“I always felt different because everywhere I go people either give me sympathetic looks or are scared that I will bring bad luck. But the first time I actually felt betrayed was when one of my sisters was getting married. I was treated like an outcast by my own family, all of whom thought that if I touched the bridal clothes or anything related to the nuptial ceremony something catastrophic will happen,” narrated Mahar whilst describing her experience as a widow in Pakistan.

Mahar belonged to the upper-middle strata of the Pakistani society and lives in one of the largest cities in the country. However, her narrative made me think about hundreds of widows living in the rural areas of Pakistan who are far less educated and empowered than Mahar and most definitely a lot more discriminated.

Many will fail to admit the truth that despite all the progress that societies have made in terms of equality and human rights, widows are still considered a bad omen. Many widows are ostracised from society whereas, quite a handful of them are deprived of their rights to remarry and inherit property. Although all religions ask their followers to treat widows with respect and dignity, however, it is evident that the traditions and superstition supersede religious diktats.

It is important to understand that with the world embroiled in conflicts ranging from wars to religious violence the percentage of widows in societies is surging drastically. It is important to recognise them as equal and contributing members of the society by empowering them as much as possible so that they are able to lead ‘normal’ lives.

Despite of all the awareness regarding human and equal rights, widows are still living unfortunate lives in many south Asian countries. In fact, Pakistan is not the only country where widows are marginalised. Most South Asian countries such as Afghanistan, Nepal and India do not treat widows on equal footings with other women and citizens of the society. However, the situation in India because of old values and tradition is highly critical and worse than most countries.

An Indian widow from Pune, who now lives in Detroit, Michigan, shared her experience on condition of anonymity by saying, “I belong to an elite Indian family and one would think that with the world is changing so fast the country would have left behind its traditions. I agree that India is a progressive society but there are various issues that are still considered beyond discussion or argument and widowhood is certainly one of them.”

“I lost my husband when I was 40 and there were times that people, especially married women refused to even eat with me. I remember not being invited to events, people looking at me suspiciously if I smiled or laughed or at times even refusing to sit with me. It was almost like I was the reason why my husband died and I was left to live with the guilt. I still remember my mother telling me that I should have died with him. I was treated worse than an untouchable,” she added with tears glistening in her eyes.

“I fail to understand that why people do not realise that life and death is in the hands of Almighty and we play no role in such decisions whatsoever. If I had it my way I would have died before him,” she said.

India is one of the few countries where widows suffer the most. It is estimated that over 15,000 widows from different parts of India are forced to live in Ashrams located in holy cities such as Vrindavan — most of them hoping for a death which remains their only solace. A heavy majority of these widows sing bhajans and receive a small pittance from the people who visit temples, whereas others beg or receive a petty allowance from the government. One of the most heart wrenching facts about these widows is that sometimes they do not even receive a respectful cremation. In fact, just a few months back some of the widows who died were chopped up into pieces and their extremities were stuffed in gunny bags as the government did not have sufficient funds to cremate them in accordance with Hindu rituals.

Although many social organisations and activists are working to help Indian widows, however, it is evident that for them the only hope lies in death which will liberate them from this vicious cycle of life.

The predicaments faced by South Asian widows has prompted South-Asian Network for Widow Empowerment in Development (SANWED) to undertake various measures in order to create awareness about the problems faced by widows and mainstreaming them into economic and social stratum of societies. A few months back SANWED held a conference in Islamabad to adopt a unanimous declaration called ‘Islamabad Declaration for Mainstreaming Widows’ and ‘Single Women’s Rights in Public Policy’. The declaration is aimed at providing equal opportunities for widows who are discriminated in the society.


Comments are closed.

