Mehdi Hassan – Dawn/File photoMehdi Hassan is dead, but I am not sad. Don’t curse me when I say I am relieved, for death has brought an end to his decade-long suffering. Watching him lie helpless and speechless, afflicted by so many ailments, not to speak of bedsores, was a heart-wrenching experience. Strangely, while I am one of his biggest fans, I only met him – save a cursory exchange of ‘adaab’ at Mumbai Airport in the 1990s – when he fell ill. The first time I spoke to him was in 2001, after he suffered his first stroke (in Kerala, where he gave his last performance). He could answer questions, albeit with long pauses. This meeting took place at his house in Karachi.

I had accompanied Dr Saira Khan, who had made arrangements for the ambulance of the Medical Aid Foundation to take him from his house to the Aga Khan University Hospital daily for physiotherapy sessions. Also with us was a young Indian girl Nandita Bhavnani, who had arrived from Mumbai to see the city of her ancestors. She had been a great admirer of the vocalist. When I introduced her to Khan sahib (as he was often referred to) he said “Jo haq Pakistanion ko meri museeqi pe hai wohi Hindustanio ko bhi hai. Unho ne mujhe kum muhabbat nahi di” (Whatever claim the Pakistanis have over my music, the Indians have it in the same measure. They haven’t shown me less love). I highlighted this comment in my piece on him for Dawn. Atal Bihari Vajpaee was the Indian prime minister at the time and my friend Sudhendra Kulkarni, a journalist turned political activist, showed the article to his boss, who sent a very touching letter to the singer, admitting his great admiration for the maestro.

When I decided to write a book on the singer, I was handicapped by the fact that he was in no position to speak and a member of his family, who called the shots, was not cooperating. He wanted his pound of flesh, since he believed I was going to make loads of money at the expense of his near and dear one.

So, the next best alternative was to get music lovers, those who knew him and others in the profession to give their views, which I transcribed. Collecting music, unheard and less heard, was yet another problem but friends helped. It was my earnest desire to show the book Mehdi Hasan: the Man and His Music to him. I took the slim volume to him sometime in 2010. Speechless as he was, all he could utter was “Ahaa” and later said “Shukriya”. There were flickers of smile on his face, and the work I put in for the book was repaid.

Full marks to Dr Aziz Sonawala, an eminent neurologist, who treated the icon from day one and didn’t charge him any fee, as well as the hospital, where he was treated while his bills remained unpaid. A month or so before Mehdi Hassan’s death, the Sindh Government paid five million rupees to the Aga Khan University Hospital to settle a large chunk of the outstanding bills that had gone up to 5.2 million rupees.

Now the question, why did it happen or rather, if I may be allowed to be blunt, who killed Mehdi Hassan? To begin with, he didn’t manage his finances well. He had a large family, two wives (he outlived both of them) and 14 children and education was not a part of the family tradition. His case was a far cry from the one of Noor Jehan, who was treated by the same hospital and who paid all her bills.

Mehdi sahib was not an alcoholic, but he was not a disciplined drinker either. To make matters worse, he was a chain smoker, who also consumed tobacco in his paan.

Some people close to him used him for raising money. Where did the money go is anybody’s guess. Television channels exploited him too by paying his family and making the poor man sit on a wheelchair, suffering physically. Mehdi sahib was also made to listen to junior singers, who in an attempt to sing his famous ghazals and film songs, made a complete mess of immortal numbers – which was a torture of a different kind for the legend.

All said, the great singer, who had also been a generous soul is gone. His contribution to ghazal gayeki will forever remain second to none. May God rest his soul in peace.


Asif Noorani is a Karachi-based journalist and author of Mehdi Hasan: the Man and His Music.


Comments are closed.

