Sixty-five years ago, India was divided into two countries, Pakistan and India. It was a decision taken by an ageing empire, in its season of decline. World War II had broken the financial back of British Empire.

United India had been destabilised due to widespread support for Subhas Chandra Bose's 'Indian National Army' and other incidents such as the sailor's strike in 1945, and increasing political resentment shown by both the Indian National Congress, All-India Muslim League, and other political parties in India.

It was decided by the British policy makers to let go of India, for Britain’s own good. There was little hesitancy in the transfer of power because India's nationalist leaders including Nehru, Jinnah and Patel were trained in British constitutionals values and this ensured a continuity of systems. This led to division of India in two halves.

Partition on the map led to mass migration across the newly formed border. Families were separated, valuable land was left behind. Arduous journey to the new countries began with nothing but hope for a better future, and the diabolical bloodshed between all sides made it a bitter memory for most that still live on.

Movement across the border was relatively easy in the initial few years. After the 1965 war, which was a result of the botched attempt i.e. Operation Gibraltar, it became difficult to obtain entry across the Pakistan-India border. After 1971, the trust deficit plunged even lower. Due to isolation from each other and propaganda mongering by hawks on either side, generations of Pakistanis and Indians have hated each other. There are three types of views among Pakistanis about relations with India.

The first one is held by right wing hawks (such as the members of Difa-e-Pakistan council and Zaid Hamid) who make no effort to hide their resentment and animosity towards India. This view is peddled by some Urdu press and to a certain extent by our textbooks.

The second view is held by so-called liberal elite which favours an end to hostilities between the two countries and the borders to be wiped off.

There is a third school of thought, which I subscribe to, that accepts the status quo and wants to establish neighbourly relations with India on equal basis.

It is my firm belief that the only way for normalisation in relations between the two countries is through people-to-people contacts. We do not need to tear down the border but we must tear down the wall of hate separating the two countries.

Unfortunately, the discourse on Pakistan-India relations has been held hostage, since Independence, by militaries and hawks in both countries. It must not be forgotten that the few times of normal relations with India that we enjoyed were, under civilian governments.

The major roadblock to people-to-people contacts is the brutal visa regime of both countries towards each other that is currently functional. People from both sides of the border face difficulties in acquiring visas to visit the other country for either tourism or meeting loved ones.

There have been many high-profile people that suffered due to this regime. Last year, Mohammad Hanif, celebrated Pakistani novelist, had to face a lot of difficulty in obtaining a visa to India for participation in a Literature Festival. Similarly, an Indian journalist based in Islamabad was not allowed to fly to Karachi to take part in the Karachi Literature Festival. In the recently held India-Pakistan social media mela, the participants got their visas at the eleventh hour, that too on intervention of our Interior Minister, Rehman Malik.

Based on interviews with people from Pakistan and India who have travelled across the border, I came to know about the various difficulties faced by them. Visas are not issued till the last moment, police-reporting can be added to the visas making the life of visitors difficult and spooks from respective countries often interrogate and harass them just to be intimidating.

It should be understood that the problem lies with both parties and not just one. India, for instance, recently made it mandatory for Pakistani visitors to have a ‘sponsor’ in India if they want to visit. This is not a very welcoming step and simply adds to the nuisance value.

In Pakistan, there has been an effort by a Lahore-based organisation to get a petition (addressed to the prime minister of Pakistan) signed for a Relaxed Indo-Pak Visa Regime. They had to face numerous difficulties, including some ‘interference’ from our deep state agents.

People in Pakistan and India need to realise what they are losing out on by ignoring each other. India is one of the largest consumer markets in the world right now and Pakistani traders deserve to expand into that market and vice versa.


Comments are closed.

