THIS is apropos of the recent reports about the migration of Hindu families from Sindh to India. I have been serving in Sindh for the last two years as assistant commissioner, and at presentl posted as AC, Dahrki, Ghotki district.

My observations about persecution of Hindu families are entirely different from what has been projected in the media. I have frequent interactions with Hindu community. The majority of the members of Hindu community in cities is educated and belongs to the middle and the upper middle class. They are well assimilated in society, and have good businesses in all economic sectors and have strong social and economic relations with the local landed elite. They have freedom of worship. For example, in Dahrki tehsil alone there are many Hindu community and worship centres, one of the most popular is the recently built Sain Sunt Ram Das complex, comprising a huge temple, a medical complex and community centres.

Even devotees from India quite often visit this place. It all shows that the Hindu community is prospering economically and socially.

I have also not observed any discrimination at the government level with the Hindu community. They are well-regarded as patriotic.

However, this is another aspect that some of the Hindu business families have relatives in India and they like to settle there to explore further economic opportunities. The migration of a few families does not mean that Sindh has become a hostile place for Hindu families. If some families are complaining against the law and order situation, they then must understand that it is the same for all.

RAO ATIF RAZA Assistant Commissioner Dahrki


Comments are closed.

Comments (27)

Devil
August 20, 2012 3:59 pm
ha ha ha ha !! Good Joke man !!! Hindus are safe !! umm ... you kidding right ?
INDRA
August 20, 2012 10:58 am
Mr Nasim , muslims and christians are safest in INdia than any other country , u see news websites and comment , According to human rights report pakistan is worst country for minorities .
Vaibhav
August 20, 2012 9:42 am
muslims are never forcibly converted to hinduism in india.................there wont be a single example of it..............just bcos hindus are being forcibly converted in pak, u want to justify that by saying so.
rsr
August 20, 2012 8:21 am
thats the spirit. Close your eyes and all is fine in Pakistan.
gh.mujtaba
August 19, 2012 5:18 pm
Although the Sindhi Congress attempted to set up the Sind region as a new state in India, they did not succeed. This was mainly due to the scattering of many Sindhi, as well as a lack of unified effort by the Indian government.
p kumar
August 19, 2012 4:58 pm
killing shias and abducting hindus is a 'law and order problem'
skyalrk
August 19, 2012 4:56 pm
THE ARTICLE IS FULL OF ANTIDOTE : Read the CIA Roport of world facts book and world press & human index in pakistan about hindus & other minorities. for a govt. official to speak untruth in RAMADAN is blatant disregards to truth. it's pathetic condition that only untruth is the only answer to pakistani govt. officials. world has changed , even you would have said thousand times USA didn't believe that BIN LADEN was not sheltered in pakistan. amazaingly some still believe these are concoction. if pakistan can build on UNTRUTH, no body needs to tell you what lies ahead
allaisa
August 19, 2012 3:58 pm
What in Sarcasm dont you understand?
ali ahmed
August 19, 2012 3:44 pm
no body is safe in sindh..every day 10 -15 innocent people are killed..police Rangers,Govt..failed to maintain law and order...corrupt govt has failed
naseem
August 19, 2012 2:48 pm
I can bet you, the standard of living in Pakistan is much better than in India. Only your skin is shining, look within and you will see a different India.
naseem
August 19, 2012 2:45 pm
Whats the big deal? Muslims and Christians in India are also forceably converted to Hinduism. This is not a new. It has happened in the past and it will happen in the future.
NIRAJ
August 19, 2012 1:29 pm
It shows that pakistanis have forgotten the dream of Jinnah and the white colour in their flag
Himanshu
August 19, 2012 1:01 pm
Pakistan is a failed state. Even Pakistanis are not safe there.
Zulu
August 19, 2012 11:34 am
Are you kidding me? Recently there was a video published on internet about a hindu minor girl surrounded by 3-4 men with weapons, calling her parents. She was shivering with fear and was compelled to say that its her own will. And this is just an example. Reduction in hindu community suggests something else and definitely not them liking islam and converting willingly. I would rather send them to India or any other country where they feel safer & realize that they are part of their country. Discrimination against Hindu community is known to every single citizen here in Pakistan.....
Gerry D'Cunha
August 19, 2012 11:15 am
In today's Pakistan, none of the minorities are safe in Pakistan - so much so now even the shia muslims are not safe.
Alok
August 19, 2012 10:19 am
Pakistan keep poinking its nose when they hear any thing about indian Muslims..... What are they doing with Pak Hindu's. These pakis are coward, they dont want to accept indian muslim in there country (we can send all illegal bangladeshi immigrants to PAK, if they are feeling do bad)
onkar Sharma
August 19, 2012 10:04 am
Not even Muslims are safe in Pakistan how can Hindus be safe?
kumar
August 19, 2012 9:53 am
they came to realise the greatness of islam and happily and voluntarily embraced islam; many sufi saints also helped them convert; that is how their numbers have come down. their 14 year old daughters fall in love with the islamic boys and marry them at the age of 14! many neighborhood islamic scholars help in this; good for the girls! why shed tears for their parents.
Vijay Dixit
August 19, 2012 8:49 am
Does the Assistant Commissioner really believe in his heart that he is speaking the truth.Either all Hindus must be lying or the Commissioner.People understand the truth.
Ravi
August 19, 2012 8:14 am
before reading this article i went on to see who is d writer of this article...and as soon i saw d name of write i immediately got it dat it going to b normal as if nothing is happening with hindus of pakistan. just like ptv potrays the image of pakistan even if the whole pakistan was burning on fire....common dude open ur eyes...dis isnt hw u going to ge heaven....u jst opening d doors of hell for urself
Zimbo Indian
August 19, 2012 8:07 am
I have two observations -- (a) Muslims are migrating from Muslim majority Bangladesh to Hindu majority Assam/India and Buddhist majority Myanmar to become refugees. (b) Muslims in Hindu majority India (even Kashmir) are NOT migrating to Islamic Pakistan. I request the AC or some learned Maulana to explain the above mentioned paradox.
ali malik
August 19, 2012 6:15 am
I think where there is smoke there is fire. Something sinister has happened to these families forcing them to migrate. No one does that if they were happy and prospering.
Kautiliya
August 19, 2012 6:14 am
What a malarki. This man should be removed from his office. Does he mean that all the Hindu are lying or want to immigrate ti Bharat? Rao one has to be a Mussalman to get a high paying job in Pakistan according to the Pakistani Constitution. I would like to know how many kidnapping of n young Hindu women or other kidnapping of Hindus for ransom? Lets have those numbers for starters and we will ask about looting and land grabbing and forced conversions of Hindus by the Muslims.
guest
August 19, 2012 5:54 am
How do you explain reduction of Hindu Community in Pakistan from 22% to 1% over 65 years?
ssm
August 19, 2012 5:29 am
I am a reader in india...I would like to request my pakistan brother to put comments on this news...
Ashamed Pakistani
August 19, 2012 5:16 am
Atif saheb, should we have expected truth from you? I am a Pakistani Muslim and am very familar with the plight of minorties in our country. Shame on you to allow this to happen, and shame on us to not rise and protect our fellow citizen who happen to follow a different belief than ours.
Monty..
August 19, 2012 4:05 am
Yeah..keep showing the world this "beautiful" side and hide the "dangerous" side of situation of hindus in Pakistan...It will be of no purpose...It amy coner ur face for a while...But the reality wil come in full blown out fashion to the world one day..