Recently on a visit to New York I was being driven in a taxi across one of the stunningly diverse and animated city’s many avenues.

The cabby was a middle-aged, working-class Pakistani.

We didn’t talk much, mainly because while driving he was attentively listening to a FM radio news channel.

After some news about the upcoming American Presidential election, the newscaster turned to the next big story of the day: The mob attacks on American embassies in Libya and Egypt.

Triggered by the sudden emergence of an amateurishly made film based on a rather clumsy (if not entirely silly) strain of Islamophobic bigotry, the anti-US riots soon spread to more than 20 Muslim countries.

Nevertheless, on that very day, the riots were still contained within Libya, Egypt and perhaps Yemen. So as the newsreader went into the details about the mob attacks, the Pakistani taxi driver’s forehead at once became the scene of a tense frown. He shut his eyes for a few seconds, sighed and shook his head in hapless disappointment.

“Day in and out,” he began (in Urdu), “the Muslim communities in America work so hard, so very hard... for money, for our children, but mostly to show Americans that we too are hardworking, self-made citizens who have values as strong as theirs.”

I remained quiet. He still wasn’t sure if I was a Pakistani or an Indian. He briefly glanced at me trying to figure this out, but didn’t ask.

“We’ve had to do so much in the last many years,” he continued. “Every time we feel that our community has proven to the Americans that we mean no harm, that we are peaceful and decent and willing contributors to the economic well-being of this country, our brothers back home, just by indulging in a single act of violence, push all our hard work back. We have to start all over again.”

This time I decided to speak: “I understand. You are from my country, Pakistan, aren’t you?”

“Yes!” He answered, suddenly excited. “How did you know?”

“Your Urdu has a very Karachi touch,” I smiled. He laughed: “You are from Karachi too?”

I told him I was. But I was more interested in his story. He didn’t say much. However he did offer me ‘desi tea’ at a restaurant called Handi whose board outside suggested it served ‘authentic Indian, Pakistani & Bangladeshi cuisine.’

As it turned out it was a greasy joint famous among South Asian taxi drivers. The tea there was awesome. And so were the clients. Indian Hindus, Sikhs, Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims as well some Egyptians and Jordanians. Most of them were taxi drivers, but I saw at least one South Asian NYPD cop, a young woman but I am not sure whether she was an Indian or a Pakistani.

Founded by a Pakistani couple some 15 years ago, the place buzzed like a poor man’s South Asian utopia. The TV switched between Indian and Pakistani news channels, and as people chatted among themselves, one could hardly tell the difference between them. Who was Indian,  Pakistani or Bangladeshi?

Only when people said goodbyes could one tell. ‘Khuda Hafiz’, and even a few cries of the concocted ‘Allah Hafiz’ underlined the men’s religious leanings, all mixed with ‘Ram, Ram’ or ‘Dhaneywar.’

Posters surrounded the wall at the entrance. Posters about ‘Pak-India Cultural Shows’, concerts by visiting Pakistani singers, Eid and Devali gatherings, et al.

As we sipped tea, the driver finally told me that he moved to New York from Karachi in 1990. He didn’t say how or why, but it was only a few years ago that he got his American citizenship.

“For almost fifteen years I didn’t meet my parents back home,” he told me. “But with Allah’s grace, I earned and saved enough to send them money and a ticket to come visit me last year. They loved New York,” he laughed. “Inshallah, now I have enough to go back to Karachi and pay them a visit.”

“Pakistanis really work hard here,” he reminded me. “Especially men like me who come from poor backgrounds. And we send back a lot of money to our country. We prove to the Americans that we mean well, that we appreciate their system that gives opportunities to men like me. Hard work pays off in America. I’ve seen some very humble Pakistanis become millionaires in America through sheer hard work.”

I politely redrew his attention to the anti-American riots in the Muslim world. He shook his head again. “What can I say?” He asked, rhetorically. “There are fools (pagal) all over the world.”

But then he said something culled from the wisdom of a hardened New York taxi man: “I’ve had both Muslim and non-Muslim clients in the back of my cab who talked rot about other religions. But does that mean I run them over with my taxi?”

He continued: “But you know, if you live long enough in America as I have, you’ll find that Americans, both Muslim and non-Muslim, black, white, brown or whatever, are highly tolerant people. It’s our politicians and maulvies back home and some ‘padres’ (Christian preachers) and Jewish preachers here, who like to make trouble.”


