Pakistanis protesting against the arrest of Christians — File Photo

blasphemy-law-illus670

Pakistanis protesting against the arrest of Christians — File Photo

ISLAMABAD: A lawyer for a young Pakistani Christian girl arrested on blasphemy charges in a poor suburb of Islamabad claimed Thursday he had been refused a meeting with her.

Police arrested the girl, Rimsha, who reportedly has Down's Syndrome, in a low-income neighbourhood of the capital last Thursday after she was accused of burning papers containing verses from the Quran, and remanded her for 14 days.

Rimsha, aged between 11 and 16, is being held in a jail in Islamabad's twin city Rawalpindi, and her case has prompted concern from Western governments and fury from rights campaigners.

“The lawyers are facing difficulties to see the accused girl. The jail authorities have told them to get permission from the top authorities,” Shamaun Alfred Gill, a spokesman for All Pakistan Minorities Alliance (APMA), told AFP.

Her legal team said they had approached the higher authorities in Punjab province but could not get a go ahead for the meeting.

“I myself contacted the inspector general (of prisons) by phone and he told me that he will call me back, but I am still waiting to speak to him,” Tahir Naveed Chaudhry, one of Rimsha's lawyers, told AFP.

“He is not receiving my calls now. Legally, they can't stop a lawyer seeing his client in the jail but the authorities are refusing us a meeting.” But Farooq Nazir, the inspector-general of Punjab prisons, told AFP there was no restriction on Rimsha meeting her lawyer or immediate family and insisted she was being cared for.

Earlier, an activist who said he visited Rimsha said that the girl was too frightened to speak in a prison where she is being held in solitary confinement for her safety.

Christian activist Xavier William said he visited Masih at a police station where she was first held, and then this week in prison.

“She was frightened and traumatised,” William told Reuters.

“She was assaulted and in very bad shape. She had bruises on her face and on her hands,” he added, referring to an attack by a mob in her village on the edge of Islamabad after she was accused of blasphemy.

Rimsha is being held in the same jail as Mumtaz Qadri, the bodyguard who last year gunned down Punjab governor Salman Taseer, who had declared Pakistan's strict anti-blasphemy legislation “a black law”.

Chaudhry said that they have also filed an application with a court in Islamabad to set up a medical panel to determine Rimsha's age.

“We want the court to constitute a commission to judge the age of Rimsha, because, the church records show she is 11 years old only. While her age mentioned in the police report is 16,” he said.

Christians flee girl’s village

Masih’s arrest triggered an exodus of several hundred Christians from her poverty-stricken village after local mosques reported over their loudspeakers what the girl was alleged to have done. Emotions were running high there.

A neighbour named Tasleem said her daughter saw Masih throwing away trash that included the burned religious material.

“If Christians burn our Quran, we will burn them,” she told Reuters.

Other Muslims were more conciliatory.

“We protected the rest of the Christians,” said Masih’s landlord Malik Amjad Mohammad. “People here support them.”

Christians, who make up four per cent of Pakistan’s population of 180 million, have been especially concerned about the blasphemy law, saying it offers them no protection.

Convictions hinge on witness testimony and are often linked to vendettas, they complain.

President Asif Ali Zardari has told officials to produce a report on the girl’s arrest, which has brought protests from Amnesty International, British-based Christian group Barnabas Fund, and others.

Masih is due to appear in court in the next 10 days. She could be formally charged with blasphemy.

Spotlight on blasphemy law

The case has put another spotlight on Pakistan’s anti-blasphemy law, which rights groups say dangerously discriminates against the country’s minority groups.

Under the law, anyone who speaks ill of Islam and the Prophet Mohammad commits a crime and faces the death penalty, but activists say vague terminology has led to its misuse.

Convictions are common, although the death sentence has never been carried out. Most convictions are thrown out on appeal, but mobs have killed many people accused of blasphemy.

Christians, who make up four per cent of Pakistan’s population of 180 million, have been especially concerned about the blasphemy law, saying it offers them no protection.

Convictions hinge on witness testimony and are often linked to vendettas, they complain.


Comments are closed.

