Pakistan’s present day business climate is currently marred by various obstacles and problems, which makes it very unattractive to investors, local and foreign alike.

The power crisis, law-and-order situation and political instability are the ones most notably faced by stakeholders. That being said, there is one more obstacle, which although has received significant attention, it still remains the most ignored amongst them all: bureaucratic bribery.

A few instances come to my mind when I think about the issue, the first: paying a government department peon to forward your file, on top of the stack of the pending hundreds, to the relevant official. This does not mean your issue would be resolved, that’s a different matter altogether, it just means it would be taken up to address. For the solution itself, you will once again have to reach out to the official handling it.

This is just one instance of the major road-block which pulls back Pakistan’s economic growth; bureaucratic inefficiencies.

Its one thing to pay under the table fees to get something done unlawfully, but paying to get through routine bureaucratic processes is something completely different, and much more frustrating. It’s astonishing how expensive it is to just exercise your rights.

For example, getting the transfer of ownership for a vehicle could take you weeks if done the standard way. Some hurdle or the other is inevitably brought up, labeled as a missing requirement or a documentary inconsistency, while if you are willing to pay; the process is a quick, smooth one.

On the commercial front, one could ask a businessman how hard it is to receive his stated tax refund.

Citizens at large have accepted this system. No one contests it for sheer inconvenience, or for the fear of a backlash at a later time.

This system is very deep-rooted, and goes further now than just getting routine tasks completed as for the right price; you can get any work done.

Getting pulled over by the traffic police, and I can count on my fingers the number of people who actually submit documents for a traffic ticket. Why get into the hassle when you can just pay the official a sum lower than the ticket itself and get away with it? Makes sense if you are in a hurry to get to work or home, but on a macro-scale, this is the moral and ethical erosion of our nation.

While it may not seem very disturbing on a personal level; we all push the status quo at some point as we’re not all aiming revolutionaries. But the real nail in our moral coffin is the institutional corruption that it gives rise to.

Ask a lot of businessmen candidly, and they say getting permission for larger projects is an arduous process, especially in the power and construction sectors. The ‘process overheads’ can go as high a 5 per cent on large projects, so if you’re talking about a project worth $100 million, it comes out to be $5 million. In local terms, that’s Rs450 million. So in cost terms, not only are these costs inflationary, but for many ethical foreign corporations there are no basis for justifying such payments. Even on the record-keeping front, it is very hard to explain and validate to external auditors.

Government contractors face the worst brunt. Whenever I hit a bump on an unlevelled, uncompleted road, it not only hurts my car but also any patriotic feeling I may hold. Interrogate a contractor, and he will blame it on the bureaucracy.

“How can we complete a job effectively if 15 to 20 per cent of the budget goes back to the officials?” said a contractor recently, when asked about the poor quality of his work. He stated that if a contractor wants to profit from a job, there is no way he can use quality materials, even if they are prescribed in the tender itself. What is worse, he stated, is the timeline for receiving payments on a completed job.

According to various contractors, a large chunk of the portion paid to officials is when they are in receipt of the final bills for payment. While resource shortages are quoted, hundreds of contractors have to go out of their way to please officials to get their payments released.

The worst aspect of this practice is that people accept this as status-quo, and individuals and businessmen begin to use it to their advantage. Whether it is satisfying a tender with cheaper, poor-quality materials or services, or whether it is paying notice server to state a document as undelivered, an easier way of getting things done, whether right or wrong, is by making an ethical or moral sacrifices and that is somehow more socially acceptable in our society.

As we say in Urdu, “Yeh toh karna hi parta hai” (You cannot avoid doing this). The question is how long will we go on like this? Unless there is a tipping point, things will only get worse. And the thought of worse, frankly, is just plain and simple scary.


Comments are closed.

Comments (30)

