“They do not have a word for ‘ghairat’ in English,” said Khadim. He paused, looked at his audience and asked: “Do you know why?”

Without waiting for a response, he added: “Because they do not have ‘ghairat’ in the West.” His remarks, as he had expected, pleased this audience of South Asian Muslims, Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis.  “Not true,” said Farhan, one of the few liberals in the crowd. “They do have a word for ‘ghairat,’ honour.”

“Incorrect,” declared Khadim, “honour is a very light word. It does not have the intensity of ‘ghairat.’”

Many in the audience understood this ‘intensity’ well. They had grown-up daughters. And every time their daughters went out, in jeans or shalwar-kameez, they felt this intensity. The intensity increases, if the jeans are a bit too tight or the headscarves do not cover the head properly.

Farhan had so far been very patient. It was the ‘barsi’ or the annual prayer meeting for someone who had died last year. It was a solemn occasion, where conservatives outnumber others. He did not want a confrontation with them. Whenever they lose an argument, they go to his father who forces Farhan to apologise to “your elders.”

But he could hold no more. He looked around and found a copy of the day’s newspaper. He opened a page, holding it above his head and said:

“Look, this is your ‘ghairat’ and this is what you do when this intensity gets out of control.” And he started reading the caption under a picture:

“This is a June 19, 2012, file photo of Iftikhar Ahmed, the father of murdered teen-ager Shafilea Ahmed. A British court found that Iftikhar and his wife Farzana Ahmed suffocated their 17-year-old daughter, Shafilea, in 2003, because she was seeing boys and had refused to accept an arranged marriage. Both parents are originally from Pakistan.

“During the trial, Shafilea’s sister Alesha told the jury that her parents pushed Shafilea onto the couch and she heard her mother say ‘just finish it here’ as they forced a plastic bag into the girl’s mouth.”

(On Friday Aug. 3, 2012, the court found the parents guilty of murdering their teenage daughter in a so-called honour killing.)

Farhan stopped, waiting for the words to sink in, and said: “If this is ‘ghairat,’ thank God people in the West do not have this ‘ghairat.’ They only have honour.”

“Enough. Sit down,” shouted one of the elders at Farhan. “Who invited this brat to this religious gathering?” Nobody answered him, although they all knew why Farhan was invited.

Unlike most in the audience, Farhan had learned the Holy Quran from an Arab teacher. He recited it faster than others and pronounced every word correctly. He also had a sweet voice. So he was always invited to such places.

And his parents made sure that he went to all such gatherings, sometimes against his will. This was the last Friday before Ramazan. They finished the recital, said the evening prayers and were waiting for the meal when the argument started.

They usually served kebabs and rasmalais at such dinners and Farhan loved both. But the argument upset him, so he walked out, got into his car and drove away.

Once outside, he realised he did not want to go home yet. So he drove to a nearby shisha bar.

“Still no news of the moon?” Razi, who runs this alcohol free shisha bar in a Washington suburb, asked as he saw Farhan.

“Not my problem,” said Farhan, who was still upset.

“It is my problem, though,” said Razi, also a Pakistani-American. “I need to know, to decide whether to have belly dance tonight.”

Around 10 pm, a friend called and told Razi their local mosque had announced that Ramazan starts tomorrow. “OK, there will be no belly dance tonight,” he said.

It was Friday night and the dancer was already there. Razi paid her $400 and sent her home. The dancer, Zebi, although nobody knew her real name, was also a Muslim, a Central Asian Muslim. “I am going to fast as well,” she said. Some believed her. Some did not.

“You wasted $400,” Farhan said to Razi.

“Yes, I cannot do this during Ramazan,” said Razi.

“Oh, I see. You are a Muslim too, right?” said Farhan, “As if Islam allows dancing on other nights.”

“It does not and that’s why I do not serve alcohol at my place. You see, this is America so we have to compromise on some issues.”

What Razi and thousands of others do in America is not a simple compromise. They modify their faith to suit their needs.


Comments are closed.

Comments (228)

