It's official: We are not a nation. We are a mob.

All those ‘think positive’ types waiting for some kind of a ‘moderate Muslim awakening’ in this country are simply deluding themselves.

No amount of your egos, resources and ‘positiveness’ invested in ‘moderatism’ such as interfaith dialogues, Sufi music, lectures by ‘moderate clerics and Islamic scholars’, and your insistence on how peaceful our faith truly is, all this won’t make an iota of a difference.

You are fighting a battle that you have already lost; simply because all the mindless violence in the name of faith in this country has been tolerated for too long, sometimes even rewarded.

Thus, who should the mad mob which loots, burns, plunders and kills in the name of God and his messenger be afraid of? Not the police, not the courts, not the media, not the government and believe me, not even the Almighty himself!

Why should they? How can they when such mobs and those who fire them up have all been playing God themselves – judging, condemning and executing everyone and everything they deem ‘unIslamic’, heretical, blasphemous and infidel, without fear, remorse, or any chance of ever being reprimanded.

This faith-driven madness is not a recent happening. It’s been accumulating for decades.

And every time it has reared its ugly head in the shape of belligerent mob violence, it has not been dealt with the help of the law but with words and gestures that actually end up justifying it.

__________________________

In 1954 the former Chief Minister of Punjab, Mumtaz Daultana, after failing to solve the problem of food shortages and unemployment in the province, encouraged rabid hordes belonging to the Jamat-e-Islami (JI) to instigate anti-Ahmadi violence just to divert the people’s anger from his failing ministership.

Though Daultana was ultimately removed from his post, soon after the commotion all those arrested for instigating the violence, damaging public property and attacking members of the Ahmadi community were released unconditionally.

Then in 1974, the popularly elected Prime Minister, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, capitulated like a man made from jelly when the JI used another round of anti-Ahmadi violence in Punjab as a way to reignite its failing fortunes and ask Bhutto to declare the besieged community as non-Muslim.

Instead of condemning mob violence, Bhutto, the great progressive democrat, did exactly what the mob demanded. As if overnight the Ahmadi community that had played a major role in the creation of Pakistan and was one of the most vigorous contributors to the new country’s economy, was reduced to becoming second-class citizens.

How many Pakistanis questioned Bhutto’s cynical move or JI’s politics of hate? None.

All that the reactionary Ziaul Haq dictatorship (1977-88) had to do was to turn such politics of hate into actual state policy, thus beginning the now consolidated Pakistani tradition of churning out a continuous flow of blood-thirsty sectarian and Islamist outfits.

But more dangerously, these policies eventually generated an ethos that promised material, political and spiritual rewards and benefits for anyone willing to become violent, self-righteous, exhibitionist and hypocritical in matters of faith.

However, once the great tyrant and mastermind of this mindset blew up somewhere over Bhawalpur in August 1988, did the democrats that replaced him reverse the tide?

Not quite.

In 1995, late Benazir Bhutto’s Interior Minister, Naseerullah Babar, was busy sitting with ISI sleuths conceiving the creation of a dreadful and barbaric force that became to be known as the Taliban.

They said they were doing this to ‘end the civil war in Afghanistan and stabilise the region,’ all the while turning a blind eye to all the atrocities being committed by their creations once they took power in Kabul.

It was thus ironic that when Benazir was brutally killed in December 2007, the killers had used the services of Pakistani Islamists who had in turn been inspired by the same Taliban that Benazir Bhutto’s interior ministry had created with the help of Saudi money and ISI expertise.

Meanwhile, the other great democrat of the 1990s, Mian Nawaz Sharif, till even about 1996, was passionately leading emotional processions to Ziaul Haq’s grave site in Islamabad and promising to ‘continue Shaheed Zia’s mission.’

Though he finally faced a few assassination attempts by members of a sectarian organisation in Punjab in the late 1990s, this didn’t stop some of his party members to hold hands with leaders of the same banned organisation in 2009!

The so-called moderates let out a sigh of relief when a military gung-ho, General Pervez Musharraf, toppled Nawaz and positioned himself as a Pakistani Attaturk.