Comments are closed.

Comments (70)

Ahmed
September 24, 2012 1:11 pm
What do you mean minority ? it was a minority who took the path of violence. Only that majority is too afraid of this minority in Pakistan. Your comment basically indicates how media brings up the worst from Pakistan.
salman
September 24, 2012 8:00 am
Not really. These guys have had a chance to see the world and that has opened their minds. It is not a built in gene that causes people to behave like this. It is the intolerant teachings and this taxi driver proves all it takes is for someone to change our perceptions of things.
Faraz
September 24, 2012 7:57 am
Correct.. Financial/social insecurity has nothing to do with rampant mayhem going on.
Ahmed Sultan (India)
September 24, 2012 4:44 am
MMS made several deals with US he doesn't hate America. Get your facts correct first.
Ahmed Sultan (India)
September 24, 2012 4:40 am
So India is respected you guys started calling yourself Indians. Loser Mentality
Anshu
September 24, 2012 1:50 am
Just wait for the same hard working pakistanis (muslims in general) to form a 5/10% of population and you see the difference. The same guys will take to street demanding sharia law and better respect from the majority. It's for the muslims to decide how to let go of the "Us Vs. Them" attitude and learn to "Accept differing views". The interesting part is the taxi driver didn't say "The movie maker had a right of expression" rather he conveniently termed the whole thing as "some peoples" mischief.
Anshu
September 24, 2012 1:39 am
well said. and it's a sad truth.
qzj00
September 24, 2012 1:02 am
Regarding the first sentence of your post, even if we were to assume that this person would/could have been ". . . .the very Pakistanis who burn US flags in Pakistan, destroy public and private property in Pak-the scence which was repeated on the Love Day! ...." the question that needs to be asked is WHAT IS THE REASON that this person will NOT do it now . . . . unless you are saying that he was lying? Regarding the second sentence of your post, "They also recently took peaceful protest against the movie in US and Canada", aren't you contradicting yourself!!
Fida Sayani
September 24, 2012 12:45 am
What a socialist is doing in American financial center.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 10:16 pm
That's right!
Joe
September 23, 2012 10:11 pm
Here in Florida (USA) we have neighbors from Afghanistan. Our family doctor is Indian. Another friend is from Afghanistan. Together we can go to two Indian restaurants, a Pakistani restaurant (amazing pakoras!), and a Lebanese restaurant. We shop at an Indian market and an Iranian market. They have halal food and goods from everywhere on the shelves. We meet people and their families from multiple countries there. Folks simply just get along as normal human beings.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 10:08 pm
It is not that simple,they are tools in the hands of unscruplus politicians and so called religious scholars,it is there bread and butter or is mutton ghost ,chapathy,parata and biryani or all of them.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 10:01 pm
it is about 91% ,but the other observation is on the dot.Same with Pseudo liberal leftist Indians too.They hate USa,but their Children all live in USA,including MMS and Sharad Power.Check it if you do not believe,I know my information.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 9:51 pm
You are right,it is not that simple cut and dry or is it paste?Ghaziabad was a very good Example,the authority always take easy way out since 1947,that is no way to run modern nations,we will always remain backward,that way.It was same on 11th Aug in Mumbai,they patted each other on back,saying it could have been worse. As far Nadeembhai observation,it is partly true,and part not so.Our people's problem is very complex,there is not just one cause.We are in essence very retrogressive ,religious dogamatic people,we literally believe everything,I will give you an example,it will offened lot of Indians and my co religininst,I can only talk about my religion and my experience,if I'm not right,it my opinion.I'm not a part of any organised religion,but like Iyn Rand will take up arms to defend my hindu way of life.One can strongly feel that without the 9 yards of overt religion.I know I do not have to believe in the story of Lord Ganesha losing his head and head replaced by elephant one to be patriotic nationalist.To reach the level of awareness of what Rand talkjs about,the society has to reach a level of scientific advancement,education,rule of law,very social and civic solid institutional sofistication,plus very mature democracy,in absense of that,real mature behavior is impossible.We can be religious,yes christian believe that Jesus was born of a vargin birth,without his grace one can not attain salvation,are they willing to burn down Manhattan,no Sir,they do not,that is our differance,we will burn down Karachi or Cairo.How do we reach were West is?If you know that,I will eat your most dirty & smelly soocks.Nice day.
