Another Eid is here, another hajj performed ...

In pre-Islamic times the years were measured from hajj to hajj amongst the Arabs, ever since the times of the prophet Ibrahim – upon whom be peace – who had originally initiated it as a rite at the Behest of God. This was so, because, apart from its tremendous spiritual significance and meaning, it was probably the most spectacular socio-economic event in the annual course of the desert life, or rather, it became that in the course of time. Originally there was none of that; it was a pure ritual of worship without any worldly diversions from its exclusively spiritual nature. Like everything else, however, within the matrix of the time-space continuum of phenomenal existence, its spiritual purity was not to last.

With more and more people of lesser dedication than its founders and their immediate clan, following, the atmosphere and environment, in which the rituals took place, became more mundane and intermingled with materialistic concerns. This however, is the natural course of things, and can perhaps be understood as a divinely designed balancing mechanism to dampen the extreme emanations of divine light, which are being poured out at this occasion, the immensity and intensity of which would be too much to bear for people of a lesser degree of spiritual purity, much like the clouds that screen the torching heat of direct sunlight.

The essential meaning of the hajj is of course to turn away from all mundane concerns of one’s life, and turn to, or rather return to one’s Maker, bare of all possessions and decorations, stripped of all pretenses, in pure humility and realisation of one’s utter insignificance – nothingness – before His Greatness; rehearsal for the ultimate return to Him on the day, when all the sons and daughters of Adam will be brought back into His Presence. This should at least be the intention of anyone, who hopes to be admitted to that ‘Court of Divine Presence’.

I would like here to draw attention to one very special element of the hajj – the slaughtering of a sacrificial animal, or ‘qurbani’, as it is commonly known.

For one thing, the sacrifice is the reminiscence of an event, which occurred before the hajj was instituted as a ritual. The prophet Ibrahim saw in a dream that God demanded of him to sacrifice his son, and when he was about to actually obey God’s command and put the knife to his son’s throat, an angel prevented him from slaughtering his son, and gave him a ram to substitute for the required sacrifice. The unquestioning submission of Ibrahim and his son Ismail to God’s Command pleased Allah so much that He instituted it as a ritual and living memorial.

Secondly, sacrifice in its overall spiritual meaning and objective, is one of the most essential means of drawing near to Him (which is the central idea of the hajj altogether); this reality is literally reflected in the word ‘qurbani ’,  which is  derived from the Arabic root ‘qaf-ra-ba’, meaning to ‘be near’ or ‘to draw near’.

Thirdly, it is the only hajj-ritual, which is not only performed then and there, but emulated at that time beyond the venue of the hajj, all over the Muslim world, so much so that it has become integrated as an almost mandatory tradition in the Eid celebrations.

Unfortunately, the above touched upon tendency of sidetracking original spiritual contents and meaning in exchange for prominence of materialistic externals has widely gained such an overpowering momentum that in the worst cases it has reached the limits of sheer profanation, in that not only inward meanings have been lost beyond recovery, but such behavioral patterns and attitudes are manifesting, which are perverting those cherished values into their total opposites.

Humility and self-negation, have been replaced by boastful pride and showing off. Giving up something that is dear to us ‘for the Countenance of God’, i.e. unconditionally seeking His Pleasure – which is what sacrifice is all about – has been alienated into pampering our self-importance by blowing a lot of cheap, if not ill-gotten money in order to parade an animal that outweighs any other beast in the neighborhood.

That Allah has stated in His Holy Word, that it is not the blood and flesh of the sacrificial animals that reaches Him, but rather the spirit of those, who offer the sacrifice. What has, instead, become important is that the blood and flesh reach the attention of the onlooker.

This shift in priorities has brought yet another desecration in its wake. The sudden increase in demand results in a noticeable ‘butcher-boom’. At the time of ‘Eid ulAdha’ our cities experience a ‘mushrooming’ of part-time butchers, amateur butchers, seasonal butchers, opportunity butchers, in most cases, unskilled people, eager to make a quick buck. The bigger the animal is, the more skill is required on the part of the butcher, and the less skilful the butcher is, the more suffering it entails for the animal, something God disapproves of in the strongest terms. I have seen camels being dragged through the agony of death for hours of torture before they eventually collapsed in weakness, and their throat was finally cut. How can the most Merciful God find any pleasure in this?