Hasaan
August 7, 2012 8:40 pm
This "ghairat" you write abt has nothing to do with religion. It has everything to do with culture.. that is why hindu, sikh, muslims all suffer from these kind of killings and forced marriages in the West. The issue of Islam arises when a Muslim girl wants to marry a non-muslim man, and is also often dealt with in the same manner. It's all about how to raise your children and teach them right from wrong and boundaries they should not cross... but you have to trust them then and that is where most of the parents fail.
Viz
August 7, 2012 8:29 pm
As for "hypocrites" yes it seems Muslims have a predominant number. The reason the stricter the rules the more human psyche will try to dodge these rules. And it seems even Muslims have become, instead of surrender to will of Allah the worshiper of the rising Sun i.e. the current western values that are derived from Darwinian Theory of evolution. The whole world is tilting toward opportunistic behavior every “man for himself” and “you live only once”. As for South Asian immigrant trying to balance the religion and value they cherish to this new world, it is a struggle but not impossible. If you look at the western society with an open mind there is a big overlap between what these immigrants value and the local values, meaning hard work, decency and respect of human life.
Viz
August 7, 2012 8:28 pm
"Ghairat" is a cultural word and has no religious bearing. The problem is, due to media the fringe issues of the societies are brought front and center. Honor killing is one of those taboos of the societies that took place but were not talked about in the past. Again the age old question is the society represented in media or media is molding the society. There are bad people and good people in every society, honor killing has taken place in all societies but due to renewed interest in Islam post 911 all the ills of Islamic society are being scrutinized.
Nazar
August 7, 2012 3:19 pm
Azad Zehniyat
Ahsan Rasheed
August 7, 2012 5:43 am
little bit of this and little bit of that doesnt work, you either have 1 or 2. The pros and cons of the society shud be kept in mind while making a decision to move abraod, and stick to ur decision for life time.
Ahsan Rasheed
August 7, 2012 5:37 am
Need to sit down and set the priorities, what comes first, religion, culture, society, ethnicity, etc to solve the confusion we have in our minds.
Rao
August 7, 2012 4:38 am
You have experience of very rare community, I live in USA and when you said, ... "Most Pakistanis in American will not eat pork but they will comfortably gulp down a bottle of beer or a glass of wine." I was surprised which USA you are talking about, Muslims do not drink bear or any kind of alcohol here. It is very very rare, same as in Pakistan or anywhere in the world Muslims drink bear but that is very rare.
Talha
August 7, 2012 4:16 am
agree to u sal!
Asma
August 7, 2012 12:57 am
I don't think Gerry was talking only about the literal halaal/haram debate. Susan, I think you took this a bit too literally.
ACFP
August 6, 2012 11:35 pm
If words could describe people or cultures then what is the Urdu ( or any language spoken by so called Muslims ) word for integrity? Does that mean Urdu speaking people have no integrity? Words like Ghairat are used by cowards who hide behind the emotional baggage carried by such words. Hypocrisy has a perfect translation in Urdu and other languages spoken by Muslims and it is called "Munafiqat". There is plenty of that found in all countries inhabited by people who called themselves Muslim.
Ali Ahsan
August 6, 2012 7:06 pm
True story from Norway: Some Pakistani Muslims were enjoying a beer at a bar one evening. A friend who joined them later brought a pizza for all of them. The guy on his third beer eagerly enquired if the pizza was halal. "As halal as your beer", came the reply. Precisely because of this hypocrisy, I am now at peace as an atheist.
Ali
August 6, 2012 3:51 pm
I am a pakistani living in the west. A fellow pakistani friend came to me the other day. He wife was pregnant. He said " yaar dua karo larka ho warna pakistan waapis jaana parhay ga". My suggestion: if you spend most your time trying to find out the correct length of your shalwar so you can get into the paradise, you are better off staying in saudia or pakistan
Ali
August 6, 2012 1:52 pm
Siddiqui Sir you totally missed the point. He was not talking about literal meanings. His point is that all those things exist in the West and not in the EAST especially in Pakistani culture and He's very much so correct.
@shahg64
August 6, 2012 1:09 pm
Is there a word in Urdu that means non interference in other peoples lives, and worrying instead about your own? Why are we so quick to judgement upon others and not ourselves? Why does it matter to us if someone drinks wine or eats pork? What does that have to do with us? Did Allah command Muslims to worry about each others gunah instead of our own, or did HE say, you will each have to answer to ME for your sins? I dont care whether any muslim drinks wine or water, it is me who I must watch and guide, each soul will have to answer for their own conduct, so the writer need not worry about others.
Maira
August 6, 2012 12:46 pm
Very well said. Simple rule is "What goes around comes around".
Gerry D'Cunha
August 6, 2012 10:41 am
saythetruth: You should give your guidance to your champions of Islam 'Moulvis/Mullaha' not to misguide the people or to advocate in killing one another for minor differences.
Sohaib YAHIA
August 6, 2012 10:07 am
and we, the people of this pure land, do not have words for tolerance, kindness and sympathy in our dictionaries!
W.Sarmad Khan
August 6, 2012 9:55 am