BHB
September 23, 2012 8:54 pm
There isn't anything remarkable about the Taxi Driver or any of what you observed. That's just how life is in any modern multicultural, tolerant, secular society. People are able to separate the rice from the chaff, keep things in perspective and move on. They are simply focused on making a good life for themselves and their families. Faith is kept close to the hearts not worn on the sleeve.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 8:51 pm
Very good observation,it beats me why?Most people who are there know what they are in for,but food is very good.I remember I was a sales Engineer in late 60's for mid town Manhattan,there were many Pakistani boutiqe store(Indian/Pak Cotton cloths was very popular then,it is no longer now),the Pakistani's were lot more friendly(I love to sing Gazals and talk in Urdu,beside I was 99% desi,then),I used to have best of time(2 reasons,I was young,never been corrupted by CHING -_CHING,dollars,so I was just a very nice guy to talk to,,even now i still have that,but very selective,time & knocks does that to you,often),but Pakistani's are just nice(stay away from discussing religion& Cricket),you will enjoy their co,one more thing,no malice here intended,they I mean both male & female way better looking than most people from rest of sub-continent.Females and girls out of the world.Nice day.
The_Progressive_Conservative
September 23, 2012 8:46 pm
They were no protests in Saudi Arabia either but would you say Saudi Arabia has a tolerant culture? This episode has nothing to do with culture but with education. The ones protesting are 95% uneducated and unable to critically analyse or understand an issue. The educated ones amongst us understand the purpose of the video (ie to provoke a reaction) and have simply ignored it with the quiet disdain and disgust it deserves.
Pradip
September 23, 2012 8:38 pm
Very sensible statement. I must ruefully state that I had one or two Muslim classmates at IIM where I had studied and out of sheer callousness and ignorance, I did not get to know them better....my loss.
Pradip
September 23, 2012 8:31 pm
May I say that your story of Pakistanis in front of PIA counter resonates completely with me? I was at JFK to fly to India on Emirates and the picture was no better. In fact I tried flying even on Lufthansa and after a few hours, you cannot enter the bathroom any longer. The smell is overpowering and the floor is inundated. Poor stewardesses as the Indians (and I am one too) think it is someone else's job to clean up after them and/or does not know how to use a bathroom. And then wait, once the aircraft lands, it is immediately a mad scramble to get out.... There are more things that unite us ...the Indians and Pakistanis, only the religion thing is different...LOL.
BRR
September 23, 2012 7:59 pm
The same people who torch the US embassy one day will line up outside it for a visa the next day.
suneel
September 23, 2012 7:41 pm
yes, we are all Indian....although, name of our political units are different.....I wonder, why Pakistan did not choose a name like "India" or "west India" or "Islamic Republic of India"....We in here use Bhartiya, Indian and Hindustan interchangeably when changing between Local, gulf (Urdu, Persian, Arabic) and Western language. We are still proud of our history and culural heritage including most of the muslim time. How many Pakistani are proud of Buddhist/Hindu/Jain/Sikh contribution to the land which is called "Pakistan"? this is here they lose right to use name India. They can still use it in ethnic term though.
Anant
September 23, 2012 7:08 pm
I think khan wanted to comment out their reluctance of calling themselves Pakistani. By all means India today means 'Bharat' an no way does it represent Pakistan.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 6:38 pm
The dawn is much better,tolerant than TOI,I often have to rewrite 5 times before they will publish one,they are very strict ,they have to survive in sharl infested waters,I hope you will understand their limitations,they are in business for very long time.They are survivors,and I do not fault them,I used to write in Tribune,they give more slack,but I stopped there as it is infested with very rude and out right rascals who do not think twice in abuseing in most foul language.You will never see me there,you are good,i enjoy your comment,nice day.
h.mani
September 23, 2012 6:30 pm