Comments (92)

Mohammad Arif
November 14, 2012 11:44 am
In most part of India also, the situation is nearly same like or worse. And in Hindu community it is like crime against humanity. But the situation has become a little better. I remember during my childhood (nearly 30 years ago), one man from Rajput Hindu family had died. His family was very rich and they were like landlords. He was the head of the family. We, as children liked him very much. Sometimes when our primary school classes were over at evening and we were going back to our homes, he will suddenly appear on the road and chase us and distribute sweets. Please note that time there was no gap / difference between Hindus and Muslims (every body was practicing their religion peacefully and without any objection from others and no hatred among them). When he died, the people wanted to burn his wife also with him but she resisted and finally they left her from burning alive. But after that her life became like hell or worse. She had to shave all her hair. She had to wear only very cheap white saari. She couldn't go to temple. She had to leave her house and live in a very small dark room. She was to cook her own food in one pan in that room and eat alone. Nobody should touch anything of her. They were giving her very limited food which was only enough for one time in one day. She had to live mostly in the room in dark - without any light. She was not allowed to go to public places and also was not allowed to show her face to anybody. If she was caught in Public or in temple, she had to be beaten by hunters. She was only allowed to go for daily routine requirements in the night in dark and for bringing her water also she could go only in dark. But even if somebody saw her in the night, then again she had to be punished by hunters and sticks. There were many more things I cannot write here. But one thing I'll write that she was many many times raped by his own family members and outsiders and there was no complaint of this, since she had to live alone in her small room. The cruelty finally was over after some years when one of her family member killed her for capturing her property. Alaas, we loved her and her husband but we children couldn't do anything since nobody will listen her. Seeing these crimes against humanity, I hate this type of religion. Can anybody tell me where in Vedas these atrocity has been written. Shame on you who are the protectors of religion. Shame on you.
Abdullah Cheema
November 14, 2012 8:43 am
Brother its Deuterogamy (A second marriage, after the death of the first husband of wife),Islam doesn't allow polygamy(The having of a plurality of wives or husbands at the same time) for women but men.
Rakesh
November 14, 2012 7:56 am
@Manghirmalani The writer does have a name---Faiza Mirza :-) If you read her previous articles, I am sure you will realize that she is well meaning in all her articles and doesn't intend to be rhetorical. On the contrary she does have good things to say about our country/society. I recon she is being objective in this article and is certainly not absolving the Pakistani society of the prejudice inherent in them either. Let our generation give peace a chance. Wishing you success in everything you do! Rakesh :-)
Rao
November 14, 2012 7:52 am
Please read other articles written by the same writer in Dawn. She is not prejudiced against India or Hindus. I agree with the author that widows in India, among Hindus, face much more discrimination than Muslim widows. Remarriage is not a taboo in Islam, but in traditional Hindu societies it is a taboo For your information...I am an Indian, born into a Hindu family.
idol worshipper
November 14, 2012 5:59 am
It may sound strange but it is women who are against women and it is men who are doing things to get them out. There are mother in laws, sister in laws and other wonderful women who will pass these rules as who is auspicious and who is cursed.
Dr. Najia Khan
November 14, 2012 4:36 am
Dear Prafulla, i shared with you all the experience my mother had. She is as strong as your colleague as she is the reason for us to have professional degrees and successful in our lives. I am protective towards her, but as someone has very truly commented in one of the posts that in the subcontinenet many traditions and trends are still being followed without any consideration for those being logical or not - my mother and her siblings were brought up with similar mind sets. It is sometimes difficult to go against what the society believes in. Look around and we find many single women in powerful positions, independent, intellectuals who do defy the rules of the society. We are talking about the way "We as a society" treat single women. Some elders of my family, when I was orphaned, were against pursuing a career in medicine, my mother was the only person who stood for me. Life for a women, no matter how educated and urbanized we in the South Asian countries are, will be difficult.