Comments (136)

FreedomSpeech
September 13, 2012 1:35 am
Pakistan and India are huge masses of population. Of course we should live peacefully and prosper together. Keep life simple and sweet. Do not fall too much in the religion crap. Keep your faith to yourself and strive for betterment in life using human values. That way you can sustain it. It is no surprise that the west has now dominated the east for over 500 years now. Because they are liberal minded, yet very intelligent in the fact that they understand that liberal is the most sustainable.
dr j k sinha, hyderabad, india
September 12, 2012 1:19 pm
The view expressed by Dr.Abid makes great sense. Love, not hate, your kneighbor should be our new slogan. Problems are bound to crop up every now and then. This happens even in close knit families. But they are us settled amicably and in joy and sorrow we share. Once people of the two countries are able to meet each other freely all the barriers will start crumbling. Trust and love is the need of the hour.
Yakub khan
September 12, 2012 10:01 am
Pakistan has been declared a rogue country by the international community. That may not imply that all Pakistanis are unreliable and untrustworthy but it does raise the question of increase in the Muslim militancy in India if the border restrictions are lifted. With increased influence of al quida in Pakistan one needs to be extreemely careful in letting the border between India and Pakistan become a gateway for increased militancy and further terrorist attacks in this country.
Kesar
September 12, 2012 9:08 am
Well, Azhar, I'm a Pakistani and fully concur with the views of A. Shah. You need to get a reality check or better still get your head out of the sand.
MOHAMMAD
September 12, 2012 1:50 am
the best way to develop relations is improve trade, and solve all issues.
Anjaan
September 12, 2012 1:09 am
No one can reat down this wall which took almost hundred years to build. However the wall would fall apart on its own, only if Pakistan and India can manage to have peaceful coexiatence for atleast two generations. The process has to start in Pakistan by removing hate from the school text books.
pathanoo
September 11, 2012 6:30 pm
AGREED.
Beg
September 11, 2012 5:40 pm
You are degrading get Canadians since they are at par to their southern neighbor,no less and Canadian will not be inferior in any aspect.this shows Indian psuedo sense of supiority. Over their neighbors which in fact reflect Indian inferiority complex. Which in turn is due to the thousand year muslim and british domination over India in the past.Americans and Canadians are mutually respectful and that is what is needed by both Indian and pakistani friends if they want to prosper
Vineeth
September 11, 2012 1:13 pm
The expereince of the last 65 years has shown that this attitude of 'resolve all disputes first, friendship will happen after that' has not taken us anywhere near the solution. Emotions aside, it is only logical that resolution of such core disputes needs an atmosphere of trust and mutual understanding. India and China recognized this principle and have adopted the same method to resolve many of their border disputes.
Deepu, delhi
September 11, 2012 11:01 am
'Sooner the Indian leadership realizes it, better...'! This type of mindset which is the dividing factor. It won't be fair if onus of making peace rests only with India. It is also not making sense of equating India and Pakistan for due reasons.
FAIR DINKUM
September 11, 2012 10:29 am
This visa development between these two countries is much appreciated,but reporting to the police like criminals is not acceptable and we know how they behave for corruption in both countries.
Ravi
September 11, 2012 10:16 am
Yes, yes very big concessions in 1999 and 2008
R.Albuquerque
September 11, 2012 8:28 am
Some Pakistanis say - resolve the Kashmir issue first and then we will be friends. Some Indians say- be friends first and let's discuss Kashmir later. Which argument makes sense? Which course of action will yield the resolution of this issue? This is something we need to think about.
Amit Singh
September 11, 2012 7:17 am
Oh yeah any ways you living in Canada ain't you and people far away from reality can talk the way you do because you are very far away from suffering.
Amit Singh
September 11, 2012 7:15 am
I will partially agree with you but I think we all as a human being have to change and start respecting each other even we Indians have our share of lunatic elements
Amit Singh
September 11, 2012 7:13 am
very well said sir
Hassan
September 11, 2012 6:32 am