There is nothing wrong for a native from Indo/Pak are calling himself/herself Indian/Pakistani or anything else,I often travel in New york as I'm retired,most often cab is either pakistani or sardarji,they are both very well behaved,they are extremely friendly,I tip them good,always talk to them in Urdu,they often think I'm muslim or Pakistani,I tell them guys from Hyderabad(daccan) are very well versed in Urdu,and me even know read/write urdu,since now I'm reader of Dawn and Tribune,well informed than most Indians.I think we can have reasonable friendly relations if we can avoid repeat of 11/26 and concentrate on trade and commerse,and stay away about merit or demerits of our respt,religion,we will be better off.To me we can do well,if we do not talk religion,there is no common ground,to be honest one need not have one,what common ground between A jew & Hindu,but we get along just fine.That is good model to follow,neither better nor inferior.Nice day.
Praveen
September 23, 2012 6:21 pm
Dear Nfp, with all u r rational mind how did u miss d point . Your taxi driver, looks , talks sensibly because he is a tiny minority in US. He will be d first one to smash a wind shield of a bus, torch a car,attack d kafirs if had been living in a Muslim majority society.
metric
September 23, 2012 6:12 pm
Mr Faisal.. you said the truth, and only truth.
Krish Chennai
September 23, 2012 5:41 pm
Aw, Guru, maybe he was born before 47, and felt similar to what LK Advani expressed, when it came to his election id turn, said he was from "undivided India". Give a chance, will you !!! And even otherwise, do remember, it is still referred to "Indian sub-continent", for whatever it is worth.
Imran
September 23, 2012 4:35 pm
Rasheed Sb the answer to your query is very simple. In Middle Eastern and Western countries there is the rule of law and the law is enforced. Our people are laaton ke bhoot that is why they have to abide by the law once they arrive there. All these hooligans of the last few days knew one thing: no one will challenge or arrest them.
Abdus Salam Khan
September 23, 2012 4:32 pm
There is nothing sad about a Pakistani calling himself an Indian; in fact,he is more deserving of the title of an Indian, because the word India is derived from the mighty Indus river that flows mainly through Pakistan. Remember, India was divided in to Bharat and Pakistan, so each one of their citizen is entitled to call himself an Indian, meaning a person coming from the Indian sub-continent. Sadly, you, the Bharatis have misapproriated the term Indian to mean Bharatis, which is wrong historically and factually.
Faisal Ahmed
September 23, 2012 4:31 pm
These very kind of Pakistanis like the ones who drive Taxis in NY and do other odd jobs, who now pretend to be peaceful, law abidding US citizens are the very Pakistanis who burn US flags in Pakistan, destroy public and private property in Pak-the scence which was repeated on the Love Day!, insist US is behind every conspiracy against islam and Pak, but will leave no effort to get to US and Europe even by illegal means. They also recently took peaceful protest against the movie in US and Canada. So Nadeem you should have ask the taxi driver question Shoail Waracih always ask in his progam aik din geo key saath : "Kia ye Khulla Tazada nahi"??? (clear hypocrpiy)
Imran
September 23, 2012 4:30 pm
Very few Pakistanis hate America as a country, only the policies of it's government. Theres a difference.
Imran
September 23, 2012 4:25 pm
YOU REALLY ARE GANGADIN AREN'T YOU
Nisha Rai
September 23, 2012 4:08 pm
If you say you are an Indian, people will always assume that your are from "Bharat". It does not matter what you assume.
Guru
September 23, 2012 3:56 pm
Abdus, now that is some ingenious justification. Our passport says "Republic Of India", not "Republic of Bharat". BTW, what does your passport say, does it say India anywhere?
A Vetta
September 23, 2012 3:41 pm
Dear NFP; I read your pieces often. Now, they remind me of an Urdu couplet by the poet Aslam. “Khoogre nalan samjh kar mujh ko, Aslam, Akhir, Tang Aa K mary aahoon ney be asser chor diya”. (Convinced that I addicted to cries (complaints), my cries lost effect). Any solution, please?
Saz
September 23, 2012 3:23 pm
Why must we protest , should we not offer durod and ignore the idiots you tube video with the disgust it deserves and it will die it's own death. As of right now we have adhered exactly to the script written but the makers of the video.
arcane
September 23, 2012 3:02 pm
YES!
gangadin
September 23, 2012 2:47 pm
so what's your point?
Prashant
September 23, 2012 2:11 pm
Then would u agree Pakistanis are hypocrites?
lalit bagai
September 23, 2012 1:28 pm
i made a few comments wrt cyril almeidas article. it was removed by a click by the moderator.disappeared after a short life of 5 seconds. if dawn has such intolerance about the slightest difference in opinion, what must be the mindset of the mob on the streets. i am indian, liveng in danmark. you said that the taxi driver could not see whether you were pakistani or an indian. thats neither of us has a symbol of the crecent or the svastik on our foreheads. i like your article. well done. new york is a great place.
A. Nabi Baloch
September 23, 2012 1:23 pm