Rashi
July 23, 2012 8:57 pm
I agree with you!
Ray
July 4, 2012 7:40 pm
The wonderful part is that Islam is in their heart, which they don't feel the need to show outwardly by keeping a foot long beard. In Pakistan people feel the need to show outwardly their religion while evil and corruption lurks in their heart.
SIR
May 4, 2012 1:52 am
There is an unfortunate but pervading mind set that looks towards the army, or the politicians, or the judiciary, etc. to give people their basic rights, like due process for everything. This empowers these institutions beyond their role essentially as servants of the people, paid to administer the laws made by the people through their elected representatives. Until people take responsibility for their own well-being and stand up for themselves, they will not get their rights. Voltaire said the price of freedom is eternal vigilance, and this applies completely to being vigilant in protecting the rights of and by every individual. The solution really is that simple. Being able to do what is right is always possible because being right has its own irresistible force, provided always that the rights of others are respected, and no short-cuts are desired. Ultimately ordinary people are the real power but they need to recognise that, and use it. Its called character.
CYrus Howell
April 26, 2012 7:46 am
I did pass this blog on to my son who lived in Argentina for three years. Believe it or not, the situation is much, much worse there.
CYrus Howell
April 26, 2012 7:35 am
We can believe that.
CYrus Howell
April 26, 2012 7:33 am
That's just it. If the big shots are stealing ordinary people want their share too. Always remember... In the Halls of Justice, justice is in the halls.
CYrus Howell
April 26, 2012 7:16 am
In theory, Yes.
CYrus Howell
April 26, 2012 7:09 am
The politicians want people to play by the rules - their rules.
umer
April 25, 2012 6:28 am
People act rationally if they have a stake in the sustainability of the system. Once this trust and confidence in the system is lost then you can't stop people from feathering their own nests. Pakistanis have completely lost trust, if they ever had any, in the state's ability to look after them.That is the reason why Pakistani government officials have the urge to amass indecent amounts of wealth.
babar
April 25, 2012 1:04 am
I am sorry to say but each and every individual citizen is to be blamed. They always take the esay way and do not want to make the effort or push back or the effort it takes to go thru proper channel thereby encouraging people to ask for graft and eventually to an extent that they consider it their right. I can give thousands of examples to get all these thinggs done without paying a dime and following the procedures. I did that and have been doing so successfully. So far so good.
jd shami
April 24, 2012 3:31 pm
What was so wonderfull about it????????
Harry Khan
April 24, 2012 10:44 am
Recently I was on holidays in Turkey, found mosques after every two miles but did not see a single man with a beard, now how wonderful is that!
Shafi
April 24, 2012 7:32 am
corruption, corruption and more corruption. It is there from top to bottom. The article unfortunately does not suggest any remedy. How to eliminate the flood of corruption is the question? This cancer had been getting worse over the years and now it is considered a 'normal' way of life in Pakistan. Even the supreme court can not cure it when it involves high profile cases.
Sultan Khan
April 24, 2012 3:16 am
And the burden of the manageable corruption BUILT into the contract cost is transferred towards the poorer sections of the society.
Niazi
April 24, 2012 12:38 am
What are you grumbling about. Officials go for Haj and Umrah on bribery tickets.
Shafi
April 23, 2012 10:31 pm
Corruption, Corruption and more corruption. I purchased two items worth £7.36 from a Pakistani shop and gave him a twenty pound note. He gave me 10 pounds and some change which I put in my pocket without counting. However it occurred to me there and then that he did not give the correct change. I took out the change from my pocket and it was 2 pounds short. Had I moved on, I would not have been able to reclaim. Pakistanis do it everywhere. Sad very sad.
Ron ( Canada )
April 23, 2012 9:58 pm
I too lecture Architectural students in their professional practice class. On the question of handouts and graft the entire class was vehemently against any such practice. I have been in practice for almost thirty years and the question of any form of a bribe has never arisen.
Habib Vora
April 23, 2012 5:53 pm
I agree with Anwar. Unless we take a stand, things will get worse.
Harry Khan
April 23, 2012 5:45 pm
And yet mosques are full of worshippers and the country is the Islamic Republic, may they live in interesting times!
Guest
April 23, 2012 5:01 pm
Peon , Clerk, Supervisor, Group Head, Office boos, etc etc is how the Bribe route takes you in our land of Puers. After Finishing my College Education , as it was ripe quota system i had to get a domicile certificate . Free from the court form available , I had to pay 1 Ruppee to the peon to get me the form (on my 3rd visit each visit costing me Rs 5+ on bus fare) so I paid 1 rs to save 4 9else i had to come 4th time to get it) , Submited my Court's effidavit (help from a friend who happens to be a lawyer available and met me that day ) , Sumitted my forms with the nominal fee and promised to have it ready for collection after 5 days.. Went there No Sir , next week , Went there No Sir Commisionar is not in come after 2 weeks , went there , No sir its with the commisionar for signing , next week pls..... By the time Ramadan set in and it was May / june time