Comments are closed.

Comments (187)

Imran
September 24, 2012 8:12 am
Thank you Gupta Ji for your kind feelings and the DNA bit. The sharing of DNA certainly explains a lot.
Imran
September 24, 2012 8:09 am
And what brings you here Amol? Same old story. Hate us but still obsessed with us. And then you claim its we who are focussed on you.
andleeb (Canada)
September 24, 2012 8:01 am
Your comments reek of anti-Islam. Our atomic weapons are a divine gift for a nation that truly believes in Allah. No other muslim nation was chosen by Allah to have such a gift. The fact that Abdul Quadeer Khan has such poor scientific knowledge and yet made the atom bomb shows the divine power that allowed it. Allah chose him even if he has no knowledge of physics because he is a true muslim. You sound like a Hindu from India pretending to be a Pakistani from your comment.
Imran
September 24, 2012 7:57 am
Gulshan, right now just go to any Indian newspaper, go to the archives of this anti-Islam movie and read the comments of these so called liberal educated Indians over there. Then come back and tell me what you see and how you feel. Believe me there is nothing liberal or cultured about them, its only that if they show their true colours here their comments will not be published.
Imran
September 24, 2012 7:46 am
I think we should start apologizing more loudly to all these minorities. That would be a good start.
Imran
September 24, 2012 7:44 am
Would have been worse with the Hindus, trust me. Might have taken less than 60 years.
Dixit
September 24, 2012 7:41 am
You are truely a rational person Mr. Khurram. Your kind of people are realy a boon to the society.
Bilal
September 24, 2012 7:38 am
I know what we need! We need a revolution, like the 1917 revolution in Russia. Ban all religions. Beat this religious crap out of mullahs and whole society. Hope that answers your question.
Whatever...
September 24, 2012 7:36 am
One piece of advice bro..... never feel sorry for acknowledging or stating a fact. There is nothing wrong in calling apples apples. If your passport requires acknowledging that summers are hot and winters are cold.......... what's wrong in approving that, when it's a win-win situation for all... you get your passport and all legal formalities are satisfied as well.
ahmed41
September 24, 2012 7:15 am
So~~~~~~am i to conclude that in Pakistan , religion is not working ? In theory religion should be a force for good. In actual practice it continues relentlessly to be the just the opposite .
Shankar
September 24, 2012 6:55 am
Mr. Milton, if you need points to bash India, there are plenty. Ill treating Sikhs is not one of them.
Samresh
September 24, 2012 6:54 am
Only about 7% ran away from Hindus. Chased away the Hindus would be more appropriate.
Nauman
September 24, 2012 6:49 am
What a lovely reaction to man shouting his shoes off, around the corner. Love you patience Samir. Imran, I'm a pakistani and just couldn't understand how you stereotyped everyone in a population, that of 1/6th of the planet :) Salute to your intelligence dude.
Nomi
September 24, 2012 6:18 am
I generally don't always agree with NFP but this article is so unbiased and spot on the root issues.
Nadeem
September 24, 2012 6:14 am
The problem with media (and the most of the writers) is that they either have deliberately closed their eyes and have opened a part of them just to look at the violent incidents. If you turn around and look around honestly, most of the protests were peaceful that were nowhere shown on the media. A few violent protests, which are only 5% - 7% of the total, don't justify to call a nation a mob ! For God sake, be honest with yourself. I won't say "be honest with the country", because your actions make up your own character. And because you are the people who got a chance to raise a voice, to spread some message or information, you will strictly be asked in the next world about what you told to people. So, to be honest to yourself, be honest to others, thanks.
TruePak
September 24, 2012 5:28 am
Correction, KS of A, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the wahabi capital of the world and illegal occupier of Hijaz !!!!!
Girish
September 24, 2012 5:25 am
Hello Mustafa, What is your role in all this mess? People like you who got educated using public funds...what are your responsibilities. One of my favorite passtime is watching pakistani TV shows on youtube. It is hilarious to see educated pakistanis blaming every one but themselves. Educated middle class in any country sets the tone for social/political discourse and body politics. Vibratnt, assertive middle class is the need of the hour to build progressive, inclusive and tolerant society. Pakistan is today a jungle raj. Worst than many african nations becuase educated hypocrites like you have built weapons of mass distruction and then fled the country...leaving this arsenal in the hands of mullahs. You have no symphathy from me.