Tabassum
November 14, 2012 4:36 am
Just because you don't understand religion, you cannot make it a private matter. People are on WAR in the world and ranjit says it should be a private matter. Brother, All the prophets had one and same faith. Bases was same always that there is none worthy of worship other than Allah. They came one after another and spread the same message. I don't know which hotline you are talking about but YES all these prophets were the chosen ones of Allah and the only HOTLINE(as u said) I know was the angel Gabriel who used to bring them Allah's revealetions. All of them taught same thing that worship ALLAH only and do NOT worship IDOLS. IDOLS cannot give you anything. HOw can something made by you can give you something. How can you make your own god and worship it. God is the one one who made you and not whome you made and he is the one whome you should rely upon. Allah gave different commands accoring to different eras. And its the people who did not follow the commands as they came. If people had believed all the prophets and did as they said which was a command from Allah then there would have been no conflict. The whole humanity would have followed mohammad because he is the last prophet(sallalaho alahe wasallam) but people stopped till their own desired prophet who in turn taught them not to do so. Thus the fault is not in the religion. It is in the people who for their own pleasure did not follow the whole chain of prophets. There is only one religion and that is islaam which is taught by all the prophets.
Virkaul
November 14, 2012 4:31 am
@factcheck, Roop Kanwar died in 1987. Pl check on google.
Sunil
November 14, 2012 4:16 am
That may be true about several pakistani authors; but not about Faiza Mirza. She has a very balanced mindset. I have read several of her articles. She is equally critical about many aspects of pakistani culture - Sunil
tabassum
November 14, 2012 4:11 am
Well I don't agree with you. She has highlighted both the societies. Read it again. And if you think she mentioned india more then may be problem in india is more than pakistan. At least someone wrote about women of india or else people are stuck with BOLLYWOOD mania there!
tabassum
November 14, 2012 3:57 am
I am sure those who say Quran doesn't teach anything, have never dared to read it with its translation. And those who have read it will never say that its useless. Quran and bible are the two holy books among four. And Quran is the last book to be followed which is still and will always be as it was revealed. Atheist became atheist because they used their Common sense. If common sense was enough, their wouldn't be any books. Even this is common sense that we need The book to lead our lives properly. How did you reach professional level and got a job? By reading books? or by JUST using your common sense?If you need books for that then obviously you need BOOK for other more important things in iife too. Common sense!
Rakesh
November 14, 2012 3:24 am
The writer is doing a great service to all of us in the subcontinent, by highlighting social issues that require acute attention by those who want to live in a peaceful and civilized society. The least we could do to help is discuss it rationally, dispassionately, and to introspect to look for societal/individual remedies. Sadly many of us use this forum to make comments that reek of chauvinism of many a denomination. Why is it so difficult to realize that all humans are born equal irrespective of their nationality, religious beliefs, the language they speak, their ethnicity, or orientation of any other type! Peace, happiness etc can only be found when we purge ourselves of prejudices, stereotyping, bias, etc. Please realize that as citizens of this world, we have an individual/collective duty to make it a safe and happy place to live in for the future generations! Love and Peace Rakesh :-) :-) :-)
Zeeshan
November 14, 2012 12:28 am
Pakistanis don't believe in God or Islam or teachings of the holy prophet of Islam (pbuh). They just pretend to do so, which is total hypocrisy. Pakistanis follow exactly opposite to what Islam teaches.
Truth Hurts
November 14, 2012 12:22 am
If Zakir Naik talks nothing but Islam then he is another Tanvir....or vice versa......Does it make a difference :-)
Truth Hurts
November 14, 2012 12:21 am
Well said Tanvir,......Masha'Allah
Zeeshan
November 14, 2012 12:13 am
Well said Tanvir. However you can see that that more people have given your good comment a thumb down, showing the 'jahalat' of our society. So jahalat is the bigger issue of our society which needs to be resolved as well. Unfortunately its a catch22 situation, can't fix one without fixing the other. How do you expect tens of millions of jahils to allow to fix this issue even though Holy Prophet of Islam (pbuh) himself clearly gave instructions on this matter and demonstrated it with his own example.