Comments (86)

Nurul Alam (Lal)
July 9, 2012 3:21 am
The above comment was 100% correct. I like it. Maestro Mehdi Hassan Sahib was my inspiration in the music line in my life. I will never ever forget him. Allah bless him piece be on him. Nurul Alam (Singer) Toronto, Canada.
Basit Yousuf
June 18, 2012 5:13 am
agreed Immy. well said
Immy
June 17, 2012 12:22 pm
I don't understand what the big deal is. He was a normal human like many others. If he was helped by the sindh government why not help the many poor humans who cannot even afford treatment? It should be a level playing field for all! I don't understand why you people have so much extra love for celebrities. What does a celebrity ever do for you except get rich from your money?
Cobrajock
June 16, 2012 4:28 pm
There can be no doubt that the great Mehdi Hassan was a national asset for Pakistan. When individuals attain that recognition then it is expected that they will be looked after in times of distress, ill health and demise. The article is especially meaningful when we see the rape and deplorable levels of indulgence in luxury by the ruling dacoits, the foreign trips included. Somethings are better left unsaid directly and Noorani Sahib has done just that.
kamal afsar
June 16, 2012 10:04 am
khan sahab's music provided happiness to a huge number of human beings all over the globe. let us not lose sight of the fact that he did not go suddenly, he was very ill for a number of years and what were we doing to alleviate his miseries all this time! even the medical bills were lying unpaid!! the title was appropriate to make us feel guilty for giving back nothing in return except lip service.my friends where does selfserving and shamefulness come in? to my knowledge asif noorani sahab is a gentleman.and for khan sahab all our prayers for a place in jannat. aameen woh kab ka ja chuka sadaen use na do.
Syed Huzaifa
June 16, 2012 7:53 am
Mehdi Hassan was a genius. Nuances he brought to ghazal gayeki is unmatched. I will ask all his fans to buy a book on him written by Mr Asif Noorani. This is an excellent book that sheds light to this great artist. Although its not a complete autobiography it can still quench the thirst for the avid admirers. Moreover, the book is accompanied by two cds with mehdi sahib's tracks. As far as the article is concerned , I would have liked the life of mehdi sahib celebrated rather than his death.
Syed Huzaifa
June 16, 2012 7:51 am
Mehdi Hassan was a genius. Nuances he brought to ghazal gayeki is unmatched. I will ask all his fans to buy a book on him written by Mr Asif Noorani. This is an excellent book that sheds light to this great artist. Although its not a complete autobiography it can still quench the thirst for the avid admirers. Moreover, the book is accompanied by two cds with mehdi sahib's tracks. As far as the article is concerned , I would have liked the life of mehdi sahib celebrated rather than his death. In the midst of all the media attention now perhaps mehdi sahib would have uttered these verses of ahmed faraz: Zehar jo pee chuka hoon tumhi nay to diya hai Ab tum tu zinadagi ki duain mujhay na do
Virkau
June 16, 2012 6:16 am
It can happen to any one. Many artists die paupers in India too. Pakistan may not have so many opportunitis compared to India but that does not diminish love for the artist. Let us not bring disputes in the area of arts.
puchka
June 15, 2012 11:38 pm
absolutely true ..although writer has given facts but he tries to capitalise them n make money on someones death ..
SRINIVAS, MUMBAI
June 15, 2012 1:55 pm
I visited Dawn site to look for a touching article on Mehdi Hassan saab. But was disgusted to read Asif Noorani's article. Please... he was a great singer loved by all in both our countries. Just as Lataji is never considered a hindustani in Pakistan, Mehdi saab and Ghulam ali saab are never considered an outsider and talked in the same breath as all Indian legends. God has decided that his time has come to leave this world. The Almighty has numerous ways of taking a soul back to HIM. Mehdi saab's sufferings leading to his death is one such way. Please leave it at that. May his soul rest in peace!
Syed
June 15, 2012 11:33 am
True! And nice reply
narendera k gupta
June 15, 2012 7:09 am
it pains to me to read the article; the time chosen is not in order. i simply request all admirers of medhi saheb, the world over, to pray to ALLAH, the most merciful to grant peace to his soul and courage to members of family to bear the repairable loss. narendera k gupta vice president dr ustad bismillah khan educational society [registered] delhi