Comments are closed.

Comments (46)

seeker
October 29, 2012 12:36 pm
Can they understand the Quran? I have doubts. Everyone cannot understand Quran only kind hearted people can understand the language of god,Not the sinful.
Masud Alam
October 29, 2012 12:25 pm
Thank you Mohd Harun for speaking up on the issue. And speaking with sympathy and understanding towads the unfortunate hordes that call themselves Muslim and consider qurbani obligatory. If anything, qurbani has become a status-related social evil like dowry - everyone feels compelled to spend on it beyond their means, and feel socially small if they can't.
Salman
October 29, 2012 12:13 pm
Any idea why the meaning is hidden? would it not be preferable if it was easy to understand for everyone?
chaudry
October 29, 2012 11:10 am
you people are civilized........... Say us orthodox, because we sacrifice animals for the sake of Allah and Sunnah of His Prophet(A.S)...........
Shah
October 29, 2012 8:44 am
Qurbani means to get near of Allah, not only slaughtering animal but becoming a great human being. A person Haj and Qurbani of One day cannot cant be accepet by allha if he/she is doing sin throughout the year. Qurbani is an islamic culture, which remind us the Hazrat Ibrahim Qurbani of ismail. But slaughtering only animals are cannot be comapred with the real qurbani...
Murali.N
October 29, 2012 7:34 am
Killing wont make god happy! Protecting make god happy! There is lot of hidden meanings in the writing of Quran! People only see the words not the meaining!
Murali.N
October 29, 2012 7:30 am
Well Said
Zeeshan Shamsi
October 29, 2012 6:22 am
Maybe because spiritual concepts escape your pedestrian view of the world!
Pramod
October 29, 2012 5:32 am
Better give 5 Kg rice to a poor man than a 1/2 or 1 kg of meat. That will give him the surity of food for a week or so.
kaushik
October 29, 2012 5:12 am
This is exactly what one attempts to give up / takes an oath at Kasi while taking a bath in the holy Ganges. One of our favorite dish/fruit & vegetable is also given up here.
Dixit
October 29, 2012 5:01 am
Kya likha hai Harun Bhai. This is the first time I have read from a Muslim on this senstive issue. Yes I agree with you that it cann't be called sacrifice but cruel killing of animals who have done no harm to you. They are also created by God.
gashirazi
October 28, 2012 9:46 pm
They are both the same.
sbb
October 28, 2012 9:45 pm
Thank you for writing this. It used to be that Qurbani was a very thoughtful thing to do. Friends who participated, did so with tremendous thought. Food was shared among friends, but it was never excessive. Today, you can just pay a butcher $200 and he will do your qurbani for you. Where is the qurbani in that?
M A Hussain
October 28, 2012 9:26 pm
Yeah...let the animals die a natural death of old age. May be we can eat mushrooms instead.
Roney Indian
October 28, 2012 7:21 pm
Sensible Muslim...good job mate
khalid
October 28, 2012 5:59 pm
As I started reading this article I was asking myself is it possible a real Pakistani could have said or written all of this. Is this possible this person is really from Pakistan. Aha! till I read the authors background a Germany revert! Bro Mohd you are a true Muslim and I really appreciate and enjoyed your article.
Waltair
October 28, 2012 4:48 pm
And herein lies the problem! People do not keep their opinion to themselves. So many people want to impose their religion on others. They feel free to criticise other religions as inferior but do not tolerate criticism of their own religion. First be tolerant towards to the beliefs of others and then demand the same tolerance to your beliefs. Beware of the dangerous politicians and self styled guardians of religion who criticise secularism; Secularism is tolerance.
Rahmat
October 28, 2012 3:51 pm
Killing an innocent animal to appease Allah can not be true. Allah is all merciful and would never sanction any killings in His name. Killing animals is an absolute abomination.
dhanathavale
October 28, 2012 3:34 pm
very apt. I think the real meaning of qurbani here is to sacrifice the thing which is dear to oneself such as your ego, wealth etc. May be in those times, the live stock was precious to Arabs and hence that sacrifice might have been ordained. But does it still hold true? Try to sacrifice your ego, your attachments to worldly matters. What is the sacrifice when you kill an animal?
Skhan
October 28, 2012 2:54 pm