manghirmalani
November 13, 2012 10:58 pm
does writer have a name, or she is daughter of some General ?
manghirmalani
November 13, 2012 10:56 pm
Good article, Why do use India as example, look at your country, how many people die every day in Karachi??????? Get your mentality straight.
george
November 13, 2012 9:22 pm
At least Indians spend their own money,not the American money.
george
November 13, 2012 9:18 pm
OK my friend,Pakistanis are the most cultured people and Islam is the best religion. Islam is the only religion which came from God,and all others were manufactured in the factory. Muslims are the most honest people in the planet. It is another fact that in almost all non-muslim countries,muslim form a large chunk of the prison population.
george
November 13, 2012 9:13 pm
All Pakistani muslims are descendants of Arabs, or some far away land. Please do not insult them saying they are related by blood to kuffars they love to hate.
george
November 13, 2012 9:10 pm
You have already showed arrogance which is typical of muslims that their religion islam is the best and all others are not as good as theirs. Well,there are many people who do not agree with you.
george
November 13, 2012 9:08 pm
Why deny this little pleasure to the Pakistanis.They do not have much to make them happy. They are so scared that their culture would be diluted by the Bollywood that they advise their country men not to watch hindi movies.
george
November 13, 2012 9:03 pm
Another Zakir naik.
Ranjit
November 13, 2012 8:37 pm
Respectfully I will submit that every religion believes that their prophet had a direct hotline to God. And yet all these direct hotlines by different prophets have resulted in different commands from God. And that is the basis of all religious conflicts and intolerance. That kind of intolerant thinking is true of all devout people of all religions, including my own (some of whom can be the most intolerant on this planet). So what do we do? I suggest we leave religion out of social discourse and let it remain a private matter.
FactCheck
November 13, 2012 7:17 pm
@Jennifer: “Which madrasah thought you that widows are burnt now…can you point out when the last incident of Sati was reported or even conducted...” The practice of sati is on going even as we speak. The last recorded incident, that I know of, was on June 3, 2011. This was the case of Roop Kanwar, 18years old girl, married for only 8 months before burnt alive as sati. You may also want to read the following referenced book: “DEATH BY FIRE: Sati, Dowry, Death and Infanticide in Modern India”
ZZX-1
November 13, 2012 6:46 pm
You are brave and truthful to have the guts to expose the Hindu culture with so much anguish and pain here.
Pagan
November 13, 2012 6:35 pm
I can't do it because because I can't get it up. I have fallen down and can't get up. CYRUS HOWELL LOL
Pagan
November 13, 2012 6:32 pm
Tattoos are a Pagan and Christian thingy. Muslims and Jews avoid them.
Tanvir
November 13, 2012 5:54 pm
All these omen-filled concepts about widows in Pakistan are not based on Islamic teachings. They are culturally fabricated over time due to other local influences. If Muslim men and women really want to resolve this issue and give some respect to widows, both the men and women must accept the concept of polygamy allowed under Islamic guidance. There mere fact being, that men are more prone to dying earlier than women because of their demand in the battle field or on dangerous missions, this leaving widows behind. These widows should have the right to seek financial and social security and human pleasures by finding jobs and marrying willing men. So there are always more available women than men for each other. This makes it a more a women's issue to fix the widowhood problems. Unless Muslim women accept the Islamic teachings and change their attitude on the polygamy rights of their husband, the women widows problem continue to linger on, ironically against the welfare of their own gender. In short, Islamic teaching offer a solution to both women and men to provide security and respect to each other and to enjoy life, it is more on the women to accept and enforce it for resolving the widowhood miseries of their gender - the women.
Tanvir
November 13, 2012 5:26 pm
Human rights are not awarded by a ghost. After all, they are declared by either a human or a human society. In case of Islam, it happen to be Prophet Mohammed (PBUH).
BEA
November 13, 2012 5:04 pm
Cyrus what problem do you have with my name.?
Karachi Wala
November 13, 2012 4:51 pm