hasan
September 24, 2012 5:21 am
You are in urgent need of help. Please get it soon.
Gulshan
September 24, 2012 4:28 am
Please respect Our soverginity. Don't interfere. The $100,000 will come from next instalment the US is going to give us for fighting against the Qsama's men we trained.
chakraborty
September 24, 2012 4:24 am
No Sanjib, If India would have been United we would be facing problems like Nigeria where Muslim Christian ratio is almost 50:50. India would have been in a civil war. We have shed our extra flab/ weight in 1947. I am happy for the division
With respect,
September 24, 2012 4:18 am
Dear writer, if some people (numbering hardly 0.05% of total protestors nationwide), had already planned the day earlier to cause mischief in the name of Prophet (pbuh) for their material gains, then it is not the protestors fault. Most or almost all of the violence was reported in major cities like Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad, Peshawar. Tires were burnt (at the max) in many other cities. No person from JI, PTI, MQM, or any other religious party (shia or sunni) was allowed to throw a stone or damage property. Absolutely not a fan of Hafiz Saeed & his views but the rally that he lead, didn't hurl a single stone. If Pakistan is burned, torched, looted, destroyed after Benazir Bhutto is assasinated, this doesn't mean that she had this gigantic number of "aashiqaans" or "jaan nisaars" out there burning property, carrying away ATM's, raping girls who could not reach home due to non availability of transport etc. You sir, know better than me that they are opportunity seekers waiting for any suitable time to get down and dirty. Calling such demons as real protestors is maligning actual peaceful protestors and the cause itself and a horrible generalization. Clearly, the population you discussed in the article is on one extreme, but you sir, with due respect are also not on a neutral or unbiased viewpoint, you are also on another extreme.
Ali
September 24, 2012 4:18 am
The writer has not said anything that we all are not aware of, pointing out the problem is the easiest bit ...... what is the solution? Or is there one? We all, the writer and the people who have commented on this piece (including myself) and the entire intellect of Pakistan that sit in the drawing room and discuss how bad things have become my question to them is, how many times have you actually gone out and voted in your lives? Some of you may be young and the others never cared! One who are young it is time for you to bring the change and let the process continue. So what if Zardari comes back to power .... as long as it is as per the due process. Time will take us out of this chaos ..... In my opinion the process has to continue ...... we will have to vote for the best available candidate and with time things will fall in their place. And that time may not happen in your or my life time but if our will is strong enough our children will live in a better country.
Gulshan
September 24, 2012 4:11 am
Wah Wah Imran Sahib. I wish I had gone to same Madarssa as you have. The way you answered Zaid Hamid, makes you a a strong Paki Muslim and shows how Madarssa has changed your character. With people like you Pakistan is going be a leader of the Islamic World. You have shown how Islam has made us so great. Pakistan Zindabad. We have atom Bomb, bigger and stronger than others because it is Islamic. Its technology came from Koran' We will teach America India and Israel a lesson. All our problem came from India, America and Israel. Conspiracy against Islam. We should finish them as soon we have more Atta and Daal and a few more hours of Electricity.
asifiqbal787787@gmail.com
September 24, 2012 3:39 am
Pakistanis ran away from the Hindus to form a nation that would protect them. But little did they realize that their own kind would consume them in just 60 years.
asifiqbal787787@gmail.com
September 24, 2012 3:35 am
WOW! You are a true Muslim. With People like you, the Islamic world can look forward to a very progressive and peaceful existence, but for others, it will be very dismal.
Agoodmaninafrica
September 24, 2012 3:27 am
