Eminent journalist Kuldip Nayar shares the memories of his days in Pakistan before Partition:

murray_college_670

Nayar's alma matar: Murray College, Sialkot

After Partition we were among the very few Hindu families who did not want to migrate to India. We mistakenly thought that as large numbers of Muslims would continue to live in India, the same would be true of Hindus in Pakistan. Our resolve was strengthened when a few days prior to Partition, Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the founder of Pakistan, categorically pronounced that people were free to go to their mosques or temples and practice their faith because the state would never mix religion with politics. He reinterpreted his thesis of two nations, Muslims and Hindus, to mean Pakistanis and Indians.

Jinnah’s encouraging statement apart, there was his gesture to select a Hindu poet, Jagan Nath Azad, to compose the national anthem of Pakistan. The anthem was changed after Jinnah’s death for communal considerations: a Hindu writing the national anthem of a Muslim state appeared unthinkable.

Moreover, our family’s lifestyle was so comfortable that we did not wish to uproot ourselves. We had substantial property and my father was a leading medical practitioner in town. How could he, then past 60, begin his practice afresh in a new city? He had already spent most of his savings a few months prior to Independence building a new house, a new dispensary and an array of shops.

I have fond memories of my home, at Trunk Bazaar, Silakot, a two-storey house with a garden at the back where there was an old grave which my mother said was the qabar (grave) of some pir (saint). The grave was like a family shrine where we prayed in our own way and sought refuge from the outside world. It was here that we lit a lamp every Thursday and made an offering of sweets which we, the children, subsequently distributed amongst ourselves. A few years before Partition some Muslims demanded a passage to the grave on the plea that they should have free access to their religious site. We had to yield to the demand but the passage, which cut through our property, was rarely used.

Ours was a joint family, with my grandmother as the effective head. My grandfather was alive but he took a back seat. She was a great one for astrology and had the horoscope of every child prepared by a leading pundit, forecasting the future. I recall one occasion when the pundit dropped in at the house. A visit from him was always eagerly awaited because he would also read our palms. To me he said that I would read the malechh vidya (a language of foreigners), thereby meaning English. He also predicted that I would travel a lot by udhan khatola (plane). When my youngest brother Sindhu showed his hand, he was dismissed in a second with the remark that the lines on his hand had not properly developed. This was perhaps his way of saying that Sindhu would not live long.

When my grandmother died, I rode a horse alongside the cortege of family and friends who carried the coffin to the cremation ground. Women, some of them hired, rhythmically beat their breasts. Brahmins were fed one day and the poor of the locality on another. My grandmother apparently evoked a great measure of respect because scores of people were gathered at the cremation ground. I remember, I went to Haridwar with the family to immerse her ashes in River Ganges. I do not recall crying because the whole ceremony of her death wore an aura of festivity. This was the custom among Hindus when a woman died at a ripe old age.

My immediate family comprised my father, mother and four brothers — Rajinder, Hardip, Surinder — and a sister, Raj, who used to live in Jamshedpur at the time of Partition. Sindhu had died of cholera a few months earlier. I can never forget his last moments: he passed away with his head resting on my lap. He called me bhapa (elder brother), and when his moment came, he asked me to hold him tight so as to prevent anyone from taking him away. I held him tight, but I could feel his body going limp.

His last words were, ‘Bhapa leave me, I can see the light. I am going there’, and then he was gone. His loss left me distraught for a long time.

His parting words often make me wonder whether there is indeed a higher power controlling the universe. The light, to which Sindhu referred, represents a power which eventually leads us in our journey from life to death. Why? How? And when? I cannot say, but, notwithstanding my leftist leanings, I have come to believe that there is a power beyond: be it God or any other name you may choose to give it. I have oscillated between faith and doubt for many years but have come to accept that there is a force which I feel within but which I cannot explain. I am neither an atheist nor an agonistic; I am a believer, but notwithstanding this I have failed to curb my doubts and misgivings, and prayer has not helped either.


Comments are closed.