Comments (166)

Azhar
August 26, 2012 1:14 pm
As simple as that. I agree.
Azhar
August 26, 2012 12:41 pm
good question!
misaal
August 26, 2012 9:41 am
My tears keep falling and I am suffocating. For God's love please send that innocent child to her home before she goes insane or dies of trauma. Who will be responsible for her that crime? O' my nation, I am not proud of you.
jtar
August 26, 2012 1:43 am
This comment reflects perfectly the ignorance and intolerance that has pushed Pakistan to the brink of self-destruction... "...soon every other Christian would be burning our pious literature in their backyard" -Really? Does anyone really believe such total nonsense? Please don't project your own narrow hateful mindset on other faiths. It may be hard to believe, but Christian teachings are about love, acceptance and tolerance - not hate, rage and intolerance.
shazia
August 25, 2012 8:21 pm
sometimes it feels like sin being born a religious minority.
Raj
August 25, 2012 3:19 pm
How do Pakistani expect fair deal outside Pakistan ??? Does people of other country should act in a same way they are treating minority in their country. Believe me or not that is going to be happened in near future. Then it will be imposible for Pakistani living outside the country to survive.
indur
August 25, 2012 2:15 pm
I was born in karachi pakistan,I do not even dream to visit pakistan.
Engineer
August 25, 2012 12:48 pm
Aren't you supposed to burn pages containing verses of Quran instead of throwing them in trash. Isn't that the proper disposal method.
taimur
August 25, 2012 10:00 am
At the time of Prophet (PBUH), there was a man belong to rural area who pissed unknowingly in the Haram Sharif (holy places in Makkah) in the presence of our beloved Prophet (PBUH) and His companions. On seeing this, companion got angered on him and asked Prophet in order to stop him from pissing. Prophet told them let him piss and once he was over with piss, Prophet asked companions now call that indl but with respect. Prophet told him that this is Haram (holy place) and next time dont repeat it. before doing something first we should inquire into the matter and this is what Holy Quran says, so if she is really young and having down Syndrome then case is different but if she is mature enough and mentally fit then she must be persecuted in accordance with the Islamic Law.
misaal
August 25, 2012 9:17 am
Christian theology condemns blasphmey and tradittionally anything spoken aganist the Holy Spirit is unforgivable by law, Pakistan copied this law which is not a part of Islamic teaching, and made disecration of religious literature or the holy prophet punishable by confinement, fine or death . Now this law is misused against minorities even if there is no evidence of an insult. The ignorant people in Pakistan support this law like rhis was a divine Word. They are more gungho on this borrowed law than they are on the techings of their faith. Why? Because it gives them a sense of powee..Also, because they don’t know it’s not legitimate law. I’ve been so depressed whole day thinking about this poor child with health issues locked up in solitary confinement. She will come out of there a mental wreck…that is if she survives. Think people, do your own children make no mistakes? Shame on Zardari ! Shame on Sharifs ! Shame on Altaf ! Shame on Imran ! Shame on the media ! Shame on the intellectuals ! Shame on the activists ! Shame on a nation which remains silent on the face of such cruelty abd injustice! O God help us please!
jtar
August 25, 2012 6:29 am
Once again: Stunning ignorance, inhumanity and barbarism from extremists who cannot even read the texts over which they have now become so enraged. Maybe it's time to join the civilized world instead of continuing to shock the rest of the world this barbarism?
souravie
August 25, 2012 5:44 am
Muslim community in general feel very vulnerable but they have crossed their limits long time ago so by thinking they are protecting their religion they have turned into inhuman monsters.I dont think Prophet Mohammed has said that murder and torture should be practised by the so called "devotee" Muslims.
pankaj
August 24, 2012 7:45 pm
Merciless people..I feel pity for the girl.It shows double standards of Pakistan Police and constitution
kiwi/paki
August 24, 2012 5:15 pm
Dr sahib do you want to burn the newspaper's buildings down by the custodian of faith.
Dr. Emile Unjom
August 24, 2012 4:44 pm
Thank you for your thought provoking reply. Behavour devoid of tolerance and respect of fellow human beings even of different religions and beliefs is subhuman and barbaric. Quaid E Azam was right in his views expressed in his speech on the 11th of Aug 1947. If future is something that seriously concerns us we need to look back and see how we can promote harmony and live in peace as a Pakistani nation with different religions, beliefs, traditions, and cultures. Otherwise the future is staring at us and surely it is dark and bleak as seen in the light of todays realities so pathetic and painful. Serious thought and critical self analysis is required as polarizations and divisions within are counter productive and self destructive.