First they came for the communists, and I did not speak out - because I was not a communist; Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out - because I was not a socialist; Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out - because I was not a trade unionist; Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out - because I was not a Jew; Then they came for me - and there was no one left to speak out for me. Martin Niemoller Pakistan is truly staring at the abyss and until we realize and face the wrongs we have done as a nation, there can be no moving in the right direction. My sincere apologies as a Pakistani to Ahmadis, Christians, Hindus, Parsis and all minorities for the treatment given to them. Shameful how every Pakistani has to sign on their passport application that they believe Ahmadis are non-muslims. This is what we get for breeding hate. When they come to burn my house down because I don't have a beard or wasn't seen at prayers 5 times a day there will certainly be no one left to stand up for me.
Saba
September 24, 2012 3:13 am
I have only read the first line of your piece, as yet and I am so grateful that you have said what you have. I've been saying this for some time now, but when you say it, it means more..! OK going back to read the rest!
Haider
September 24, 2012 3:12 am
Very well written and worthy of a larger debate.
Mohammad Ali Khan
September 23, 2012 11:37 pm
Eswaran, I condemn Bilour.I hope you will condemn the treatment of Shudars in Indian culture.I give credit to Indian law makers that they don't have any thing like Pakistani blasphemy law.
Mohammad Ali Khan
September 23, 2012 11:32 pm
Imran, There is fanaticism in India.Remember the Gujrat pogrom or the massacre of Sikhs after the death of Indira Gandhi.Or the treatment of Shudars.If fanaticism is eradicated, it is less likely that people will tolerate corrupt leadership.It is true for Pakistan and India.
nasir
September 23, 2012 10:23 pm
very well written article.wish t.v. anchors and producers should read it arefully
Rahul
September 23, 2012 9:53 pm
"Sikhs from India (mistreated by Indra Ghandi)": Wait a minute, as of now our PM is a Sikh and Army General is a Sikh, oh u r from Abyss as NFP said, u wont know, my apologies !!!
abc
September 23, 2012 9:44 pm
yes. to spread the "messege of peace" from the "messenger of peace" and to uphold the "religion of peace", sometimes stern actions are required. long live "the land of pure", who are always willing to sacrifice anything for the honour and glory of the holy prophet.
abc
September 23, 2012 9:38 pm
Sikhs from India are integral part of india, while Ahamidis are lost childre of Pakistan, who cannot identify with any religion in its own country
Joe
September 23, 2012 9:24 pm
This is the most powerful article yet from NFP's pen. This subject ought to be an active national debate NOW in the parliament. It should be an urgent speech to the people by the PM. Sadly, it appears that it's getting too late.
Think
September 23, 2012 9:17 pm
I don't know either whether Imran is your real name. I am proud to originate in a country where we have elections, and not ruled by our army. I am proud to belong to a country where there reside millions of Hindus, millions of Muslims and millions of Chrisitans. We are way ahead in technology and education. Start looking at what you can improve in your country-- forget focusing on India. Your constant competition with India has led you all to this state of affairs -- maybe YOU should read your own writer's honest article above more carefully.
Beg
September 23, 2012 9:12 pm
But the destruction done by Bush was not in his religious capacity rather in the evolutionary democratic capacity.open your your eyes khurram
Amol
September 23, 2012 8:55 pm
Why are you banging your head against the wall? The wall is on a path of self-destruction. Sit around, watch and feel relieved that you are not a part of that wall.
asifiqbal787787@gmail.com
September 23, 2012 8:39 pm
Before you point a finger at the other party, have you ever considered what kind of vicious stuff our Muslim brothers say about Indians and their religion? I am sure you have but you chose to forgive your brothers because they are Muslims. This is precisely why many columnists in Pakistan keep screaming that our community is very hypocritical.
Gulshan
September 23, 2012 8:37 pm
Truth, only truth and nothing but the truth. I wonder how many Muslims will be honest enough to accept this truth. Because once you realize this truth, it will be easy to understand as to why Muslims are seen with suspecian..
Mack
September 23, 2012 8:34 pm