Comments (115)

Lavendar_Fields
August 6, 2012 12:49 am
I would like to correspond with you, M Gulati. Where are you located in CA?
Baber
August 2, 2012 8:27 am
How can you have a Muslim without Islam?
S.Rana
August 1, 2012 9:08 pm
What a beautiful piece of prose. The message is awesome---- the humanity is much greater than nationalism, tribalism or sectarianism and at times even religions.
Simrat Kapoor
July 31, 2012 8:55 am
For us born in the 1980’s, Pakistan is just a different geography, with whom we share little values, aspirations or cultural moorings. We hope that peace prevails between the two nations on realistic grounds and not on the dualist sentimentality of “can’t live with you; can’t die without you”. I think the older generation needs to forget the painful birth pain and pathos; and sever that umbilical memory for the younger generation. Only this will allow ‘the now and the future’ to treat each other dispassionately.
Khalil Lahore
July 31, 2012 6:29 am
Kuldeep ji I remember from my days in Indian pow camp that you used to write in favor of release of pows.the govt at that time did not listen to you .India took full political advantage out of sitation. I think you wrote I quote A thing which morallr can not be politically right the politicians have their own agenda .people of your. Generation are fading away the way India is educating it's new gratin one is not hopefully any positive outcome..we should from history people like you make some difference but it seems imposible. Jaswnt Singh has attributed creation of Pakistan to an unjust treatment of Muslim in united india. We committed the same mistake in east pak India took full advantage of the situation and created bangladesh.as b
Kaafir
July 31, 2012 5:19 am
Very good of you to keep a tab on no. of muslims killed - now please do some effort and find the no. of hindus killed in the post-babri riots too.
Raju Shah
July 31, 2012 2:19 am
Waqasji At least you should visit Bangalore, so that you will feel at peace to have fulfilled your mother's wishes. Bangalore is a great happening place and you will feel at home,
virendra gupta
July 31, 2012 12:33 am
Very reflective piece. May more of us Indians and Pakistanis learn to see each other's humanity and work towards better understanding. Your thoughts about religion and your personal belief at your current stage is revealing and even more interesting. Peace and Joy to people who think and live like you, Mr. Nayyar.
M. Gulati
July 30, 2012 10:59 pm
Dear Kuldipji, I was 8 years old at the time of partition, living in Mandi Dhaban Singh and a village called Ratti Tibbi, District Sheikhupura. I have been a fan of your writings from the Daily Tribune from my high school days and have enjoyed your piece in Dawn. I applaud you for your efforts to promote India-Pakistan unity. I have been living in California for the past 43 years. I will like to correspond with any readers from Mandi Dhaban Singh or Ratti Tibbi.
Bal K. Gupta
July 30, 2012 10:09 pm
I was 10 years old when Pathans and Pakistan army over ran Mirpur (Pakistan Occupied Kashmir). Mirpur was also a town where Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs used to live like brothers. I used to share Eid, Diwali and Gurpurab with our Hindu, Sikh and Muslim neighbors and visit mosques, gurudwaras and mandirs without any fear. But Pakistani invasion and subsequent Fall of Mirpur on November 25th, 1947 changed those good times. I was not lucky like Kudip Nayyar but was kept in Alibeg Prison (POK) from 1947-1948.
M Sal
July 30, 2012 8:45 pm
Although i was born in the 70s in Pakistan,my granddparents and my parents have told and retold the tragic stories of migration and relatives and friends killed and lost.That generation has taken the loss of eveything they new to their graves.My father has located his birth place Kot Badal Khan in indian Punjab on U tube and watches it regularly and even remembers some of the streets as things have not changed that much.Having said that Pakistan remains in a state of evolution and hopefully with time will evolve into an egalaterian society.Guys comments like above do give me a lot of hope.Peace
Raja imran Dhruggi
July 30, 2012 8:25 pm
Would you believe I read around six times the Kuldip nayar sweet memories of the past.Every line every word every sentence brought tears in my eyes.how magnificently he recollected his sweet memories of his great and legendary family.i was feeling my self as the part of funeral procession of Mr.Nayar grandmother.His'oft repeated visits to the Peer sab kubir shows his deep attachment , affiliation and heart felt reverence for religious and holy bodies.people like nayar are really above the so called grips and boundaries which our pseudo mullahs have defined for us.Many people of my great village Dhruggi Rajgan( which is very close to the village of Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh ) burst into tears when they recollect their past sweet memories of pre partition of pakistan. they still love many cities of Hindustan and remember their sincere friends with whom they chatted and shared their worries.Mr Nayar s' article wet the eyes of many people.Sir i convey you the heart deep feelings of my friends.May Allah bless you and your family