"God does not at all make the sacrifice compulsory for people who are not performing the hajj" .... can you quote a verse from the Quran or a hadith to support this statement? Thank you.
watch
October 28, 2012 12:01 pm
give the poor people money, but don't kill animals
Anonymous
October 28, 2012 10:02 am
I have a few questions: 1) Why dont the same feelings apply when you/we are devouring the chicken/mutton/beef burgers? Certainly those animals die before being served? 2) Don't you think even if 1/2 of the meat is distributed among the poor, it makes a difference? 3) Don't you agree that if hospitals like 'Shaukat Khanum' sell the skins to help the needy, makes a difference? 4) So sacrificing your wealth for the above mentioned reasons is wrong? I would like to hear how much each one of you is submitting for the sake of helping the needy? 5) The 'pretenders' do exist, but the few do not represent all. Are we really better off without the sacrifices? The same pretenders would probably keep on accumulating. Is that a better option :P I think it really takes a good heart and significant wealth to buy and sacrifice even in todays time. Its very easy to point out whats wrong and criticize, but nearly impossible to appreciate some good happening around us.
Ghuffran Amanullah
October 28, 2012 9:46 am
Mr. Harun, a very pertinent observation and I agree with you on many fronts. However I would like to ask for references with regards to your observation that Sacrifice is only applicable during Haj. I agree with you on the fact that it is a lot of keeping up with jones'es going here and the amount on money spent on this over priced pieces of meat can be much better spent in regions of the world where this much livestock and or capital can make the difference between life and death of entire populations. However having said that can you pls post some references about your observation. I have tried to research it at my end however its all a bit grey. Thanks
khalid
October 28, 2012 9:44 am
Sacrifice means cutting the throat of innocent animals?
Muhammad
October 28, 2012 7:22 am
In the name of Allah people kill themselves(suicide bombers,fidayeen), kill others(animals and other people) and call it Qurbani. Is this real Qurbani what Allah wants?
zulwiqar Mohammad Zulwiqar
October 28, 2012 6:50 am
very well written article. However, I do not fully agree with the para on livestock imports. The qurbani obligation for only Hajis is worth to mention, as a huge number of muslims are unaware of this fact
Astral Dust
October 28, 2012 6:49 am
So basically god created us all and is in constant need of assurance that we still value and remember it?
Currat
October 28, 2012 6:30 am
It's all show off these days.. there's not any sort of spirit reflecting from people's act for pleasing Almighty. The all they want is the BBQ parties, praises for them selves and they just want to prove themselves superior from others unfollowing the teachings of Islaam which teaches us the equality and purity of intentions..
seeker
October 28, 2012 5:56 am
Present Muslims have forgotten the spiritual meaning and are following blind rituals killing innocent(masum) animals and eating its flesh and rejoicing.
M.Hanif Khan
October 28, 2012 5:05 am
"On the other hand, God does not at all make the sacrifice compulsory for people who are not performing the hajj, and even those hajis, of whom it is required, are only conditionally obliged, i.e. if they can afford it. If not, they can substitute for it by keeping a certain number of fasts." It is certainly written very well and in a very convincing manner. The above quoted lines appear to contradict what religious scholars say that Qurbani is mandatory on all Muslims whether performing Haj or not. Will the writer or someone else throw light on it?
Ram Krishan Sharma
October 28, 2012 12:24 am
A similar story exists in the Jewish old Testament where God tested Abram ( Ibrahim) to sacrifice his only son Isac to confirm his faith in God. Which story is the correct one ?
rajiv
October 28, 2012 12:10 am
How can we call it sacrifice when all it takes money to buy it and then we can eat it too.... so we dont loose money also.... kindly help me how you translate sacrifice..
BRR
October 27, 2012 10:39 pm
A very bad piece of writing - "within the matrix of the time-space continuum of phenomenal existence, its spiritual purity was not to last.". Such meaningless writing.
sparky singh
October 27, 2012 10:38 pm
Animal sacrifice might have been a 'sacrifice' in times when everyone kept animals and used them for work in the fields and for transportation. Giving up an animal at the time might have been a token of respect/surrender towards god.