Bhatti Did you ever realize that Indian Muslims work even harder to prove themselves patriotic Indians when pakistanis were causing trouble in India. The first ten years after partition things were very difficult for muslims who did not migrate to Pakistanis.
Khan
September 23, 2012 1:03 pm
NFP, an insightful article as usual. I have lived in US for six years, I am an Indian. One observation I have made in last few years is, that Pakistanis in general have lost their self-esteem here; to avoid embarrassment and maybe for economical reasons, a lot of pakistanis here who are involved in day jobs, claim themselves to be Indians in front of western customers etc, which is sad.
Abdus Salam Khan
September 23, 2012 1:03 pm
To understand the Muslim psyche, the following couplet from Iqbal puts it in a nutshell. He makes Satan instruct his disciples thus: Yeh faqa-kash joe mowt say darta nahin zara rooh-e-Muhammad iss kay baddan say nikaal doe ( This starving Muslim who has no fear of death Remove the Spirit of Muhamamd from his body!} This evil film was an attempt to do just that. So let us remember that since Muhammad(PBUH) came as a Mercy unto all mankind, we also follow his example by being a mercy to all mankind. Let us not burn and destroy, rather, we should present the loving face of islam to all mankind. I commend the taxi-drivers of New York for doing just that. And I condemn all the Mullah-led zealots who have used this incident to burn and destroy.
Mack
September 23, 2012 12:56 pm
dear Crayo, It doesn't take a movie or a cartoon to spark violence in Pakistan and many fanatic countries. Last week, in Ghaziabad (India), a muslim mob burnt down a police station and police vans , and six died in police shoot out, over a piece of paper found from trash, that was hyped upto the level of Blasphemy. So, you are still living in a state of denial when you say that it was the movie that caused the riot. Maybe this week's riots were caused by the anti-hate movie, but what about the last week's riot, or suicide bombs that will occur in october or november?
Abdus Salam Khan
September 23, 2012 12:50 pm
Correction: India was divided in to Bharat and Pakistan; so if ,I, as a Pakistani, call myself an Indian I am not passing off as an Indian; I am an Indian, bgecause I belong to this sub-continent called India
G.A.
September 23, 2012 12:15 pm
Why is it that Pakistani restaurants in the West always have Urdu news blaring into your heads from their multiple tv sets. You simply cannot have a fine dining experience as they never play light music in the background and use tube lights, which are for offices, to light up the place. Are they afraid to offend customers if they play music? There used to be music before the Zia came along. Contrast this with how well the Indians and Bangladeshis do it. Dawn please publish this as I am desperately trying to tell Pakistani restaurant owners.
Karachi Wala
September 23, 2012 12:13 pm
As someone stated "when I first arrived in New York about 26 years ago, no one knew where and what Pakistan was. Now everyone knows about Pakistan, and for all the wrong reasons. Before 9/11, Pakistanis were proud users of all the bad habits, tricks and trade learnt back home. They used all the short cuts to get ahead and proudly used and abused the system." These days 9/11 may have softened the bad habits and manners of Pakistanis. People like taxi driver NFP met, try to put their best face when dealing with non "desis" but as soon as they get to the PIA counter at JFK, the Pakistani within jumps out. One can see the same pushing and shoving and most certainly no lines are followed. No sane person should be surprised to see what is coming out from Pakistan these days. Without any doubt it is the result of mixing the religion with the state affair. NFP has written numerous articles about the rise of Ziayyat, JI and Saudi funded Madrasah system, all the right ingredients for the destruction of Pakistan. With each passing day, Pakistanis take to the street to prove it right.
Atique
September 23, 2012 11:30 am
@NFP... How can you put across the opinion of a taxi driver as the lens through which to view the thinking of general American public. Go see the comments given under news reports in CNN and Fox News. They show a completely different picture.
Sukhbir
September 23, 2012 11:29 am
Dear Nadeem Bhai Keep up your good work. May the almighty give you long life to bring sense to the citizens of Pakistan.
Sukhbir
September 23, 2012 11:25 am
On the other hand there are some like me who poitedly tell all "I was born in Pakistan" yet not once in last 22 years have any one white, black, brown, Jew, Gentile, Christain or an atheist treated me different. Hiding your identity is not the answer. Changing your identity to be an Americanis the only answer. One cannot be an American and some thing else. Either you are an American or still struggling to melt in this great pot.