Purush Vichaar
July 30, 2012 5:09 pm
Baba !! One is not so sure about your analysis but we do wish Pakistan all the best chance to come out of its evil shadows and find its rightful place under the sun.
pankajdehlavi
July 30, 2012 4:17 pm
Jinnah knew very well in 1945 itself that he is going to die soon by TB. He was neither interested in making a country nor had any long term vision for it. He just wanted a space for himself in the history as head of state. And that is what he achieved in his lifetime. If he would be interested in well being or vision for the country, he would have created second rung leadership for Pakistan, as Gandhi did during his life-time for India.
Rashid
July 30, 2012 3:49 pm
What Kidwai saab says is correct - this is the state of Pakistan at the moment unfortunately. I would think of it as giving the younger generation a 'heads up' on what to expect and to educate themselves on how to improve the situation and survive.
Unnikrishnan
July 30, 2012 3:19 pm
I am touched by the sentiments & feeling expressed by your father. Often wondered whether there are any old-timers in other side of the border recalling past memoirs like Shri Kuldip Nayyar
Rashid
July 30, 2012 3:06 pm
I totally agree. Jinnah would be mortified to see what Pakistan has turned into
Kirpal
July 30, 2012 2:11 pm
I was one year old when my parents brought me to Amritsar from Lahore. Now i am retired and play golf. In my views creation of Pakistan was good for Hindus and Sikhs as they are now living in peaceful India and those who wanted Pakistan are living in the land of their own choosing. With the Hindu Muslim historic dislike of each others life style, there would have been perpetual violent agitations on the streets of joint India by hardliners from both communities. May the people of Pakistan live in peace.
Kumar
July 30, 2012 1:16 pm
Can you please give me his book name. i want to read it. I am great admirer of him.
Mohammad Afzal
July 30, 2012 12:57 pm
That is the basic difference between a Pakistani and Indian mind!
Mohammad afzal
July 30, 2012 12:34 pm
So very well said,sir!
vikas
July 30, 2012 12:34 pm
But what "Najib Kidwai" is mentioning is a reality. Except for "communal riots in India. Muslims are peacfully living in India. they are running theiir daily lives very peacfully, but in Pakistan No Hindu is safe today.
Dr. Archana Zutshi
July 30, 2012 11:35 am
A poignant dream to recapture the ethos of familial brotherhood. I happened to be at two event where you were presiding in these couple of years...I looked on thinking how I could connect with a towering personality like yours, i hesitantly stayed in the shadow. Mr Nayar has turned old but his spirit is still full of verve to guide the jounalists of today.He told them not to give up and continue writing against Mayawati's misrule.
p kumar
July 30, 2012 11:24 am
Mr Nayar's biography on wikipedia pays great tribute to his secular mindset.The last paragraph illustrates how well he has served his adopted country;we are proud of him
Mohammed
July 30, 2012 10:17 am
Reading the comments I feel there is a strong need for perspective. Undoubtedly Pakistan has many problems, however when compared to most post colonial developing states they are not unique. Issues surrounding democratic transitions and a resurgent religious right (including India) are commonplace. I also feel there is a tendency at time to look back at the time before pre partition with nostalgia by some quarters. I agree that some communities did live together peacefully, but equally the 1940's were highly communally charged, a process which had become more acute since British rule. Many people faced a very real discrimination and with the deteriorating communal situation partition had become the only option in the absence of a constitutional agreement. Jinnah intended for Pakistan to be a secular state, however his conception of secularism was different to India's. Jinnah had a liberal conception of secularism whereby Islamic ,identity, would play an important role in the state. In some senses this is similar to Islamist rooted AK party’s 'redefinition' of secularism in Turkey.
Shez
July 30, 2012 9:11 am
In his presidential address to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan on 11th August 1947 Jinnah stated and I quote "You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place or worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed that has nothing to do with the business of the State". If that that is not stating clearly of Pakistan being a secular state then what is? This intolerence and influence of extremism is destroying Pakistan.
Pramod
July 30, 2012 7:40 am