nadeem
October 27, 2012 7:03 pm
There is a no compulsion in relgion that is what quran says but I a believer so hajj,roza,namaz,zakat and qurbani is not waste of time or money,I am happy to be muslim and I do not mind you keep your opinion to yourself as I am.
gangadin
October 27, 2012 6:22 pm
If there is any message from Abraham's story, its definitely not a passport to kill millions of animals in the name of God. The message would be that " My faith in God is so strong that I will sacrifice anything in His name".
shahab ahmed
October 27, 2012 6:17 pm
correction bouquet
nooffence7
October 27, 2012 6:05 pm
Do not sacrifice an innocent animal to please the God.
shahab ahmed
October 27, 2012 5:56 pm
its bouqe of good english hidden inside , sorry to say , totatal ignorance. Every thing is not 2+2=4 .May Allah give you guidence
khoso
October 27, 2012 5:46 pm
not demanded his son but GOD demanded that sacrifice your lovely thing
Kamran
October 27, 2012 4:52 pm
I agree with defining the term sacrifice which the muslim world needs to understand and follow as their religious duty, if you remember prophet Ibrahims call to Gods command by offering his son for sacrifice,you understand this event teachs us to be completely submissive and obidient to God,in fact we need to be sacrificing our dearest assests in the name of God, which doesnt have to be an animals slaughter,it can be our precious time, money, energy etc going in the way of Gods way.
Shankar Bandyopadhay
October 27, 2012 4:44 pm
Sacrifice requires real strength of character and involves giving up what is really dear to oneself. Very few humans have actually done it. Sacrificing of animals is nothing but slaughtering for satisfying one owns greed in the name of god.
Human
October 27, 2012 4:27 pm
Good article. There is a gross misconception of god. God is full of love, compassion, merciful. How would he like cutting throat of his creation, the animals. So much pain is endured by misconception of human minds.This is not the way to get close to god. I have seen goodness in the eyes of goats and cows. I have seen that in mother duck who is passionately training ducklings the swimming. That is love, the very vast godly attribute. That is god. It is pity that people who know least about god are doing this in the name of god. The people who are training their kids to sacrifice should not make them demons and killers by spilling animal blood on the streets. They should rather teach them about god. They should teach them about how to be closer to god by letting go of ego, attachments and vices. They should teach them sacrifice of not giving into our senses and sense organs such as taste to our tongues which is a big culprit. But alas! They are doing totally opposite. This doesn't take them close to divine light, the noor.
Indian
October 27, 2012 2:28 pm
Greatest sacrifice is sacrifice of the Ego.Sacrifice of Bad qualities you have like anger,greed,pride,lust,selfishness,hatred,malice, jealousy towards other and imbibing good qualities such as love,sharing,speaking kind words,peace,friendship,performing holy actions,good thinking. Inside purity is what one wants.Purity of mind is what one needs to achieve. To see god outside is foolish To see god within is wisdom.
zafar Malik
October 27, 2012 2:24 pm
Thanks for this blog. I agree with you one hundred percent. In my view it is no sacrifice at all, it is gluttony. People eat so much meat during this time that they often get sick. It is unhealthy for people and cruel to the poor animals and it is not obligatory at all for ordinary Muslims. A poor family can have food in their house for a whole month for the price of a single goat or lamb. Most of all poor animals are slaughtered proudly in streets in full view of every one, even little children, Who are even encouraged to participate, naturally they learn to become insensitive to spilling blood and causing pain and suffering to others as they grow. It is not hard to imagine, what kind of society is created by this life time training to kill mercilessly. Taliban who are known for their merciless blood shedding and brutality, are just one step ahead.
raika45
October 27, 2012 1:15 pm
If God gave Abraham a ram for sacrifice, why are you muslims doing it to cattle, camels and goats?Why not chicken?After all they are available in plenty and not much bloodshed is involved.No malice meant.Just a question.