Zimbo_Indian
August 24, 2012 4:18 pm
Can some one tell me if there is any non-Muslim country which has a blasphemy law? Or is it that only the God of Muslims is so weak that He needs protection through man made laws. Fortunately, the Gods of other religions are quite strong and are so big that human insults can't even touch them. Thank God, my God is not Muslim.
JOY FREEMAN
August 24, 2012 4:11 pm
i am glad to see that people of PK raise question against attacking on minorities.
Haider
August 24, 2012 3:39 pm
What kind of a country and people are we? what kind of message are we sending out to the world? what kind of people live in this country? is this a jungle or what??? utterly shameful and appalling!
rizwan
August 24, 2012 2:49 pm
yes, defend your country with this argument that since INDIA is doing this, it's fine with us. unfortunately, it actually works in pakistan, and we become complacent when we know that we are better than india. way to go...but any comparison viv-a-vis economy, literacy, employment, is bound to bring blushes to you. be sure regarding it.
dr vimal raina
August 24, 2012 2:17 pm
Ask the 800 odd people who have got Indian citizenship in last few years. Your information about minorities in India maybe comes from the local moulvi.
Sanbrown
August 24, 2012 2:14 pm
Blasphemy and Protection of Holy Scriptures. (Sanbrown - Toronto, Canada.) I have a serious question, how does those torn papers from Holy Quran got into the hands of a poor christian girl? That proves "SOMEBODY" is at fault. Do you think these holy books are available to everybody in Pakistan as they are in West? We have access to these materials here in North America and we can do whatever we wish, read or burn. But this is not the case in Pakistan and particularly in poor, slums. It must be some muslim who had carelessly thrown into the street where by her ill-luck she got hold of. Or could be a part of grocery packing. Few months ago I watched a documentary in a Pakistani TV channel, where they showed sacred sheets from Holy Quran and other religious books were found in general garbage. The presenters were concerned with the indifferent behaviour of people and government. Their main discussion was how and why in a very strict muslim environment these most scared papers are found in garbage dumps. They showed not one or two but many places in the city. Situation is that muslim respect their books but cannot maintain the sanctity. Also every household has too many of these. As and when these books get old and worn-out it gets difficult for a sacred religious disposal. It then ends up in fate like this. Pakistan is a good country where people are very caring and loving. But they get easily carried away by mob psychology. Religious and political leaders or the government thrives on these conflicts.
dr vimal raina
August 24, 2012 2:14 pm
if the law is repealed, say it never existed, would this girl not have been beaten to death? Your guess is as good as mine. Blasphemy is not only what the moulvi did and the mob unleashed; it is the silence of the people of Pakistan who do not come on streets to protest against this. If God is going to punish these barbarians, He is also watching those who are not coming on the streets to stop this unjustice done in His name.
raj
August 24, 2012 1:56 pm
What is blasphemy law...???
misaal
August 24, 2012 1:44 pm
I feel that if this madnes and injustice continues some bad curse is going to befall on Pakistan.If you stay quiet in the face of injustice you become a part of it.
amlki88@hotmail.com
August 24, 2012 12:48 pm
If the girl has down syndrome, her accusers seems to have contracted every syndrome that exists against humanity.These are barbarians, This mentality is the beginning of the end and will finish Pakistan. .
Sandip
August 24, 2012 12:25 pm
Why does she need a lawyer? She has not stolen anything or killed anyone? She is for god sake a 11 year old kid. Let her go and let her play and have fun.
Muhammad Asif
August 24, 2012 12:19 pm
We Muslims are ourselves the most blasphemouse by not following the commandments of Allah as stated in Quran. how cruel. Do we think only burning is blasphemy. shame!
Muhammad Asif
August 24, 2012 12:17 pm
because they are being trapped, mostly, if not at all occassions.
Sam
August 24, 2012 12:17 pm
as far as christian saying anything against muslim i think that cannot happen in a state like pakistan.. however the vise versa holds true and we can see examples everyday about the things that are been done to the minorities which includes Christians.
Muhammad Asif
August 24, 2012 12:15 pm
what have we "Muslims" done for out Muslim brothers of Burma? why are we complaining of the west for their criminal silence. Islam is not for tit-for-tat, but for forgiveness.
Muhammad Asif
August 24, 2012 12:13 pm
Amjed, who are you to protect the Holy Quran when Allah Himself has taken its responsibility. Remember, Abdul Mutallib left the Ka'aba when abraha came to destroy it saying "Jis ka ghar hey khud hi bachaye ga". Muslims are recognized with their Akhlaque. We need to consel all those non-muslims through our Akhlaq, not by pushing them.