I was borne much after independence but still I do feel the futility of having two nations. What a pity that we Hindus and Muslims could live happily under a British rule but we thought that we will not be able to live together when we are independent because we practice different religion. This very thought conveys complete bankruptcy of our whole thought process of not only our leadership, except the great man Mahatma Gandhi, but also of every body who forced or imposed this on peaople. I only wish they had lived to see their their shattered dreams.One would like to ask those leaders if they thought that we could not live together then why they were fighting for independence.
Bobby Srinivas
July 30, 2012 6:26 am
As always, Kuldip Nayyar has made an objective analysis. Jinnah was as secular as any other national leader. The present day Pakistan and its politics are the very antithesis of what the Quade e Azam had dreamed of a Muslim majority nation. Much as denigrators may scream, India is totally secular and democratic. And thats a blessing.
Ejaaz
July 30, 2012 5:24 am
It is 65 years too late to pin down what Jinnah wanted. You cannot demand a homeland for Muslims on the basis of a two nation theory, and then try to turn around on a dime and say you want a secular country just like what the Indians had. If hindus and Muslims were two nations and could not live together in India, how could they live in Pakistan? The logic of the creation of Pakistan got the "Objectives Resolution" early on, and the path to a full blow theocracy was unavoidable. Even now it is unavoidable. There is no chance of disrupting that path.
Krish Chennai
July 30, 2012 5:23 am
Najib Saab, as a Pakistani origin person, you do a disservice to the country of your origin with this comment, rather to the entire sub-continent. Even if you cannot show the way or provide encouragement, at least don't extinguish the hopes of an entire younger generation in the country, while living and prospering outside it. In short, see where you can help out !
Najib KIdwai
July 30, 2012 4:46 am
Kuldip sahib, Well said, though I am second generation born Pakistani of a migrated parent,now living in Canada, I am in opinion that division of India brought only misery to general population and only serve the interest of western world. India was fortunate enough that they have a nationalist leadership, who put interest of India first, the leadership of Pakistan always serve their GORA masters and fuedualords interest. The political forces operating in present day Pakistan do not provide any hope of future improvement for their 180M people, as most of them represent one way or other way the interest of ruling classes. In that sense I am happy that non muslim, who migrated from Pakistan are in piece in India and enjoying a state which is secular and do not discriminate. Najib Kidwai
Waqar Hasan
July 30, 2012 4:33 am
If it to be secular, what was the need of its creation? And now it is proved that Jinah wanted to make it an Ideal State and Mr. Asad was ordered to work on this and Jinnah has issued to dedicate a budget to work on the agenda to make the state Islamic. On Jinnah's instruction Mr. Asad has drafted and gave the speeches from Radio Pakistan. Otherwise I can't understand why a second secular state needed to build?
Haris Chaudhry
July 30, 2012 4:04 am
What a wonderful, mesmerising and candid articulation of events.. It sounds so pure, innocent and yet to hurtful and thought provoking at the same time. I wish we had more of you in Pakistan.. we have been taken over by zealots and thugs. So sad.
Mustafa Razavi
July 30, 2012 3:57 am
Lots of quotes are being attributed to Quaid-e-azam, most of them don't stand the scrutiny of history. Likewise, the famous Churchill quote about courts working fine in England turned out to be a fraud. The other famous quote from by Lincoln about democracy being of the people for the people and by the people would not standup the scrutiny of the history because Lincoln was voted in by a very small minority of the US Citizens.
SFA
July 30, 2012 3:41 am
Surprisingly, Jinnah had never used the word "secular" in any of his speeches. On the other hand, words like Qur'an and Sunnah can be found all over in his pre and post partition speeches.
Javid
July 30, 2012 3:30 am
Last year Har Gobind Khorana passed away. Educated in Lahore - and a Nobel Prize winner. Another Nobel Chandrasekhar also grew up there. So many eminent scholars were associated with Lahore. Partition uprooted them and sent them to the four corners of the earth. In his recent book Tariq Ali also from Lahore writes with melancholy for the lost golden age of pre-partion Lahore. My father a leftist would recall with tears in his eyes that Lahore was once the Oxford of Northern India. That world has now vanished. We now live in a time where the educated bow to the illiterate.
Nashib Hashmi
July 30, 2012 3:28 am
Simply splendid.
Kalayani
July 30, 2012 3:20 am
A nostalgic and very well written article which coveys the thought of millions like me who has lost her cultural heritage and the land of her ancestors forever. Only survivor from the family 20 plus people ..my grandma had fond memories of her home and friends from interior Punjab. Two thing stood out how kuldip's family who was Hindu had the genuine respect for Sufi saint and fond memory of the shrine which is common for so many Hindus who visit Sufi dargah and shine regularly and it doesn't contradict with their Hindu faith. I haven't seen any vice varsha example from Muslim. The second thing how Muslims in his neighbourhood demanded the right of passage to shrine in the private property of nayyer's family .The striking difference between minority population in both country have deep roots in their respective ideologies and how both communities treat each other's faith.