@ Dr. Najia Khan, Could the reason be because most of subcontinent Muslims are converts and carried these habbits with them?
Karachi Wala
November 13, 2012 4:43 pm
@Khawaja Jee, You bring a good point. Some men and women may be able to survive rationally, emotionally, physically happy and healthy life, but if it becomes a norm, there is a strong possibility that it will bring some very unhealthy to the society. On the other hand, marrying a young widow against her wishes to someone twice or thrice her age or someone who is not at the level of her intellect will not bring any of the above mentioned harmony and happiness into her life.
Intrepid
November 13, 2012 4:39 pm
“I always felt different because everywhere I go people either give me sympathetic looks or are scared that I will bring bad luck. But the first time I actually felt betrayed was when one of my sisters was getting married. I was treated like an outcast by my own family, all of whom thought that if I touched the bridal clothes or anything related to the nuptial ceremony something catastrophic will happen,” narrated Mahar ...these emotions were voiced by Mahar, a woman who lives in a country claiming to be God fearing and Islamic!! Isn't it antithetical to the basic concept of "complete trust in God", espoused by Pakistanis as a basic tenet of Islam? Or is it a left over from the Hinduism from the days of British slavery ?????
Syed
November 13, 2012 4:39 pm
Dear Sue please read islam.I have read almost all religions and all current and ancient societies including the western societies. Believe it none has reached the standards set by islam by giving so many rights to widows, divorced, orphans and in general women but even muslims are not practicing it and hence the confusion. I encourage you to read islam and then you will see that west is only doing very little
Syed
November 13, 2012 4:28 pm
You got it right tabassum that follow islam is the panacea for all social evils.By the way I had afriend by the name tabassum farooqi in Karachi from Strathclyde academy where I used to teach. I am a doctor in Canada and I have lost this friend tabassum and trying to find this friend. I am fazal
Syed
November 13, 2012 4:13 pm
I don't understand Ranjit logic.somebody has to set standards and they were set by mohammad.till to date no one reached the standards set and practiced by him.may be we have few groups setting the standards but none have practiced like mohammad did so please don't show bias.A good thing should be accepted regardless of who is saying it and it was only mohammad who showed it by example
prafulla
November 13, 2012 3:05 pm
wonderful Roberts, these religious books separate us from human beings. We start classifying people as per their religions so we should ignore these books.
guest
November 13, 2012 3:05 pm
Its true and very heart-wrenching to see the signs of marriage removed from a 'sumangli' on widowhood. Seen bangles and bindi removed from my mother-in-law when FIL died and she was 65 then. Still most of us could not take it with sons refusing to admit the ceremony. Still she underwent it as most women do, wholeheartedly, but does not confine herself to white clothes. Being so, imagining the same for a younger woman is terrible. Indian men are not mentally prepared to accept widows or a divorcees for their wives yet. All want to marry only chaste girls. Re-marriage in India is a taboo but at the same time, things are changing. Have to concede, muslim men have no problem about marrying widows or divorcees even with off-springs, something unacceptable to Hindu men who can never accept other men's children as their own. Not even in metros you can see widows remarrying - unless they are bollywood stars or celebrities/socialites.
prafulla
November 13, 2012 3:01 pm
Dear Najia, How bad to know that we can not protect our own widow mother to live normal life & you will agree with me single solution of this is all the females should be educated & made earning members of the family. One young lady in my office lost her husband & we felt very bad but now after 2 months of the incident she is regularly coming in office & living her normal life as she is independent & literate enough to manage her.
guest
November 13, 2012 2:50 pm