Couldn't agree more sir, we have focused on keeping the old theories alive and have spent all our energy to keep the past in the present and let the future suffur. The result shows that the human aspact from our societies has diminished significantly. Focus on humanity can only take us out of our troubles.
B. Ally
September 11, 2012 6:25 am
Good neighbourly relations . Just that for now and future will take care of itself on the goodwill which exits on both sides.
Akhter Husain
September 11, 2012 6:21 am
Mr Abid has very articulately expressed his mind-set regarding "wall of hatred",but seems to be short of saying what he,in fact,desires.Most of us commonly missing one important point here, that is,it is not hatred that is causing problems,but the rivalry for being an important player in this region and better bargaining position to play with.Close and friendly relations would depend on resolutions of all pending disputes with India.Sooner the Indian leadership realizes it ,better it would be for both the peoples of the two countries.
Hassan
September 11, 2012 6:19 am
Pakistan and India will have to have a liberal visa policy and genuine love for eachother if they want to see their coming generations happy and progressive in their lives. Two nation theory seemed suitable to the leaders of that time so they went forward with it; things change with time and so does the theories, evolution is a reality of this world so please deal with the future; the glory is in the future don't try to find it in the past otherwise you will keep on going round and round and round.
Akhter Husain
September 11, 2012 5:55 am
Wellsaid
vij
September 11, 2012 3:47 am
the 2 nation theory was POLITICAL theory , if there was any such in practice Indian Muslims should have perished by now.. Thhere are more Muslims in India than in pakistan . We had a Muslim President , Have Muslims Occupying highest posts in all Govt organisations , Agreed there are Religious riots in india , but these are a part and parcel of every Mixed societyies where differences happen and also solved ...
Dinesh
September 11, 2012 3:37 am
That's really great step. It seems time has come to pack holidays bag , and to full fill childhood dream to visit my ancestors moth land that's Pakistan
Allaisa Xuver
September 11, 2012 3:16 am
The biggest problem with Pakistan is trying to equate itself with India. Like a frog trying compete with an elephant. Mexico does not ask for sovereign equality with my country USA. Even Canada does not ask for it. Once you accept that and extend hand of friendship to India (not by sending terrorists to Mumbai) I am sure most Indians will accept it.
mohit
September 11, 2012 2:35 am
I like your thoughts, sir. I live in one of the western countries and have met, worked and lived with numerous people from Pakistan. this has led a great deal to form a very positive opinion about Pakistan. More people to people contact would certainly beneficial as people of both nations would see that there really isnt much cultural difference between two countries. Friendly relations between two countries will really benefit both nations.
turthbetold
September 11, 2012 1:23 am
Good article and I 2nd this notion. Tear down the Hate and Fear of 60+ years and lets do something that both Ghandhi and Jinnah would be proud of today. At least ONE thing we can do for the men who gave India it's freedom and created Pakistan
Akil Akhtar
September 10, 2012 11:54 pm
Another tolerant indian
Kanwal Kapur
September 10, 2012 11:34 pm
Well written. I totally endorse your views. Let us hold each others hands with love and friendship. We must accept,and respect, each other as proud sovereign nations, and engage in mutually rewarding activities. If we work together, both of us put together can achieve superpower status very soon. God bless Pakistan and India.
Khurram
September 10, 2012 9:59 pm
If I may ask what are you are doing in Canada? I am a Canadian and there is no place here for your kind of intolerant people.
S. S. Bakshi
September 10, 2012 5:36 pm
@Raju I am as patriotic as anyone else. I have served in the Indian Army and proud to have been a part of it. MY blood boils equally if not more than yours when Kargil or 26/11 takes place. Only that I do not believe in hating a religion without a reason. If you hate someone, he is equally entitled to hate you and then there should be no complaints.
Junaid
September 10, 2012 5:17 pm