Every society has its own problems. You can not say that western societies are bad and eastern societies are good or vice versa. Economics form social institutions. The life style is fast paced in western societies and both parents work to maintain a standard of living. This results in children being neglected and host of problems start here. Eastern societies have double standards. Most people accept western daughter-in- laws but very reluctant in accepting western son-in laws.. However; moral values in eastern culture still exist and here we are better off than western culture. Respect for elders, care for neighbors, no pre-marital sex, drinking, and neglect of parents in old age are some of the things that eastern culture should be proud of its heritage.
Jauhar Shah
August 6, 2012 9:54 am
How usual! One Pakistani judging others. (Oops, and now I'm indulging in it as well).
A. Khan
August 6, 2012 9:50 am
Story started off well with the argument about ghairat. I was expecting it be discussed in more depth but it just meanders and finally fizzles out. Must do better !
Mian Zain ul Zafar
August 6, 2012 9:29 am
This writer has never stopped astonishing me. This guy gets it write every time. A true reflection of out selves. Cheers Anwar Iqbal saab
Salman
August 6, 2012 8:20 am
It does appear so, but in the referred story, did you hear the mother saying: "end it here"?
aanwar
August 6, 2012 8:02 am
Must say a Brilliant Master-piece,true depiction of today's artificial effort of saving our muslim culture. Nowerdays it is a shame that our deeds and preachings as muslims are truly very different from each other.My personal feeling is, if we want to save our skin, we will Blame the West for everything.Self correction can be done as most of us are sane individuals with basic education. Hence we can ourselves read,ponder and correct our selves only if WE want too, but ''NO'' why should WE???? it is easy to blame the others.__ And If the ''ghariat' exsists today why search in the english language why should we not search it in depth within our own selves first!
Salman
August 6, 2012 7:50 am
:) You missed the satire in his comment. He meant, just like in west they dont "have" ghairat, similarly, all those words (infact, values), do not appear in our society.
Salman
August 6, 2012 7:45 am
What is the lesson in this? A) Since he eats halal chicken, he should also stay away from beer OR B) Since he drinks beer, he should stop insisting on Halal chicken as well ??
Manish Sharma
August 6, 2012 7:41 am
GO Veg, everything is halal.
gul khan
August 6, 2012 7:32 am
I appreciate you
Amir
August 6, 2012 7:02 am
Yes they do have a word for ghairat in english. Its 'Honor'
M Younis
August 6, 2012 6:47 am
Loved reading it. Very insightful and well written. This is a bitter truth or our people.
ZAFFAR AL QADRI
August 6, 2012 5:49 am
ham sab ko allah hidayat ata farmaye
ahmad butt
August 6, 2012 4:46 am
I thought there is a word, most frequently used by Musharraf to defend himself for all his misgivings, and the word is "dignity".
Foha
August 6, 2012 4:45 am
A well written article and really points out issues of South Asian Muslims. But let me point out one thing that somethings are not double standards it is just the way of interpreting Islam. The best example would be drinking and not eating pork. Quran has mentioned quite a few times about pork being forbidden (haram) but it never mentions alcohol to be forbidden thus those Muslims who follow Quran properly and are not stringent Muslims know that sometimes socially drinking is not a sin.
MKB
August 6, 2012 4:44 am
That is the reason they are much progressed & proper than Pakistan
Haris Iftikhar
August 6, 2012 4:35 am
Most Muslim parents are facing such type of problems in non-Muslim countries. But only one thing I want to say that “It depends upon our self what we want to do” If some one said that do this sin, we do. What that means? It means that we are interested also in this. we want to this by heart. If we will say sorry or no or I can’t then no one can force you. Sons make such type of mistakes then parents said ohh no problem dear don’t do this again. Only few parents taught a lesson to them. Make a rule of respect for all (boys & girls). It’s a human natural factor that in which culture he grew up, he adopts the values, life style etc. of that culture. Many parents do their daughter’s marriages in Muslim countries and take groom with them. This is a natural thing which cant be changed. If we want to changed then we have to change the culture where our young generation is growing up.
MKB
August 6, 2012 4:32 am
Umer, what wrong Raika has said? This is the problem. You do not want to assimilate with culture, language & customs of the country you have migrated. It sparks clash, suspicion, enmity & threat to the indigenous people. There are many other religious groups migrated to the west from Asia, but they do not face such problem & have better living condition, economic ststus than Muslims.
Naeem
August 6, 2012 3:34 am
...and who says these issues exist only in the USA or in the western world? There is everything going on in muslim country, perhaps sometimes not so much in the open.
Yanti
August 6, 2012 2:30 am
when a person choose to live in a certing type of community must accept the whole packgage not just select opportunities for economical gain. So the consequances are the we just saw in England. Think twice before moving families to west. Can't go against the society where a person choose to live.
sana fatima
August 6, 2012 1:34 am
great writing Anwar Iqbal
NASAH (USA)
August 6, 2012 12:38 am
If you are a real Muslim confident of your Muslim-hood -- you don't need to 'practice' religion -- you already know it.
American Desi
August 5, 2012 11:48 pm
Beautifully written about the hypocrisy due to denial of modern reality
sri1ram
August 5, 2012 11:04 pm