Mohammad Abid Inida
June 15, 2012 5:26 am
"Mehdi Hasan, like Lata Mangeshkar, is a common heritage" I agree but not agree with your title khair let it be. Miyan Asif Noorani Sahab don’t forget you are a journo and this is the cast who believes on facts and figures only have you ever done research about Mr. Saigal/Legendry Bismillah Khan? I would request you to please talk sense about Mr. Saigal/Legendry Bismillah Khan, I am not saying that Pak doesn’t have respect for their artists but this is 100 % true that Pak never paid such attention as they receive in India, there are so many example like Ustad Nusrat Fatah Ali Khan, Chote/Bade Ghulam Ali, Aatif, Shfaqat, Rahat Wgwra Wgera and it such a pleasure for us that list is too long. Bhai let’s not talk about complications, this is the time to DUA for his Maghfirat! ALLAH unhe Jannat ate farmaye!
Mudassir Khan
June 15, 2012 4:47 am
Well said.
Syed Rasheed
June 15, 2012 12:45 am
I am speechless, after I heard of his pass away.Allah bless hin grand him a jannah.
Siraj Khan
June 14, 2012 4:37 pm
Mehdi Hasan, the man may have died yesterday but Mehdi Hasan the artiste had died more than 10 years ago. I cannot recall many articles of any consequence written on him over the last 10 years so - a least not on his singing. There were many about his unpaid hospital bills and that he had become a "vegetable". He had basically dropped from the radar. We should be talking about his life, not death. Dil ke lutne ka sabab poocch rahi hai dunya Yaad aa jaye na aise mein tera naam mujhe http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlX2bxUlGZA
Keshab Kaflay- Nepal
June 14, 2012 1:14 pm
No words to express, except his own offering of his heart touching melody that will always remain close to us. May his soul rest in peace.
Sikander
June 14, 2012 1:02 pm
He was not killed - he has not died - he lives on - through his ghazals
S Pande, India
June 14, 2012 10:11 am
How can anyone say, "I am not sad", when someone called Mehadi Hasan is dead?
Vish
June 14, 2012 9:20 am
Excellent reply.
Admirer
June 14, 2012 8:57 am
Agreed. Author should reconsider this topic.
waseem karachi
June 14, 2012 7:34 am
The title of article is a best example of yellow journalism.........very sad to see that title came from the person who wrote a book on Khan Sahb
Asif Siddiqi
June 14, 2012 7:33 am
Dawn should not have printed this article. This is plainly one man's effort to cash on some one's death. Stealing the contributions of some one on his death and putting lights on things which were not reason of his popularity is another attempt we Pakistani's find so delightful.
Asif Anwar
June 14, 2012 7:27 am
I wasnt expecting DAWN to publish such article. Please show some respect to our legend.
Malik
June 14, 2012 7:08 am
I can still remember the days when me and my friend used to buy new audio cassettes of his songs and used to listen it for hours while giving gestures with hands .. like a classical singer does. In those days, how we used to show our anger? Guy I am angry with u and i m going to break your cassets of mehdi hasan songs and used to express love n affection by giving one in gift. Rest in Peace Great Mehdi Hasan
Aziz Shaikh
June 14, 2012 7:04 am
I am South African, born in SA, My name is Abdool Aziz Shaikh. I have read all the comments above, and it plainly shows that humans celebrate or mourn in their own way. Instead of criticizing each other we should thank Allah for permitting us to share in the genius of Mehdi Hassan. Being a South African, I did not get an opportunity to hear him "live" as Indians in India, Pakistanis or citizens of Britain, did, yet I think that I have the best collection of his songs, audio and Dvd. As I write this piece, I am listening to "Achchi Baat Karo, Achi Baat Suno....." and this should be our lessonb and logo. I am a lover of music and Ghazals and in my opinion would like to repeat what Lata had said, "Mehdi Hassan ke gale mein Bhagwaan Bolta he..." Let's appreciate the man in death as we, who loved him, appreciated him in his life. May Allah grant him the best that he had wished for himself. Salaams to all.
Shahzad Zafar
June 14, 2012 5:52 am
Asif Noorani - you are beneath contempt for tagging your article with such a misleading title.
Zahid
June 14, 2012 5:50 am
Total waste of time and senseless piece of writing. The Author seems more in a hate relationship with him rather then love. I repent to read this article as it reflects the authors tasteless sense of Music and Musician. He will never die as long as the music lovers are alive.