Sorry boss ... i dont agree ... India is probably the only reason of keeping such a large standing army of ours n vice versa. Their slow penetration in our fabric of society as per Sonia Gandhi's saying "we will conquer pakistan culturally" has probably done more damage then we might had thought. We are becoming india-dependent for cable, movies, songs, books, softwares, goods and many other aspects. We have already borne a lot of damage with their frequent terrorist blaming anti Pakistan claims. India's foreign policy has always been based on Kautaliya's policy stating " Immediate neighbour is an enemy while neighbour's neighbour is a friend". Thus, it can never be beneficial for us. Now, please dont tell me they can overtly enter our territory for their needful and we should be proud of it. We have our own identity and exclusively our borders - let us preserve them !
tinyT-rex
September 10, 2012 3:18 pm
andleeb probably knows more indians than all of you and the writer and perhaps knows about the offer of confederation and also you all need to read the book :"jinnah" by jaswant singh. The bollywood infesteed youth of today please wake up to the fact that muslims in india are still second class citizens.
Rao
September 10, 2012 3:07 pm
May be andleeb doesn't like his cousins / relatives in Pakistan to be economically well off so that whenever he comes to Pakistan, he can proudly display his latest gadgets, whereas his cousins can't even dream of having them... and distribute some Angrezi chocolates to the wide-eyed
Vgp
September 10, 2012 2:46 pm
For your kind information, there is already democracy in kashmir run by an elected government. Pls get your fact right first and then comment
SS SODHI
September 10, 2012 2:44 pm
Indian Reader I was Born in Abbottabad and lived in a village in Rawapindi Dist. Will they allow me to visit these places now. Let pak visa section reply
Neo
September 10, 2012 2:36 pm
i am afraid and god forbid it happens, but when you will see a fellow muslim pointing gun at you and ready to kill any second, perhaps thats the time you will realise how naive you have been all throughout the years.
Neo
September 10, 2012 2:33 pm
whats the core problem ???? Balochistan...
Umer
September 10, 2012 2:26 pm
Resolve the Kashmir issue and we'll be friends!
nandi
September 10, 2012 2:26 pm
What a refreshing article, came from your heart. ........Mazza Aa Gaya
Zafar Malik
September 10, 2012 2:16 pm
You cannot blame a whole country for the brutal act of a few. There are a lot of crazy people in Pakistan and may be some in India who are willing to behave like animals, but if you ever have an oppertunity to meet common Pakistanis, you will surprised to see that they don't support such criminal acts.
Aahmed
September 10, 2012 2:15 pm
Can't help agreeing with you. Yes indeed. No muslim leaguer went to jail attempting to throw the british out of india.
john
September 10, 2012 2:03 pm
with people like azhar , no hope in pakistan , current sitiuation will prevail
john
September 10, 2012 1:58 pm
mate you are on the dot,
B R Chawla
September 10, 2012 1:50 pm
I was born in Pakistan in a small tehsil called Tandalyanwala. I spent most of my childhood in a Muslim household of uncle Tuffail who had two begums vying with each others to hold me in their lap. In 1947 History cut a cruel joke on us by separating our families who lived like brothers. It is the hate mantra being chanted by the politicians that keeps us apart. A time has come to stop discussing the veracity of two nation theory or whatever. It Is time to introspect if the pratogonists of the theory would have rejoiced at the radical and intolerant Islam that is being propagated in Pakistan. Secularism as advocated by the father of Pakistan is a causality at the hands of those who swear by him. Hate would never help. Chawla
john
September 10, 2012 1:46 pm
you r right porkchop, we got nothing to do with Pakistanis
john
September 10, 2012 1:45 pm
no way mate
Raja
September 10, 2012 1:36 pm
The phrase "Move on" used by many Pakistani Senior Politicians, including Ms. Hina Rabbani Kahar has lost its sheen. Agreed, you cannot be hostage to history, but one cannot allow history to repeat itself so often.
shamma parveen
September 10, 2012 1:17 pm
unless and until pakistan turns into a secular and a democratic society, its very unlikely that relations between both the countries can be fully normalized
BRR
September 10, 2012 12:50 pm
There is no need to tear down any walls. All that is required to stop hating the other. Things will take their own course politically and economically and new realities set in thereby making intelligent people revisit their stances. But a change in attitude, a change in mindset is needed, at a personal and societal level. All of these VISA regime issues are symptoms of hatred, and a reaction to intolerance and militancy. So let the soceities reform first, before these symptoms are addressed. If Pakistanis continue to hate Indians and want to bomb Mumbai again, or conquer Delhi, why should VISA regimes be loosened?
Bikram
September 10, 2012 12:06 pm
truly said, sir