frame . Went there fasting offcourse , No Sir come after 3 days ......... i last my temper (some due to fasting more due to loosing full day and RS 5 ever visit since past 5+ weeks of promises. I ASKED The man , what is the problem Please have some pity on me tell me if my documents have problem or you have some problem with me or what ! he looked at me looked at his buddy sitting next to him and told me straight in my eyes ,, go Out and bring me 2 7-Ups cold drink ( forgeting it was ramadan but in my that town lots of hotels operated with just front curtons down and BAU food serving ) , I went out brought 2 bottles gave it to him , while he drank YES SIR in Open court office , he opened his desk , took out the Signed Domicile and gave it to me straight away When I checked on it the date it was signed by the commisioner , it was 4 days after I had submitted ...... So what you can call this sort of work deal , i am ashamed to the core even till to day that I did what i did in that phase of my life but had no choice left because that peace of Scrape document was the need of the hour for me to have any chance of getting any job any where in my land of pures..... I regret that it all my life because I ruined my Fasting for a piece of paper , I had never to use in my real job huntting afterwards .....
Anwar
April 23, 2012 4:58 pm
Those that pay it are just as bad as those that request it.
Tesin
April 23, 2012 4:50 pm
Elementary dear Watson! Stop paying the bribes. Insist on following the proper channel. The author talks about paying the peon so that his file can be seen before others in the queue and that is the problem. Don't circumvent the process question why there are so many pending files in the process and what can I do to help everybody before me get their resolution. Nobody minds waiting if you know that your turn will come and will be treated fairly. If we all help the system instead of taking advantage of it - things will definitely get better.
sid
April 23, 2012 4:47 pm
in india corruption is even more rampant.....else we would have been like china......
Parvez
April 23, 2012 3:04 pm
It is not as bad as U sound. I do business on a smaLL scale. I don't always have to pay to get the contract. However for getting my payment released, it is usually 1-2 %. Sometimes I pay extra to an official but that is BUILT into the contract cost. So while I agree that there is corruption but it is manageable and not as costly as U mention.
Khalid
April 23, 2012 1:28 pm
This article reminds me of an interesting incident narrated by Mr. Hashim Raza, the late Commissioner of Karachi, that one day a relative of his came to him asking for help. He was a civil servant and was caught red handed for taking bribe. Hashim Raza being a good poet as well promptly suggested the solution in a poetic verse that " LEY K RISHWAT PHANS GYA HEY.........DEY KEY RISHWAT CHOOT JA." Those were the early days of this country, the society will look down upon such individuals who demand a bribe, a meager some of money in cash or in kind. Now anyone who does not take a bribe is considered abnormal "PAGAL."
Agha Ata
April 23, 2012 1:15 pm
To a bureaucrat his entire budget not only for this month or this year, but for his entire life depends on, is planned on the bribery he takes. Salary is just a matter of secondary importance.
Maryam Iqbal
April 23, 2012 12:21 pm
I went to a park yesterday and the gate keeper asked me to pay the entrance fees. He did not tear off the recepit from his book but tried to hand over me an already used one. After i inisted on new one, he said the fees is Rs.10. I opened the recepit (which he had folded conveniently) and it was Rs.6 only. So its top to bottom. We need to teach morals in school, TV shows, home and things will improve. Only if we think its important. When talking to one of my colleague regarding this, he said these are minor issues...so we need to realize that its not minor...its the foundation on which a society is build!
Jalbani Baloch
April 23, 2012 11:19 am
I do not see any ray of hope or miracle that may put an end to this rampant corruption. With every passing day, the menace of corruption is pervading in society and there seems to be no seriousness on the part of relevant government agencies to suppress the corruption. I fear if this situation is not corrected, it will give way to disillusionment, and the whole society will be gripped in the mire of trouble, where lawlessness, extortion, terrorism will be the order of day.
Farhad F
April 23, 2012 11:04 am
I just guest lectured at Northwestern University in Chicago on the same subject. I was addressing a class of about 50 young Industrial Engineering students, all final year students. The students came from all walks of life and probably had every continent represented a few times over. I posed the situation we often find ourselves in living in South Asia having to confront whether to pay a hand out or wait patiently to get something done. When I proposed a hand out of $40 USD to get a passport expedited, everyone agreed that they would pay it. When I proposed a $200,000 hand out to get a Civil Engineering project from govt. to my horror more than half of the class said they would willingly pay to get the work. I don't think Pakistani's or Indian's are inherently or genetically flawed in this respect, it seems that the whole world is losing its moral fiber one day at a time, because societies have stopped rewarding upstanding moral character and hence over generations, it is has become less important to people. Sad, across the board.
vijay
April 23, 2012 10:12 am
Pakistans present day- Write India inplace of pakistan, and everything said is ditto.