Muhammad Asif
August 24, 2012 12:04 pm
why not shame on Sharifs, Bhuttos, Zardaris, Chaudhris and WaliKhan's. leave aside Mullahs.
Paul
August 24, 2012 11:56 am
Really...? You mean there are instances of other children also in Pakistan at the receiving end of mob fury, solitary confinement based on hearsay with the maximum punishment of death hanging over as the punishment - where the onus on that child to prove his/her innocence with no parental / familial support and with out practically no access to legal counsel? I think not... I really pity you that even in this situation you are not able to think beyond your religion. Would you condemn what this child is being subjected to?
NS
August 24, 2012 11:56 am
Dr. Sahib, You are expecting logic and reasoning from the mobs bent on killing and destruction? With all due respect, please think again.
NS
August 24, 2012 11:53 am
You are right, she is innocent and should be released. What disappoints me is that no Pakistan political leader, Sharifs, Khan, Chauhdrys, Wali, etc. have shown any concern for the child. This basically shows that minorities don't matter to these politicaians and political parties. Christian should take a cue from Hindus in Pakistan, and should take steps to find shelter elsewhere.
Ahmed Saleem
August 24, 2012 11:52 am
NO ONE SHOULD BE DISTURBED ON SUCH CAUSES AS STATED BY THE LOCAL PEOPLE. oNE MUST CONSIDER THE FACT THAT A POOR GIRL LIVING IN A SLUM AREA HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH BLASPHAMY. PLEASE PROTECT THE MINORITIES. THE NEED YOUR SYMPATHIES. tHEY ARE ALSO THE CHILDREN OF ADAM AND EVE.
sandeep
August 24, 2012 11:04 am
plz dont follow middleeast and be a tolerant nation and dont let fundamentalist take over this country after all we all belong to hindustan in past ,, let be frends and respect each other religion and culture,,,,,,,,from a true indian jai hind
Salim
August 24, 2012 10:59 am
Look at the news papers on special Islamic days, and they are full of Quran Verses on them. In most of the Muslim household, these news papers are handled the same way like others news papers. Lying around, ending up the same way like any other paper at the end of the month! This is just another case of a Molvi who wants to be known for his strong knowledge of Islam! in the population, who do not understand Quran but believe in Molvi!
Salim
August 24, 2012 10:49 am
Have the police and people found the Musalman who threw the pages with Quran Verses in the garbage in the first place!
Heard
August 24, 2012 10:22 am
either way an eye for an eye is not the way....
Heard
August 24, 2012 10:21 am
there should be a like button for the above post.....
Jaideep Gupta
August 24, 2012 10:05 am
Mr.Karim has rightly said so.
Jaideep Gupta
August 24, 2012 10:02 am
Sometime it comes to my mind that whether Pakistan is a true Islamic country or not. How the right of a hapless girl is denied ?She has been refused to get the help of a lawyer leave alone the treatment she has been getting in custody.
Dr Shaaz Mahboob
August 24, 2012 9:51 am
What about the countless Ayaats and Ahadees printed on newspapers everyday that end up in a rubbish dump or in dirty open sewers? Has anyone ever realised that its the same as throwing the Quran in such places? Double standards?
kashif
August 24, 2012 9:45 am
The rule of law is clearly missing in our country, these lunatics who probably don't even know the basics of Islam claim to be better Muslims. I wish someone tell them the preaching of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) about the rights of minorities.. I grew up knowing that torn/old scriptures of Quran should be burnt and ashes to be put down in plants/soil in respect of Quran. But now it turns out that few people thinks its disgrace...
Peace
August 24, 2012 9:43 am
@ajk "How all these christians always get their hands on quran while they are so discriminated?" Cuz Mr. ajk persons like you CREATE all this for Christians just to punish them of being Christian in Islamic Republic of "Taliban" Pakistan
alaina
August 24, 2012 9:42 am
people must be made aware about each others sensitivities . Religion,sects etc are sensitive issues .neither a muslim should say anything about christian beliefs nor a christian should say anything about a muslim. as far as this case is concerned rimsha is not an adult and above all she is not normal.
A True Lover of Allah and HIs prophet(SAWS)
August 24, 2012 9:35 am
Totally shameful for Pakistanis. We are defaming our Islam and showing non-muslims that we are so merciless that we have no any mercy for anyone. If she has done that thing who saw her and it is possible that she was not able to read what she burnt if she is poor and christian then how possible it is that she can read it, I just allegation but nothing. These mullas are ignorant they know nothing but making noise. Why these mullas do not rise their voices on the injustice what is happing in KPK.
Krat
August 24, 2012 8:58 am
Amazing country amazing people
secondopinion02
August 24, 2012 8:46 am
Stone-aged people again victimized an innocent!