Siddiqui sahab, Can you tell us the Urdu translations for irony, sarcasm, sense of humor and hypocrisy too? Cheers, Riz
Sameer Ashraf
August 5, 2012 10:39 pm
May Allah SWT have mercy on situation of Muslims. Bringing up your kids is a much bigger challenge here in US. May Allah SWT give TOUFEEQ to all muslim parents to teach their kids about Islam with their own example.
_oatc_
August 5, 2012 9:46 pm
The only western men who kill their daughters are those who kill their whole family and then kill kill themselves.
abc
August 5, 2012 8:41 pm
Good observation. I live in Germany, and there is a huge hijab wearing turkish population. I also, got the oppertunity to visit Istanbul and Ankara for my work. and I got really ammused by the irony. People in Istanbul are very friendly, liberal and possessed almost same values, as most europeans. But, once they immegrate to germany, somehow they become born again muslims.
Susan Naek
August 5, 2012 7:42 pm
@ Gerry D'Cunha: Your question appears to be based on a lack of knowledge, or prejudice. For example: The Jews also eat 'Halal' but call it 'kosher'. Moses/David/Jesus/Muhammad all ate Kosher/Halal. Only Saint Paul was against it.Thus Kosher, which is somewhat more complicated in its preparation, as it includes vegetables and salt, is available everywhere in the West, as Halal too will soon be. So there is no restriction in following Muslim/Jewish dietary laws, except perhaps in certain areas of the Indian Sub-Continent where beef is banned to some extent.
Rahman
August 5, 2012 7:42 pm
You do have a point. But, two wrongs don't make a right. Ghairat and honor are things all males must cherish. Because without these two male traits, our existence is meaningless. Men are the protectors of women. It says so in the Quran. We are Muslims for a reason. If we can't act, live or behave like a Muslim then why call ourselves Muslims. Western culture has decomposed in many ways and one of the things that has been affected the most is the sanctity and purity of women. Please remember, if you live around garbage, you don't have to bring it inside of your house.
masood
August 5, 2012 7:36 pm
Did you notice there is no such word in ISLAM, why because this word is useful word to subjugate helpless women for these peoples,Sadly these same people are BE-GHAIRAT enough to eye other women without a hint of self respect.
Shafaq A.
August 5, 2012 7:20 pm
@Dilawer: "English words which can not be translated in Urdu" Urdu is richer than English as it has a greater propensity to absorb foreign languages into it. After all that was its genesis. Have you considered that your own ability to translate, as your sentence structure and composition suggests, may be the limiting factor here?
A parent
August 5, 2012 7:15 pm
You say you live in the west. If that is so and you follow the news you surly must understand that western men (husbands, brothers, uncles, etc.) do not kill their daughters for dancing, listening to western music, or even, horror of horrors, having a boyfriend. In fact, because in the west, the idea of arranged marriages are viewed as akin to being sold into slavery, most young people, and their parents are hoping for a "love match" (A Korean term that translates quite well into English - The Koreans are steadily moving away from arranged marriages, by the way.). This is the culture here in the west and I do not think you can fully insulate a child from it as they are growing up. The hope for true love is a strong attraction.
Rahman
August 5, 2012 7:06 pm
The blogger is wrong! There is Ghairat in the western society as well. You hear about murders of women by men in the western countries all the time, if a man thinks a wife or a girl friend is sleeping with another man. But, they call it jealousy, not honor killing. In fact, that goes on in a much higher frequency in the western world, particularly USA, than the honor killings by Muslims. While nobody should condone murder and it is prohibited in Islam as well, one has to analyze the agony these parents must be going through finding themselves powerless when trying to raise their child according to their belief and culture. They must feel the whole world is against them when the school teachers, child's friends, child's friend's parents and the government are telling them how to raise their children. They only tell Muslims to do so, but never tell the fundamental Christians or Jews, who are doing exactly the same thing. By the way, in Britain and Canada, Hindus and Sikhs have gone through the same trial and tribulations and there have been many instances when the parents of the two aforementioned religions have engaged in the same type of behavior. The blogger tried to make a point, by asking a question "Why is their ‘ghairat’ always linked to women? Why not men? ". But failed to give an answer. The answer is: when women go out and then sleep with men they get pregnant...men don't. Guess who ends up dealing with the issues? Parents. Muslim girls while they want to experience the western culture and feel emancipated, they don't have the where with all to deal with issues that result from their shenanigans. They dump it all on their parents. Western girls don't do that...they deal with their issues. The other big reason for the Muslim girls to stay clear from western vises is that if they get too deep into the western culture, they cant find suitable Muslim husbands. Because, when they are getting married, they want a non drinker, non smoker and a hard working husband, but men of this description are not interested in women who have crossed the line. I am a moderate, and have lived in the USA for 40 years and have raised two girls who are now young ladies. They are modern, educated, pure and well balanced in their approach to life. They practice Islam without the dogma of cultural adulterants.