time there is a problem. Only reason why Pakistanis still fly PIA is some kind of loyality to Pakistan and the direct route monopoly. You can fly to Bangkok or Dehli from Europe for as little as 450-500 dollars. If we Pakistanis could do the same, we would travel 2 times a year. That means lots of dollars, euros, in to Pakistani economy. Pakistan shuld learn to do business that benefits the nation. In stead we are more in to bribe oriented economy and politics. Everybody loose. - It will cost you 500 millin rupis to set up a domestic airline in Pakistan. Plus a lot of bribes. Why? In Europe it is almost free. Pakistanis do not allow charter air operations from Europe so tourist can come cheaper to spend their money in Pakistan. PIA shuld close, they deserve it.
karim
December 4, 2012 4:54 pm
PIA does not have a birthright to Pakistani passengers and their dollars. PIA's service is poor, it is overstaffed and its planes are poorly maintained.
kirther
December 4, 2012 4:38 pm
I think the main problem with PIA is inefficiency & incompetence, one look at PIA air hostesses gives a complete picture of worse quality management. If PIA cannot compete in open market than it is no good and should be closed down or the second option is to remove the incompetent management and hire competent people on merit basis and let them operate independently without political interference. Why waist precious financial resources on courts hit the nail on the head for better results.
IQBAL
December 4, 2012 1:51 pm
Lame Excuses.
Muhammad Choudhry
December 4, 2012 12:11 pm
Incompetent persons and political appointments are killing this organization, Just count, how many previous corrupt Prime minister Gilani has hired from Multan.
shujja
December 4, 2012 9:34 am
Mostly all the PIA official are hired through references, there isn't a single well educated person inside the Pakistan International Airline. Services are below standard, every day in news PIA planes are facing technical difficulties, delay. and then PIA official come across blaming other airlines & countries for loss in their business. Perhaps all the garbage inside the PIA system should be cleaned. Especially cases pertaining to rampant corruption.
Circumbulator
December 4, 2012 8:44 am
What a great fall, from one of the best to one of the worst. Kickbacks to you know who, commissions on purchases and contracts, hiring of political employees, incompetence etc etc. Why isn't there a full forensic investigation, what are the guardians afraid of finding? Maybe skeletons in their own closets, after all it has been headed by some of their own at one time or the other.
SJ
December 4, 2012 8:04 am
PIA, like other organizations in our beloved country, is run by incompetent people. Mismanagement rules, short-cuts found in abundance, missing work ethics ensue, ... and the list goes on. They are offering excuses to be saved from justice. A usual state-of-affair. Nothing new.
Asim Khan
December 4, 2012 8:02 am
What used to be a world class organisation has been reduced to shamble due to continued meddling by successive milatary (Gen Zia) as well as elected governments. The airline is not only over staffed but is also plagued with low calibre individuals hired against quotas or parchees! The airline is a reflection of the the Country itself and cannot blame other for its own shortcomings which again is in line with our national ethos of blaming "hidden hands" or "foreign hands" instead of self introspection. In the present setup there is no future for PIA it would be best that to wind it up and let the private sector fill in the gap. Competition will ensure that the passengers not only get good service but cheap ticket as well while a monopoly of the state carrier will result in expensive airfare with sub par service. The tax payers cannot be expected to carry the burden of overstaffed, uncompetitive and inefficient state enterprises whether its PIA, Steel Mill, Pakistan Railways, PNSC, so on and so forth. The only solution is to either privatise it or if the people of Pakistan are in a benevolent mood give part of the emoluments of the staff in form of shares of the state enterprises which would force all of them to start focusing on performing their duties. Pakistan paindabad.
Khanm
December 4, 2012 7:28 am
Let them face the music. the Goverment has to remove the safety net. remember the fittest will survive. it their own doing. instead of becoming the best pakisten international air line. they become PIA. pain in ---
Qamer
December 4, 2012 7:14 am
No one mentioned the kickbacks from foreign airlines to Pakistani officials and politicians.
observer
December 4, 2012 7:13 am
As little as I know about inner workings of PIA, I think competition from foreign and private airlines is the only thing that is keeping PIA give services. If it was not for competition, PIA will be 10 times worse than it is at present. Instead of catching up with competitors, PIA is seeking to ban the foreign airlines. Is PIA thinking like a business organization or military organization?