anand singh
July 30, 2012 2:39 am
More than the article what is heartening is to read comments of posters from Pakistan. Makes you feel that Humanity is still alive & well. My compliments to all.
Rizwanul Huda
July 30, 2012 2:35 am
Nice piece of writing kuldeep ji. It represent a whole generation and history when there was peace, harmony and respect for each other. Indeed it is sad to see Pakistan gradually drifting from a secular and moderate society to a fundamentalist extremist society.
kmjumani@
July 30, 2012 1:35 am
i hope we respect Jinnah dictum of secularity take the power away from army make themlive like ordinary poor pakistani's live stop kiling our own in the name of relegion and national security and trowing the mutilated bodies of patriots to frighten Baloch into submission
M.A sheikh
July 30, 2012 12:43 am
Dear Kuldip Ji Please accept my blessings for a wonderful story,Your each word has deeply affected me.Thanks.I am from Sialkot not from Trunk Bazar,and most probably your father clinic was occupied by Dr Major Sahlia Hashmi(Late) no longer any clinic now.I wa student of Murray College and know many people who migrated to India.Please bring India and Pakistan to live like brothers and friends.Only bone of contention is Kashmir sove this old standing dispute and we should live closer together. thanks once again for your writing.
Tarun D
July 30, 2012 12:12 am
Jinnah died too soon to lay down a strong foundation for a secular democratic state.In some ways India was fortunate to have Nehru until 1964.That was time enough for a genuine democracy to take root.Jinnah did not want an Islamic state that would deny fundamental rights to non-Muslims.He wanted a state where Muslims would be a majority and masters of their destiny - meaning not at the mercy of a Hindu majority.I do not think Jinnah would want his portrait hanging any where in to-day's Pakistan.
sps
July 29, 2012 11:48 pm
My hometown is Hoshiarpur.Sixty five years later ,one can still see marked Islamic influence in the city and surrounding areas. Regards
Narinder
July 29, 2012 11:24 pm
Fortunately our family did not have to physically suffer the partition tragedy because we did not have to migrate east or west. ( Sunam, District Sangrur, Punjab) is my home city) But my father (who is no more), suffered emotionally because nearly all of his muslim friends were murdered or they left Sunam for good during those crazy days. I was born after after partition and have heard heart wrenching stories both from Muslims and non-muslims. I understand it is very difficult for the affected to forget the sufferings of those days but should we keep on remembering them and keep feeling more sad? If all of us have the will then let us learn from these sufferings and move forward and intiate a new era in Indo-Pak relations
Dr TK
July 29, 2012 10:50 pm
Nayarji Nick Bostrom a Swede heading the Department of the Future of Humanity at Oxford University says in his "Simulation Hypothesis" that the Universe that we find ourselves in is a computer simulation by an an advanced human civilization (about a million years ahead). If that is true, which I for one believe it is, then we have no control over things. Just sit back and enjoy the ride. At best, we can hope that the Simulator will tire of the game and press the "Game Over" button soon.
Mustafa Razavi
July 29, 2012 9:37 pm
My grandfather migrated from Bombay a year before the partition. He had a cousin and another cousin's husband burned alive in Bombay in the riots following the Babri Masjid destruction.
Javed
July 29, 2012 9:09 pm
Kuldip Ji,Jinnah never envisaged the misery we are living now.It was the blessing of the pir in that grave which made you to go to India.Your honesty and your talent would not have paid in Pakistan.I remember the days of 50's without electricity and half century after,we are still without it.I remember our parents looking forward to a great Pakistan and now I see my children desiring to migrate to better pastures.
Shoaib Khan, Chicago
July 29, 2012 8:54 pm
What a brilliant piece of writing! May God bless you with health and long life so that we may benefit from your words of wisdom and historical anecdotes
S Karim
July 29, 2012 8:48 pm
I was not interested to migrate to Pakistan.Studing Post graduate studies in a college.Say irony of fate ,when one fine morning while attending my B A Honours class in Economics,the lecturer started giving lecture in Sanskrit/ chaste Hindi language.I was at time become dumb founded and at last decided my future is dark here.I love India and still cannot forget the cohesion ,cooperation and friendly relationship with all my neighbours.What we got in Pakistan --hatred ,target killings and no safety of one's life.God save Pakistan .Amen