MAdamKhan
June 14, 2012 5:29 am
koii batalaao ki ham batalaaye.n kyaa
Ishrat
June 14, 2012 5:22 am
Very poor Title of the article. Just to capture the attention. Ideal example of on going Yellow Journalism in Pakistan.
Asif Noorani
June 14, 2012 5:15 am
My friend that happened with K.L. Saigal also and more recently with Ustad Bismillah Khan. Let's not be jingoistic. Mehdi Hasan, like Lata Mangeshkar, is a common heritage.
BRR
June 14, 2012 5:13 am
As one who used his gift of music to entertain mankind, and share the beauty of music, his life was indeed very worthwhile and his contributions very laudable. His music and mastery was appreciated in India. May his tribe increase.
Muhammed Ismail Kola
June 14, 2012 5:10 am
Shahenshahe Ghazal is no more but his services to classical music will be always remembered. May Allah keep his soul in peace and give patience to his relatives and fans.
Pradip
June 14, 2012 4:54 am
Amazing comment! I think you should ask for residency in Saudi Arabia!
Syed Ali Tahir Nasir
June 14, 2012 4:33 am
Mehdi Hassan was a great great singer and was admired by President Ayub Khan ,King Of Nepal ,Indian prime minister Attal Bahari Wajpai and many others but he never took any finicial advantages from these rulers as many other artist usually does.
A Subhan Daudpota
June 14, 2012 4:14 am
Agree with you, Mr. Khizr. The title of this article is too inappropriate. This is no time to talk about the self inflicted injuries of a legend who has just left us.
Mohammad A. Khokhar
June 14, 2012 3:31 am
May Allah rests his soul in peace. I wish his MUSIC is always be in our ears while listening to the TUNES our eyes shed some tears acknowledging MEHDI's gifted work solely for US.
Sonya Zaidi
June 14, 2012 2:31 am
Outrageous title - If the editors at Dawn have any decency they will take this down it is not appropriate for this somber occasion!
sam
June 14, 2012 2:29 am
World has lost a legend :( no one can replace his place ever
Najam
June 14, 2012 2:29 am
Well The article was written in a good way and highlighting very important side of Sir Mehdi Hassan Khan Sahib's life BUT I think this was not the right time for it. The people responsible for all this never realized nor they will ever. This was the time to write about his talent, contribution and revolution in Ghazal singing....
Tanvir
June 14, 2012 1:55 am
The answer lies wihin the artice if you read carefully! Hint; there are multiple killers, not just one.
farooq
June 14, 2012 1:09 am
May god rest his soul in peace to M hassan one day over leaders also had to die.
Kris Ramani
June 14, 2012 12:04 am
Title may not be appropriate at this time but the fact is Tobacco and Paan killed him.
Farman
June 13, 2012 11:40 pm
Sensational title for a mediocre article. This writer seems to lack respect for the subjects of his obituraries.
anony
June 13, 2012 11:20 pm
Plz stop taking this article as an opportunity in bashing Pakistan. It's not like india is 'all good' in every aspect of life. Go back to your indian forums.
Nusrat Rizvi
June 13, 2012 10:13 pm
it was back in 1958 when I came home after playing cricket when I was told by my brothers to be very quiet. One of my brothers had just come home from Germany with a Grundig Record player a novelty then. One of the first persons invited to play and record songs was none other than Mehdi Sahib. What he sang that day was a Ghazal by Josh Malihabadi and started with a line like Tu but hai dunya barhaman, Kali Talin Gora Badan. Aye Jan e Man , Janane man. I would pay anything to get my hand on this recording which I remember all those years later as if it was sung today. Nusrat Rizvi 1 Rowayton Court Rowayton, CT 06953 nusratrizvi130@gmail.com
Nusrat Rizvi
June 13, 2012 10:04 pm
A great loss to all music lovers.
Mohammed S Khan
June 13, 2012 9:00 pm
Now Medi Hassan Sahib is no more with us, but in recognition of his unforgetable services in the field of classical singinging, as he had been awarded with the title of Shahinsha-e-Ghazal, it is the formost duty of the Provioncial as well as the Federal Government to establish and give annually the Mehdi Hassan Award to the deserving ghazel singers.
MOHSIN AZIZ
June 13, 2012 8:57 pm
SUCH A GREAT SINGER ......AAH .....
Saima
June 13, 2012 8:56 pm
its shows the brutality of our society. Unfortunately we are loosing our great heroes and treasure of our nation one by one because of not valuing them as much they deserved. We have no substitute of our great legends.