I believe for last 60 years there has been only one promise made to people of Pakistan by its rulers. Instead of growth, poverty eradication, progress in human rights and upliftment of underpreviliged, the only agenda of the rulers have been "Lets promise our junta the neverland, a promise to wrest away Kashmir, which will overlook all other shortcomings". In this false promise of wresting away Kashmir, which was an easy promise to make rather than building infrastructure, and creating jobs, and eradicating Madrassa based education system, Pakistan is on verge of losing all what it had. Honestly, Pakistan has become a very big headache for the civilized world; a nuclear-headed monster!
Samir Gupta
September 23, 2012 8:28 pm
Imran, Vasudevaya Kutumbakam (the whole world is a family). Thus, you are our bhai even if you do not like being addressed that way. We certainly share more DNA with you than any other people in the world. There are idiots everywhere including in India. The problem is that due to the political barriers, the young in our countries have never known real people across the border. We just deal with stereotypes. I hope you come and visit us one day and meet the real Indians. Till then, may god bless you. BTW, it is true that people in India are increasingly becoming indifferent to Pakistan (or even to their own countrymen).
Kamal
September 23, 2012 8:07 pm
Great, truthful article by Piracha Saheb. The state, the army, the political parties, the Jihadis, the Talibans terrorists, Islamic militants, the judiciary, the govt, and other elements in the country are fusing together into one big Islamist Fascist country that will ultimately destroy the country and the people...
Mack
September 23, 2012 7:18 pm
I read somewhere, that every nation has bad people; but the real problem starts when good people are indifferent. The same applies to Pakistan, while the Mullahs and maulvis were preaching hate, the good people stayed quiet, and now the good people are complaining that what we are seeing day in, day out, everywhere around, is not real Islam! Then, pray tell me, what is real islam, the one that is not visible, the one that is being preached or follow, is that true islam or true Pakistan? NFP, I agree with everything you are saying, but to sum it up, its plain old bad Karma; the chicken have come home to roost.
Saravanan
September 23, 2012 6:28 pm
Imran - what you say has merit - TOI comments contain equal amount of venom for each other. Whether Indian or Pakistani, there will always be a section which will show and spread hatred. But do please try to understand, that the silent majority wants nothing but peace and prosperity, and this majority is not represented by its politicians on both sides of the border. What you and I can do is, atleast try to engage in talking to each to understand each other better, and make any message board like this as a place of constructive exchange
Imran
September 23, 2012 6:22 pm
And you think my language is vile? You clearly haven't read your own newspapers have you? And why are you guys afraid of using your real names here?
Saravanan
September 23, 2012 6:18 pm
Mr.Paracha, Congratulations on a well written article. The yearning, melancholy and pain behind your words strike a very deep chord somewhere. Though as nations and people, Indians and Pakistanis will always approach each other with suspicion and caution, anyone who has any humanism will not fail to appreciate the weight of your words. Though our country too has its share of woos, the economic prosperity is a factor which has kept religious chauvinism in check, though not fully. But reading your words, as an Indian, I can only sincerely wish good miracles for the future of your country.
Imran
September 23, 2012 6:17 pm
I was referring to the outside ones.
Karachi Wala
September 23, 2012 5:31 pm
@NFP this time you hit the "Bullseye"!!!
milton
September 23, 2012 5:17 pm
the thesis of the writer that every one is frightened of the demon let loose by the political Islam. There is no reprieve.Sorry, but some of us saw it comming before Mr. Paracha was around. Remember Mumtaz Daultana gave Rs. 40,000 thousands from the Punjab education funds to the newspapers that were fueling this fire then. He could afford to foot such donations from his pocket but mean natured people are always ready to use other people's resources to fund their evil deeds. One thing is certain,Sikhs from India (mistreated by Indra Ghandi) and Ahmadis victims of the turn face ZAB, are prospering in the West. The number of high quality professional and creative scientists are out performing their fellow professional in the West. All of them are the children of the victims thrown out by their beloved countries. Sad but true, they still yearn for their "home land" . Thank you Mr. Paracha, More power to your pen.