Its very true widows were discriminated for centuries in India. But the same is not true in modern era with divorce rates surging up. Widows and divorcees today are much more independent in urban areas, though the same cannot be said about some very backward states and rural areas. As for the signs of marriage like bindi, choori - even that is changing as you know as many liberated women do not adhere to this code and don't even like wearing a mangal sutra. Ms. Blogger, i am hearing about the chopping of dead widows for the first time here. Without evidence, please don't post such a preposterous statement. By the way, is someone else writing under your name. This time, your language has disappointed me as the grammar is not pakka. Not that i care, still its unlike you to slip up like this. As for single women holding high status in Indian society, please remember Mayawati, Mamata Banerjee and Jayalalitha Jayaram who are king makers in Indian politics. Indira Gandhi lived most of her life as a widow and so does Sonia presently. Widowhood or divorce affects mostly illiterate, poor, rural women. In India, only one discrimination exists today: haves against have-not. Doesn't matter really whether you are a hindu or a muslim, man or woman, northerner or south Indian, believe me.
Reply123
November 13, 2012 1:54 pm
@Ranjit: Respectfully sir, you misinterpret. The rights are given in the Qur’an by God, not by the Prophet. The Prophet only interpreted them, demonstrated them in practical life through his personal example.
Jennifer
November 13, 2012 1:54 pm
Factcheck... Which madrasah thought you that widows are burnt now...can you point out when the last incident of Sati was reported or even conducted....maybe you should concentrate on Karo kiri etc...for your information female foeticide and other social evils are more rampant on Haryana ,Punjab and Rajasthan....sati was common amongst Rajput women as usually when their men died ,it was better to die than to be taken as sex slaves by the barbaric invaders....whole problems and social evils that came to the indian subcontinent is due to ISlAM as if this wouldn't have touched this land,we were a liberal and much advanced civilisation from 5000 years the truth which can be found in temple carvings and ancient literature.. The invading and greedy barbarians brought their repressive culture and started killing kafirs and taking their women hence killing girls and women due to honour thingy...no wonder this was prominent in border areas of India.anyways Karma doesn't spare anyone...all the oppressors are getting oppressed today.?
Asif
November 13, 2012 1:50 pm
Some of these backward customs such as forcing widowed women to live in ashrams must have to do with denying them any right to the property of their late husband and neither her father's family nor her in laws wanting to support her.
Jennifer
November 13, 2012 1:46 pm
Malvika...didn't you get it by now that Pakistans achievements are measured against India...anything negative about India makes them feel superior and better...coupled with hate infused history for the kafir can't expect them to write better...
Zazi
November 13, 2012 1:40 pm
@Sandip: Marrying a widow is a fundamental pious deed 'swab' for a Muslim. Specially recommended in the Qur'an. And is a well known 'Sunnat'. The Prophet's first marriage was to a widow and lasted 25years...till her death. In fact to protect a destitute widow even a second marriage is advocated. And to provide a home, roof, and shelter to destitute widows and their children, maximum of four such wives are permitted...not for any other reason, even though many men have exploited this 'huddood' Shariah Law for selfish reasons. These protections of Islam shelter destitute widows, provide them honor and home...removing them from the exploitation and abuse potential of the street. A single woman, more so a destitute vulnerable one is openly targeted and discarded in other cultures...even in advanced welfare states of Scandinavian Europe, what to say of UK and USA.
TheWholeTruth
November 13, 2012 1:10 pm
@Sue Sturgess: In most Western countries people don't marry...or get divorced promptly. They do live together or 'co-habit' form early 'teens on. The divorce rate in the US is over 50%. Between 30% to 70% children, depending on race and social status, are illegitimate. Coveting and transgressing neighbors spouse is the trend. Note the 'cultural societal mores' at the highest echelons...scandals at Presidential level, Senators, Congressmen and top star generals is the normal standard course. The lower levels are mongrel...no one knows who is who's daddy---except by blood tests, a rapidly growing business now. Tell me it ain't so.
Ranjit
November 13, 2012 12:55 pm
I understand you are saying something nice, but I object that rights to widows had to be given by your blessed prophet. They should have human rights whether or not the prophet wanted them to have it.
Malvika
November 13, 2012 12:54 pm
Good article! Although I still wonder weather the real purpose was highlighting the plight of widows in India! There is not much written about widows in Pakistan. Hindu bashing and India bashing comments prove writer has hit the nail in the right place. Women in whole of south Asia is mistreated in every way possible. Unless our respective education systems teach our young to respect and value women no real change in the attitude can be achieved.